Nationality of artists

Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5  Next
View previous topic :: View next topic
Author Message
albummaster
Janitor


Gender: Male
Location: Spain
Site Admin

  • #31
  • Posted: 05/09/2022 07:14
  • Post subject:
  • Reply with quote
Hayden wrote:
Just tossing it out there—

We have the (somewhat new) 'Individual/Collaboration' option (which, I still don't quite understand the point of unfortunately). How about if the artist falls under the 'Collaboration' category, a second nationality becomes available? This new collaboration—


Limen by KMRU & Aho Ssan

—by KMRU (Kenya) and Aho Ssan (France) is classified 'mixed' strictly because it's a collaboration, even though both artists are given their nationality on our site when solo.

What if the collaboration option linked each solo artist (i.e. KMRU & Aho Ssan) instead of mixing them into a single entity (KMRU & Aho Ssan), which would then classify the act as Fr/Ke?

If that makes sense.

The collaboration/individual flag allows individual artists to be assigned to collaborations, so you can see what other acts an artist belonged to etc (e.g. obvious example of Paul McCartney being a member of Beatles & Wings etc, as well as being a solo artist). At the moment, BEA restricts membership of collaborations to those artists that already exist on the site, so not all artists have their entire membership listed (there are quite a few gaps), otherwise nationality could be derived from its members, but it would also require those artists to be fully populated with data, which is often not the case. There are also examples of collaborations with a lot more than two nationalities, and this where a dual nationality system would start to break down.
Back to top
  • Visit poster's website
  • View user's profile
  • Send private message
SD100852




United Kingdom

  • #32
  • Posted: 06/08/2022 15:07
  • Post subject:
  • Reply with quote
ForegroundNoise wrote:
Quote:
I think it's probably better if BEA avoids listing multiple nationalities on any artist. Both because it significantly complicates data moderation, and because "nationality" can be subjective. For bands, it's more about the complication e.g. AM's example where there's a band with 5-6 members of different nationalities. For solo artists, Romanelli's John Lennon example is probably the most egregious (and I agree that we're heading in that direction), but consider Tina Turner who renounced her US citizenship in 2013 but hasn't released a (non-compilation) record since way before then; for all intents and purposes I'd consider her to be from the US.


Just to respond to this and to add a suggestion I've not seen here yet:

1. I agree that Mixed Nationality should be treated as a last resort, though I personally disagree with the idea that we should "avoid listing multiple nationalities on any artist". For individuals real-life nationality and identity is often complicated and diverse, and I think our database should reflect this (I also disagree with Romanelli that listing identity is a "luxury"; on the contrary I think it's extremely important to be mindful of the demographics of our musical tastes, especially given how Anglo-American centric us westerners can end up being in our listening habits).

2. For collectives, I personally think we should institute the same guidelines as awards bodies such as the Mercury Prize, where an artist is deemed eligible if more than 50% of its members are British/Irish. This would mean bands such as White Lion listed above would be classed as American, Arcade Fire classed as Canadian etc., even if some individual members might have a different nationality. In cases where the nationality is an even split, the dual nationality function can be used (once it's integrated onto the site), with Mixed Nationality reserved for rare cases where there are multiple nationalities present and no majority can be determined.


I cannot agree more in regards to the importantance of listing nationalities on here, one think I enjoy doing on here is looking out to see who are the top acts and albums from certain countries are and again it's always a good thing to be mindful of the demographics of our music tastes (such as say finding out how many albums I've listened to have been from acts originating in non-English speaking countries). It could also highlight the achievements and influence some countries have had on the popular music scene (for example how many highly rated albums have been made by Icelandic acts considering the population of that country is only around 360,000).
Back to top
  • Visit poster's website
  • View user's profile
  • Send private message
albummaster
Janitor


Gender: Male
Location: Spain
Site Admin

  • #33
  • Posted: 04/27/2023 08:54
  • Post subject:
  • Reply with quote
Just resurrecting this thread (yet) again as current guidelines still resulting in too many artists being deemed 'Mixed' (which we all agree is undesirable), so we need to refine the wording to make it less ambiguous, so the guidelines produce expected/logical results without ambiguity.

It feels like I'm making rules up on the fly, but just thinking if we are having problems deciding between 'mixed' or a specific nationality, a series of further tests could be applied e.g. for collaborations, was the collaboration formed in the same country as the majority of its members?

Are there any other tests that could be added to the guidelines to better able BEA to self-govern? Nationality assignment is the only current area that is consistently causing issues with data moderation (the rest of the site runs fairly smoothly). Or is this just making things even more complicated, and could guidelines be simplified to achieve the same result? (Nationality guidelines absolutely need to change, but do they need tweaking or completely rewriting to make them work?).
Back to top
  • Visit poster's website
  • View user's profile
  • Send private message
MadhattanJack
I mean, metal is okay, but...


Gender: Male
United States

  • #34
  • Posted: 04/27/2023 09:23
  • Post subject:
  • Reply with quote
This is about Rina Sawayama, isn't it?

