Best Ever Albums

Re: The Chronology Of Heavy Rock / Metal

Repo — Wed, 4 Nov 2026 09:41:13 GMT

Author: Repo

Posted: 11/04/2026 14:41

Johnnyo wrote:

You've highlighted one of my dilemmas when I started this thread. Hendrix immediately came to my mind but I don't really considered him Heavy Rock otherwise I might have gone with Are You Experienced as the start of it all. Jimi is an interesting one as I've always though of him as being Psychedelic Blues but it's still a totally valid pick.

Cream? Love 'em. I'd go with the Heavy Blues (where's the line between blues and rock though?) label for them but others will say, that's a great shout.

maybe it did all start in 1966 with Fresh Cream. Another album I'm going to be pulling out over the next few days.

I can see this thread dictating my listening for a few days to come. Love It and all of the varied and interesting engagement. Exactly what i had hoped for when I set it up

Keep it coming

I think the pivotal transition can be heard by comparing & contrasting ...

Blues Breakers (1966) by John Mayall & Eric Clapton

VERSUS

Fresh Cream (1966) by Cream

So THIS - Blues Breakers vs. Fresh Cream - will be my first battle. I'll listen to both over the next day or so and try come up with 3 elements that I feel marked the creation of a new sound/genre.

Re: The Chronology Of Heavy Rock / Metal

Johnnyo — Wed, 4 Nov 2026 06:58:46 GMT

Author: Johnnyo

Posted: 11/04/2026 11:58

Repo wrote:

MadhattanJack wrote:

I think what's happened over the years is that if you say Black Sabbath's 1970 debut LP was "the first heavy metal album," you get fewer arguments on internet forums, so people have just settled into doing that.

So... then people started getting into arguing over "what was the first heavy metal song ever released," which is a lot less contentious because there's less at stake culturally (especially between the US and the UK). Personally I'd go with "Purple Haze," but there are legitimate arguments for "In-a-Gadda-da-Vida," Blue Cheer's "Summertime Blues," and Steppenwolf's "Born to be Wild" too.

Some of those arguments don't make sense to everyone — for example, there are people who will tell you that "real" (i.e., legitimate) heavy metal guitar distortion has to be either an overdriven tube amp or an overdrive effect pedal, and such pedals didn't exist until 1972 or so — Hendrix used a Fuzz Face, which was a different type of circuit, and the others either used similar fuzz pedals or "Rat" type distortion pedals, which back then sounded closer to the opening riff from "Satisfaction" by the Rolling Stones. Another example is what I call the "doom argument," whereby you can't call something "heavy metal" unless the overarching mood/atmosphere of the band, or at least the album, is doom-laden, apocalyptic, scary, quasi-Satanic, and/or evil-sounding. When that argument is accepted, the Sabs' proponents pretty much always win.

I saw a thread somewhere (not on this site) that despite their not being so doomy-gloomy, the Yardbirds would have gone down as the inventors of "heavy metal" as early as 1965 if the people producing and mixing their early records had let them record the guitars the way they (or at least Jeff Beck and Jimmy Page) wanted. But oh well, a classic case of "could'a would'a should'a," I guess! :|

Interesting parameters. I sorta go with the "I know it when I hear it" school and to me, the most logical starting point for HEAVY ROCK is, and quite easily I might add, Cream & Jimi Hendrix. Those two are my ground zero with The Yardbirds, Manfred Mann and as Roman pointed out heavy Garage Rock like The Monks & The Sonics & The Remains being a decent launching pad. But, yeah, it would be unseemly not to start with...

Fresh Cream (1966) by Cream

Disraeli Gears (1967) by Cream

Are You Experienced (1967) by The Jimi Hendrix Experience

Axis: Bold As Love (1967) by The Jimi Hendrix Experience

These four albums are ground zero imo.

You've highlighted one of my dilemmas when I started this thread. Hendrix immediately came to my mind but I don't really considered him Heavy Rock otherwise I might have gone with Are You Experienced as the start of it all. Jimi is an interesting one as I've always though of him as being Psychedelic Blues but it's still a totally valid pick.

Cream? Love 'em. I'd go with the heavy blues (where's the line between blues and rock though?) label for them but others will say, that's a great shout.

maybe it did all start in 1966 with Fresh Cream. Another album I'm going to be pulling out over the next few days.

I can see this thread dictating my listening for a few days to come. Love It and all of the varied and interesting engagement. Exactly what i had hoped for when I set it up

Keep it coming

Re: The Chronology Of Heavy Rock / Metal

Johnnyo — Wed, 4 Nov 2026 06:48:41 GMT

Author: Johnnyo

Posted: 11/04/2026 11:48

Repo wrote:

I agree it's Iron Butterfly, BUT ...

