The Grunge Thread

Goto page Previous  123 ... 222324
View previous topic :: View next topic

Poll: Best of the Big Four grunge bands?
Nirvana?:
59%
 59%  [26]
Pearl Jam:
20%
 20%  [9]
Alice in Chains:
13%
 13%  [6]
Soundgarden:
6%
 6%  [3]
Total Votes : 44

  • Quote
CDQ wrote:
If Joy Division is the best of post-punk, I feel comfortable saying that post-punk is a completely awful genre.


Since you have The Smiths ranked #1, you may wanna take that back, since they could definitely be considered post-punk.

The Cure, Sonic Youth, Wire, Gang Of Four, Magazine, Crime & The City Solution, The Birthday Party, Echo & The Bunymen...etc all great post-punk bands.
_________________
http://jonnyleather.com
  • Quote
meccalecca wrote:
Since you have The Smiths ranked #1, you may wanna take that back, since they could definitely be considered post-punk.

The Cure, Sonic Youth, Wire, Gang Of Four, Magazine, Crime & The City Solution, The Birthday Party, Echo & The Bunymen...etc all great post-punk bands.


Sonic youth? I thought they were noise rock?
  • Quote
Cymro2011 wrote:
Sonic youth? I thought they were noise rock?


genres and subgenres are silly indefinable things that cannot pin down a group. They're just tools created by music critics to group bands together.

just like how we lump hundreds of years of music into "classical" despite a ridiculous range of ideas and sounds
_________________
http://jonnyleather.com
  • Quote
meccalecca wrote:
genres and subgenres are silly indefinable things that cannot pin down a group. They're just tools created by music critics to group bands together.

just like how we lump hundreds of years of music into "classical" despite a ridiculous range of ideas and sounds


sigh genres are frustrating.
  • Quote
Happymeal wrote:
Well, to be fair, you could call Dinosaur Jr. grunge and you wouldn't be too far out of the ball park. They're close enough that calling them grunge isn't too bad, though obviously they fit into other genres much better.

EDIT: Also, RYM has grunge listed as one of their genres (not their main one obviously) http://rateyourmusic.com/artist/dinosaur_jr_

And no, it's not prominent, but it isn't too far off.


I wouldn't trust RYM on that. Their best grunge albums chart determined by the usersw includes LZ4, Ramones albums, Fleetwood Mac, Pixies, and Pink Floyd. Pink freaking Floyd!
  • Quote
JMan wrote:
I wouldn't trust RYM on that. Their best grunge albums chart determined by the usersw includes LZ4, Ramones albums, Fleetwood Mac, Pixies, and Pink Floyd. Pink freaking Floyd!



The one you posted earlier wasn't even their grunge chart Jman. If you click on charts, then you can pick any genre you like to look for the "best of" if you go to the bar next to "only include genres" (they have other options at that point too). The "chart" you looked at was the best rated by those users, not a grunge chart.
  • Quote
I got done with Apple by Mother Love Bone, even though I couldn't find a track on YT. Now I'm listening to a good grunge band which I don't think anyone here's mentioned yet: Skin Yard. Heavier than the average grunge. The album is 1000 Smiling Knuckles. I'll let you know what I think.
  • Quote
You know earlier on when you were all talking about Dinosaur Jr being an influence to Grunge?

I've just remembered about Flipper - Generic Flipper it sounds grungy as hell.

New topic  Closed
Topic Posters
All times are GMT
Goto page Previous  123 ... 222324
Page 24 of 24


 

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Similar Topics
Topic Author Forum
Sticky: The Tournaments Forum Suggestions Thread Guest Tournaments
Could there be a second wave of grunge? RepoMan Music
Nu metal/post-grunge fans? Smithy98 Music
Rate more post-grunge/nu-metal bands Smithy98 Music
Point of Discussion: The Development ... RockyRaccoon Music

 
Top  Commenters
1. garycottier 2,095
2. junodog4 1,045
3. HoldenM 948
4. paladisiac 708
5. Brad1770 662
6. Mercury 659
7. meccalecca 506
8. Untitled 479
9. hairymarx1 441
10. johnner 440
The top commenters on BEA ranked by helpful votes received across their top comments.
Back to Top
Best Ever Albums
Install BEA for an app-like experience.