Sometimes you just can't win... Sad

I'd hate to think your only way out of situations like that is to retool the database to make Nationality a 1:Many table off of Artists, because that couldn't possibly be worth the development effort. But either way, I doubt many people are putting in "Mixed" because they think that's fundamentally more desirable in situations where just one out of four or five band members is from a different country than everyone else. (I know I haven't been doing that, at least.)
Back to top
  • Visit poster's website
  • View user's profile
  • Send private message
albummaster
Janitor


Gender: Male
Location: Spain
Site Admin

  • #35
  • Posted: 04/27/2023 13:15
  • Post subject:
  • Reply with quote
MadhattanJack wrote:
This is about Rina Sawayama, isn't it?

Sometimes you just can't win... Sad

No, it's not - although that's one of many that have been difficult to moderate - Elizabeth Colour Wheel is the latest instance.

MadhattanJack wrote:
I'd hate to think your only way out of situations like that is to retool the database to make Nationality a 1:Many table off of Artists, because that couldn't possibly be worth the development effort. But either way, I doubt many people are putting in "Mixed" because they think that's fundamentally more desirable in situations where just one out of four or five band members is from a different country than everyone else. (I know I haven't been doing that, at least.)

We came full circle with multi-nationality earlier in the thread, and it's not workable as a solution (ok for some cases, but falls over for others). Guidelines are causing confusion, so it's nobody's fault but my own that there are oddities.
Back to top
  • Visit poster's website
  • View user's profile
  • Send private message
Romanelli
Bone Swah


Gender: Male
Location: Broomfield, Colorado
United States
Moderator

  • #36
  • Posted: 04/27/2023 14:50
  • Post subject:
  • Reply with quote
My opinion on this...

I think that with bands, we're trying to think in terms of the nationality of the individual members. If we go down that road, then nationality is going to become considerably less useful. The more we use "mixed", the less useful it is. If we use individual nationalities to determine what to use for bands...we'll have Fleetwood Mac (a UK band) as mixed. Metallica (a US band) as mixed. White Lion (a US band). Arguments will pop up for Van Halen, The Band, Tom Petty & The Heartbreakers (they had a British drummer for over 20 years). The bass player for The Black Crowes for over 20 years is from Germany. I could go on...for hours.

My point is that we're making things far too difficult for such a small thing. If having nationalities on your charts is important to you, then I would think that you (I know it's true for me) would want as few Mixed Nationality artists as possible. Mixed Nationality is the BEA equivalent of "Other".

For the examples above: Fleetwood Mac was formed in the UK. Metallica was formed in the US. White Lion was formed in the US. Van Halen (US). The Band (Canada). TP & The Heartbreakers (US). The Black Crowes (US). Simplify, and in the process, more bands will have a distinct nationality based on where the BAND (not necessarily all individuals) are from. It's not our jobs to be that detailed and to make those determinations. And all we have to show nationality is a single flag. We don't have the tools to worry about a band from the UK that was formed in the UK with a singer who was born in Zanzibar (Freddie Mercury became a UK citizen at age 23.) Queen is, and should be, flagged as UK.

For individual artists: where the artist's career has been based. We could plant the mixed flag on so many people...again, labelling them as basically "other". And we have been. Born in one country, now in another shouldn't mean dual nationality on BEA. Keep it simple, and give them a nationality. We're not insulting anyone by assigning a distinct flag. Simply assign a country in which their career is based. I think we're using "place of birth" and what the artist claims their nationality to be (which can be, I have seen, exaggerated), and complicating things rather than saying, "this artist, based on their career, is from _____." This isn't a site to determine those things in so much detail.

Mixed Nationality, IMO, should always be the last resort. A duo with one from US & one from UK? Absolutely. I would estimate that most individuals can be assigned a country. I would say that most bands can be as well (there would be exceptions...but last resort). I think that we should be looking for ways to NOT used Mixed Nationality instead of trying to find reasons to assign it. 11% of my overall chart are flagged as, basically, "other". On the overall chart? 29% (Top 1000). To me, that is not helpful. At all.

Maybe multiple flags can be used? I know that would be some work for AM. And that would only be really effective if only one flag per artist was designated as primary...except for tru Mixed Nationality cases.

Thank you for the opportunity to voice an opinion on this. Bottom line (for me): I don't want my charts littered with artists designated as "other". I don't know why anyone else would, either. We're not offending anyone by assigning a flag so we can see on our charts where an artist is from. Let's simplify, not try to re-invent the world of artist nationalities.
_________________
May we all get to heaven
'Fore the devil knows we're dead...
Back to top
  • Visit poster's website
  • View user's profile
  • Send private message
  • Visit poster's website
MadhattanJack
I mean, metal is okay, but...


Gender: Male
United States

  • #37
  • Posted: 04/27/2023 20:09
  • Post subject:
  • Reply with quote
albummaster wrote:
...that's one of many that have been difficult to moderate - Elizabeth Colour Wheel is the latest instance.

