Rate the Oais albums

[daveybaker]

definitely maybe
morning glory
masterplan

All the others are terrible

[Moon Dawg]

Definitely Maybe A-
(What's the Story) Morning Glory A-
Be Here Now B+
The Masterplan A-
Standing on the Shoulders of Giants C
Heathen Chemistry C+
Don't Believe the Truth B
Dig Out Your Soul B

The first three are all significant musical and cultural artifacts of their time. An upswing near the end. Stop the Clocks was an odd comp btw.

[Ironic Karma]

Always been one of the bands that I really liked when I was younger than released later, "Wow this does suck".

(What's the Story) Morning Glory? is the only enjoyable piece of music that I can kind of listen to now.