Heavy (1968) by Iron Butterfly

... came first and is just as..., well, ... Heavy! And it's a GREAT album! 😈

Heavy was released on January 22nd of 1968.

Nevermind. I'm an idiot and really should have double-checked dates before throwing my hat in the ring. Your first offering, Johnnyo ...

Vincebus Eruptum (1968) by Blue Cheer

... is the correct one.

Vincebus Eruptum was released on January 16th of 1968 thereby beating Heavy by one week. It's also a great album! Now I'm going to have to have a battle - Heavy vs. Vincebus Eruptum - to decide which one's better! 8)

What's one week between friends? We need to talk about both albums at some point. Pulling Heavy out for a listen

Your comment about Heavy v Vincebus Erutptum means that I might need to listen to them back to back. It's a hard life!

Re: The Chronology Of Heavy Rock / Metal

Johnnyo — Wed, 4 Nov 2026 06:44:51 GMT

Author: Johnnyo

Posted: 11/04/2026 11:44

Repo wrote:

I agree it's Iron Butterfly, BUT ...

Heavy (1968) by Iron Butterfly

... came first and is just as..., well, ... Heavy! And it's a GREAT album! 😈

Heavy was released on January 22nd of 1968.

Oooh, yes, of course it did. What a great heavy rock album that was. Two great albums in 1968 by Iron Butterfly. You've prompted me to pull Heavy out for a listen. Nice one

Re: The Chronology Of Heavy Rock / Metal

Johnnyo — Wed, 4 Nov 2026 06:41:33 GMT

Author: Johnnyo

Posted: 11/04/2026 11:41

Romanelli wrote:

Recorded in 1966.

Link

Interesting. I'd never heard this before and thanks for sharing Rom.

Doesn't really tick my personal boxes for Heavy Rock (but of course that's just me and other will undoubtedly disagree) but you can hear some elements that subsequent bands might have picked up and developed.

Nice track though non the less and great to hear it

Re: The Chronology Of Heavy Rock / Metal

Johnnyo — Wed, 4 Nov 2026 06:36:33 GMT

Author: Johnnyo

Posted: 11/04/2026 11:36

MadhattanJack wrote:

Some interesting thoughts there and I've heard the same argument / proposition about The Yardbirds. I am going to put forward Truth by Jeff Beck as a great heavy rock album. We should also discuss Blue Cheer and Summertime Blues at some point. Born To Be Wild? Interesting pick.

It's an interesting point about what defines Heavy Metal, which is sort of why I thought lumping Heavy Rock and Metal together was a good option as I think that there is a lot of blurring of the lines. The Doom argument is also very relevant. Can a Metal album exist without that specific criteria? I guess we might find out here as the thread develops

Thanks for engaging with the thread. I think that it could be a good one

Re: The Chronology Of Heavy Rock / Metal

Repo — Tue, 3 Nov 2026 20:15:17 GMT

Author: Repo

Posted: 11/04/2026 01:15

MadhattanJack wrote:

Re: The Chronology Of Heavy Rock / Metal

Repo — Tue, 3 Nov 2026 19:26:57 GMT

Author: Repo

Posted: 11/04/2026 00:26

Repo wrote:

I agree it's Iron Butterfly, BUT ...

Heavy (1968) by Iron Butterfly

... came first and is just as..., well, ... Heavy! And it's a GREAT album! 😈

Heavy was released on January 22nd of 1968.

Re: The Chronology Of Heavy Rock / Metal

Repo — Tue, 3 Nov 2026 19:17:31 GMT

Author: Repo

Posted: 11/04/2026 00:17

Romanelli wrote:

Recorded in 1966.

Link

Great choice, but it's pretty much straight up EXCELLENT garage rock. I would put it in the same genre as The Sonics and The Monks. Love all three.

Re: The Chronology Of Heavy Rock / Metal

Repo — Tue, 3 Nov 2026 19:11:05 GMT

Author: Repo

Posted: 11/04/2026 00:11

I agree it's Iron Butterfly, BUT ...

Heavy (1968) by Iron Butterfly

... came first and is just as..., well, ... Heavy! And it's a GREAT album! 😈

Heavy was released on January 22nd of 1968.

Re: The Chronology Of Heavy Rock / Metal

Romanelli — Tue, 3 Nov 2026 19:00:10 GMT

Author: Romanelli

Posted: 11/04/2026 00:00

Recorded in 1966.