Elizabeth Colour Wheel...? They've only made one album, and honestly it's not even all that good. And I agree with Romanelli - that's an American band who just happen to have a Chinese singer, who mostly resides in the USA. (Though to be fair, considering the extreme pretentiousness that's on that page I just linked to, I can see why some Americans would rather have them show up under a different flag.)

I don't know if this is a "popular" position to take, but the best thing for BEA to do in such cases is to avoid sticking out like a sore thumb among other websites who are all saying basically the same thing, even if the other websites are ostensibly "wrong." In ECW's case, there's no Wikipedia article, so the next-best thing (not that a Wikipedia article is all that great) is probably Discogs, and all three related Discogs pages essentially have her/them as based in the USA:

...So, to me, having ECW the band listed as "Mixed" only makes sense if we assume the band came into existence the moment Lane Shi was born. Also, this "official capitalization" stuff is not just pretentious, it's a selfishly-put burden on others (i.e., us), so you know, a big "nyaah nyaah nyaah" on them, I say.
Back to top
  • Visit poster's website
  • View user's profile
  • Send private message
MadhattanJack
I mean, metal is okay, but...


Gender: Male
United States

  • #38
  • Posted: 04/27/2023 20:57
  • Post subject:
  • Reply with quote
By the way, just in the last hour after posting that (while I was mowing the lawn, in fact) I thought of four bands just off the top of my head that are much better-known than Elizabeth Colour Wheel, but have just about the exact same nationality scenario: Garbage, That Petrol Emotion, Deerhoof, and Asobi Seksu. None of these are listed on BEA as "Mixed Nationality," and personally I would consider it rather absurd if any of them were. (I'm probably going to think of a few more over the course of the next several hours, but hopefully that's enough precedent for now.)

(Admittedly, I also thought of a counter-example, namely Miami Sound Machine — but again, I would classify them as American, not Cuban, even though Gloria Estefan was born in Havana.)
Back to top
  • Visit poster's website
  • View user's profile
  • Send private message
melisandre




Location: the swamp

  • #39
  • Posted: 04/28/2023 11:03
  • Post subject:
  • Reply with quote
I guess we could simplify things by deciding that the nationality of a band is where they formed rather than where they reside. I mean, they all met somewhere initially after all.

There are still issues with bands like Fleetwood Mac, who are a UK band, who effectively reformed in America and became more famous after that. But I think that perspective would resolve a lot of issues anyway.

Helpfully, Allmusic states where a band formed rather than where they are from so this site could be a good reference point if we go with this idea.
Back to top
  • Visit poster's website
  • View user's profile
  • Send private message
albummaster
Janitor


Gender: Male
Location: Spain
Site Admin

  • #40
  • Posted: 04/28/2023 18:16
  • Post subject:
  • Reply with quote
Romanelli wrote:
I think that with bands, we're trying to think in terms of the nationality of the individual members. If we go down that road, then nationality is going to become considerably less useful. The more we use "mixed", the less useful it is... I would think that you (I know it's true for me) would want as few Mixed Nationality artists as possible. Mixed Nationality is the BEA equivalent of "Other".

Definitely agreed on that. Country of formation should be a factor to get to the 'common sense' results we want to see, although it's not at the moment, as entirely based on membership right now (& some collaborations are formed abroad etc). There are also plenty of legitimate multi-nationality individuals. The only factual way of defining a country would be to use country of birth which doesn't the capture softer factors of where somebody grew up etc (nationality being what we are currently determining). I agree we would not be insulting people on purpose by assigning one flag, but if it's the wrong one (as far as that person is concerned), then something doesn't sit right with that (although might be the easiest option to administer). I really don't want to over-complicate things, although seem to be doing well at that, and definitely this is one aspect that has truly spun out of control. I definitely agree that Mixed should be used a last resort, where there is clearly no clear argument either way, but need to make things so simple/clear-cut, debate isn't needed .

MadhattanJack wrote:
I don't know if this is a "popular" position to take, but the best thing for BEA to do in such cases is to avoid sticking out like a sore thumb among other websites who are all saying basically the same thing, even if the other websites are ostensibly "wrong.

Definitely agree.

melisandre wrote:
I guess we could simplify things by deciding that the nationality of a band is where they formed rather than where they reside. I mean, they all met somewhere initially after all.... Helpfully, Allmusic states where a band formed rather than where they are from so this site could be a good reference point if we go with this idea.

Country of formation/country of birth would be the simplest thing to do (Occam's razor), and the field would become country of origin rather than nationality. Probably need to think about what sort of impact that might have on existing data and take into account the current burden of the existing mechanism. Right now, I'd be strongly in favour of changing it if it unblocks the existing difficulties of policing the current system and maybe this is what should be done.
Back to top
  • Visit poster's website
  • View user's profile
  • Send private message
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic
All times are GMT
Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5  Next
Page 4 of 5


 

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Similar Topics
Topic Author Forum
Various Artists nationality undefined Suggestions
Nationality of artists? RasmV Suggestions
Mixed Nationality videoheadcleaner Suggestions
nationality and music Guest Music
Band nationality 19loveless91 Suggestions

 
Back to Top