Controversial Music Opinions On BEA!

Goto page Previous  123 ... 298299300 ... 405406407  Next
View previous topic :: View next topic
  • Quote
LedZep wrote:
Ride The Lightning is by far the best Metallica album.


The only Metallica album I've listened through fully is Master of Puppets, so I can't say much on this, but For Whom The Bell Tolls and Fade To Black are two of my favourite Metallica songs, and I like them more than anything on Master Of Puppets or The Black Album.

LedZep wrote:
Megadeth<=Metallica in the 80'
Megadeth>Metallica now


Nothing to say, I've not listened much to Megadeth.

LedZep wrote:
Iron Maiden>both of them


Again, haven't listened much to Iron Maiden, but I do like the few songs I know.

LedZep wrote:
Smiths are good, but overrated


I agree. They are a very good band, but not as great as this site seems to treat them; I prefer R.E.M.

LedZep wrote:
Guns n' Roses are nothing special


I thought everyone on this site hated Guns n' Roses? I agree with you; they're decent, but nothing great.

LedZep wrote:
The Cult is much better


Haven't listened to them.

LedZep wrote:
Neil Young=Bob Dylan, both equally good although I prefer Neil for albums and Dylan for individual songs


I agree on them being as good as each other and Young having better albums while Dylan has better singles.

LedZep wrote:
Nirvana=Pearl Jam=Soundgarden=Alice in Chains, Nirvana is certainly not better than any of these


I agree.

LedZep wrote:
Steven Wilson is a genius but his lyrics aren't THAT good


Haven't listened to him, have been meaning to though.

LedZep wrote:
Genesis after Gabriel sucks


I thought this was the popular opinion on this site? I definitely agree.

LedZep wrote:
I don't really like Beatles albumsโ€ฆ


I would disagree if you were to say that The Beatles suck or are overrated, but I can't argue with you saying you don't like them personally.

LedZep wrote:
I hope someone got angry while reading this ๐Ÿ˜ ๐Ÿ˜œ =D>


Maybe someone, but not me.
  • Quote
LedZep wrote:
I hope someone got angry while reading this ๐Ÿ˜ ๐Ÿ˜œ =D>

if this is the stated goal, you've got to attack forum darlings (not necessarily the overall chart stuff). red house painters, olivier messiaen, kendrick lamar... actually, even if you attack the forum regular picks, you're probably not gonna piss off much of anyone.

that polly bradfield album though...
_________________
follow me on the bandcamp.
  • Quote
I don't know how controversial this is, but I really hate the fiddle. Just don't like screeching sounds.
  • Quote
Kendrick Lamar is the most overrated artist of this age.

Also Lulu by Lou Reed and Metallica got really much undeserved hate.

And last

The new Radiohead album is good, but not that good.
  • Quote
EarthBoundRules wrote:
I don't know how controversial this is, but I really hate the fiddle. Just don't like screeching sounds.

all around? or just a particular style?

i can't stand a lot of that country stuff on the fiddle, but some of the celtic players are incredible.

tommy peoples is an absolute madman. if you're into ornamentation at all, he's kind of the king. the guy puts rolls on everything. double stops. trills. all of it. very virtuous player. it's really fun to listen to too.

the other guy i'm really high on, kevin burke, is more the artist. he's not necessarily gonna blow your mind with the over-the-top stuff, but he's a very dynamic player. he's great to hear live.

lunasa is pretty fun, but that's probably not your cup of tea. and solas... they're more of a celtic fusion thing, but their fiddler is pretty interesting. she doesn't really play the fiddle correctly, and she'd piss off any classical violinist for how she holds her instrument, but she's mastered her own approach to it.

OUTSIDE the celtic stuff, you'd be crazy not to love Kishi Bashi (srsly, the first track on Lighght) and Owen Pallett (lewis takes off his shirt), though i'm not sure that they are officially dubbed "fiddlers" rather than "violinists". the instrument is the same, and neither style is really associated with indie pop / rock... curious.

so yeah, you're being controversial. it's kind of a broad stroke too... reminds me of when i hear people say, "i don't like chinese food".
_________________
follow me on the bandcamp.
  • Quote
Yeah, I was thinking of a specific song from a video game soundtrack which I dislike when I made that comment, and I haven't delved into much music from virtuosos of the instrument, so I guess it's kind of silly to dismiss the entire instrument like that. I guess I can change my complaint to "I don't like bad fiddle playing", just as I dislike poor violin playing.
  • Quote
EarthBoundRules wrote:
I guess I can change my complaint to "I don't like bad fiddle playing", just as I dislike poor violin playing.

what the **** you talkin' 'bout? BAD fiddle/violin playing is the best! clearly, you haven't heard:


Solo Violin Improvisations by Polly Bradfield

and i've got to say, as much as i love a bit of bad fiddling, bad saxophoning is even better - especially to a nice, bad beat of a cheap drum kit. or bad singing/guitaring with a bad drummer... i can't remember which Daniel Johnston album that was where he collaborated with a drummer, but it was pretty tight. or loose, i guess. i dig it though.
_________________
follow me on the bandcamp.
  • Quote
Haha, to each his own I guess. But I like Daniel Johnson's bad guitar/piano playing too. Especially 1990.
  • Quote
Jorbaa wrote:
Kendrick Lamar is the most overrated artist of this age.



I have a hard time agreeing with this in any sense. Obviously this is the controversial opinion thread so good work, but if your answer for the question "Who is the most overrated musical artist of this era?" and the answer isn't Taylor Swift, then the answer should be disqualified.
_________________
Attention all planets of the solar federation: We have assumed control.
  • Quote
AAL2014 wrote:
I have a hard time agreeing with this in any sense. Obviously this is the controversial opinion thread so good work, but if your answer for the question "Who is the most overrated musical artist of this era?" and the answer isn't Taylor Swift, then the answer should be disqualified.


but everybody knows taylor swift is just a mainstream sellout. kendrick (and kanye imo) are praised by critics, sell a lot, and i agree that they are not that much.

reminder that kendrick did a remix for a song for taylor swift.

New topic  Closed
Topic Posters
All times are GMT
Goto page Previous  123 ... 298299300 ... 405406407  Next
Page 299 of 407


 

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Similar Topics
Topic Author Forum
Sticky: The BEA Games Hall Of Fame Guest Tournaments
Sticky: Music Diaries SuedeSwede Music Diaries
Controversial Movie Opinions hereforashortime Movies & TV
BEA's Year-End List Extra: The Most C... Guest Music
Uncontroversial Music Opinions on BEA! Guest Music

 
Back to Top
Best Ever Albums
Install BEA for an app-like experience.