Link

Re: The Chronology Of Heavy Rock / Metal

MadhattanJack — Tue, 3 Nov 2026 17:01:20 GMT

Author: MadhattanJack

Posted: 11/03/2026 22:01

I think what's happened over the years is that if you say Black Sabbath's 1970 debut LP was "the first heavy metal album," you get fewer arguments on internet forums, so people have just settled into doing that.

So... then people started getting into arguing over "what was the first heavy metal song ever released," which is a lot less contentious because there's less at stake culturally (especially between the US and the UK). Personally I'd go with "Purple Haze," but there are legitimate arguments for "In-a-Gadda-da-Vida," Blue Cheer's "Summertime Blues," and Steppenwolf's "Born to be Wild" too.

Some of those arguments don't make sense to everyone — for example, there are people who will tell you that "real" (i.e., legitimate) heavy metal guitar distortion has to be either an overdriven tube amp or an overdrive effect pedal, and such pedals didn't exist until 1972 or so — Hendrix used a Fuzz Face, which was a different type of circuit, and the others either used similar fuzz pedals or "Rat" type distortion pedals, which back then sounded closer to the opening riff from "Satisfaction" by the Rolling Stones. Another example is what I call the "doom argument," whereby you can't call something "heavy metal" unless the overarching mood/atmosphere of the band, or at least the album, is doom-laden, apocalyptic, scary, quasi-Satanic, and/or evil-sounding. When that argument is accepted, the Sabs' proponents pretty much always win.

I saw a thread somewhere (not on this site) that despite their not being so doomy-gloomy, the Yardbirds would have gone down as the inventors of "heavy metal" as early as 1965 if the people producing and mixing their early records had let them record the guitars the way they (or at least Jeff Beck and Jimmy Page) wanted. But oh well, a classic case of "could'a would'a should'a," I guess! 😐

Re: The Chronology Of Heavy Rock / Metal

Johnnyo — Tue, 3 Nov 2026 04:47:08 GMT

Author: Johnnyo

Posted: 11/03/2026 09:47

In-A-Gadda-Da-Vida (Or In The Garden Of Eden)

It's impossible to ignore the title track. Without it, the album would have been just OK however, this track is just amazing.

It has its flaws of course. I’m not a fan of drum solo’s, maybe a 20 second one is OK but here we have 2 and a half minutes. Yawn! So, any track that’s over 17 minutes long will have but overall, it’s a phenomenal track.

Is it heavy metal? Possibly not quite but there are elements of metal in here. Is it Psych? Most definitely. There’s also a big chunk of the blues in here.

A great jam of a track. To me it feels like the band are improvising the track as they go along each taking turns to impress. I’m sure that it’s not that way at all and that it was totally planned out but you get that feeling and that’s a good thing.

Re: The Chronology Of Heavy Rock / Metal

Johnnyo — Tue, 3 Nov 2026 04:42:53 GMT

Author: Johnnyo

Posted: 11/03/2026 09:42

Rather than starting with

Vincebus Eruptum (1968) by Blue Cheer

I'm going for

In-A-Gadda-Da-Vida (1968) by Iron Butterfly

I'm not sure that this can actually be called heavy rock in it's purest sense and ultimately it's a disappointing album for me however, it's the title track, which is a Bonafede heavy rock classic, this album would have disappeared into the foothills of rock history.

It does have some other decent tracks, Most Anything You Want and My Mirage are decent tracks and Are You Happy? Is great but the rest of the album is rather ho-hum

More on the title track next

Re: The Chronology Of Heavy Rock / Metal

Johnnyo — Tue, 3 Nov 2026 04:37:58 GMT

Author: Johnnyo

Posted: 11/03/2026 09:37

1968

The Chronology Of Heavy Rock / Metal

Johnnyo — Tue, 3 Nov 2026 04:36:14 GMT

Author: Johnnyo

Posted: 11/03/2026 09:36

For the sake of this thread, my contention is that heavy rock / metal started in 1968 with

Vincebus Eruptum (1968) by Blue Cheer

I know that there will be those amongst you who will have a different starting point and I’m sure that there will be valid arguments that I’m not right but for the premise that I’m going to propose, we need a starting point, so here it is.

There are threads for a variety of different genre, jazz, prog, country to name just three but, apart from the very successful Rank ‘Em Ozzy Osbourne, there are very few if any (that I’ve seen) relating to the heavy side of rock.

So, what I’m proposing is that we take each year, starting with 1968 and talk about the great heavy rock and metal albums that came out in that year and then move onto the next year and so on.

This could fall on its face and if so, fair enough, but if you are up for the discussion, so am I.