Best Ever Albums

Re: Connecting Forums and Albums

albummaster — Mon, 21 Sep 2026 16:08:15 GMT

Author: albummaster

Posted: 09/21/2026 20:08

Romanelli wrote:

I have a suggestion for album pages and forum mentions.

Showing the most recent forum mentions of an album is great. But if you select See All, if the album is a top album, the list becomes massive. And there's no way to collapse it back down to the original three mentions.

But my suggestion is this. The forum mentions are mostly redundant. It shows every Album Of The Day post, every What Album Are You Listening To post, every Monthly Overall Chart Movements (if the album moved...some move VERY frequently), every Chart Of The Day. Would it be possible to show only the most RECENT time it appears in one of those threads, instead of every single one?

Example: The album Blur by Blur shows 124 post mentions. Of those, it shows up 68 times in posts titled Monthly Overall Chart Movements. And it shows up 47 times in What Album Are You Listening To. If those were pared down to just the most recent one each, the 124 post mentions list would be cut down to just 11...a much more manageable and less redundant view. Is that a possibility?

Thanks!

Thanks for the idea. There’s coincidently a forthcoming site update (tomorrow) which will address most of this. If an album is mentioned multiple times in a thread, only one occurrence of the mention will be shown (with a count to indicate the rest). This functionality will continue to be refined once tomorrow’s update is out of the way (and extended to include grouping of posts of the same type).

(EDIT: Site update published this morning combines mentions from a single topic. Next site update will combine mentions spread over multiple topics of the same type such as CoTD etc).

Re: Connecting Forums and Albums

Romanelli — Mon, 21 Sep 2026 15:58:15 GMT

Author: Romanelli

Posted: 09/21/2026 19:58

I have a suggestion for album pages and forum mentions.

Showing the most recent forum mentions of an album is great. But if you select See All, if the album is a top album, the list becomes massive. And there's no way to collapse it back down to the original three mentions.

But my suggestion is this. The forum mentions are mostly redundant. It shows every Album Of The Day post, every What Album Are You Listening To post, every Monthly Overall Chart Movements (if the album moved...some move VERY frequently), every Chart Of The Day. Would it be possible to show only the most RECENT time it appears in one of those threads, instead of every single one?

Example: The album Blur by Blur shows 124 post mentions. Of those, it shows up 68 times in posts titled Monthly Overall Chart Movements. And it shows up 47 times in What Album Are You Listening To. If those were pared down to just the most recent one each, the 124 post mentions list would be cut down to just 11...a much more manageable and less redundant view. Is that a possibility?

Thanks!

Re: Connecting Forums and Albums

Johnnyo — Wed, 24 Jun 2026 07:38:27 GMT

Author: Johnnyo

Posted: 06/24/2026 11:38

albummaster wrote:

Thank you for posting, and I enjoy your threads. I hope more people can join in and that forum activity picks up a bit. Unfortunately, we're now entering the usual summer lull when activity tends to drop off slightly, although the site as a whole is busier than it was this time last year.

I'm definitely in favour of ideas that might help improve forum activity. Creating more of a bridge between the forums and the rest of the site is something I've considered before. For example, when someone views an album or artist page, it might be possible to surface related forum discussions.

One challenge is that not every album or artist will have a dedicated discussion, and even when they do, the conversation may no longer be active. There's also the possibility of forum posts mentioning an album only in passing, making them less relevant to the page being viewed. We'd also want to be careful not to cannibalise album comments, so any forum integration would need to complement the existing features rather than compete with them.

That said, even something as simple as a more prominent link to relevant forum discussions along the lines you mentioned could help bring people from the rest of the site into the forums, and it's certainly something I'd be happy to explore.

Thanks AM. All valid points. I think that Anything to make the site more interconnected will drive more discussion and interaction has to be a good thing. I'm happy to be a sounding board for any ideas that you might want to develop.

Re: Connecting Forums and Albums

albummaster — Wed, 24 Jun 2026 06:56:35 GMT

Author: albummaster

Posted: 06/24/2026 10:56

Thank you for posting, and I enjoy your threads. I hope more people can join in and that forum activity picks up a bit. Unfortunately, we're now entering the usual summer lull when activity tends to drop off slightly, although the site as a whole is busier than it was this time last year.

I'm definitely in favour of ideas that might help improve forum activity. Creating more of a bridge between the forums and the rest of the site is something I've considered before. For example, when someone views an album or artist page, it might be possible to surface related forum discussions.

One challenge is that not every album or artist will have a dedicated discussion, and even when they do, the conversation may no longer be active. There's also the possibility of forum posts mentioning an album only in passing, making them less relevant to the page being viewed. We'd also want to be careful not to cannibalise album comments, so any forum integration would need to complement the existing features rather than compete with them.

That said, even something as simple as a more prominent link to relevant forum discussions along the lines you mentioned could help bring people from the rest of the site into the forums, and it's certainly something I'd be happy to explore.

Connecting Forums and Albums

Johnnyo — Wed, 24 Jun 2026 06:22:20 GMT

Author: Johnnyo

Posted: 06/24/2026 10:22

Hi AM. Not even sure if this is possible but I'm thinking of ways to drive traffic to forums

So, I post at least two forums a month of a chosen album from my listening groups, usually 60's or 70's albums. There used to be a lot of traffic going on but, over the last few months it has dried up pretty much completely to the point where I'm wondering whether there's really any point in continuing with them as I'm basically talking to myself.

Anyway, I was wondering whether there might be a way of attaching a link to a forum discussion somewhere within the album page so, you might have a link at the top of the album page say "if you are interested in a broader discussion about this album clink here" sort of thing

It might generate more traffic to forums.

Let me know what you thing

Johnnyo