Which lyricist would you rate over Bob Dylan?

Goto page Previous  123456
View previous topic :: View next topic
  • Quote
Jรณnsi
  • Quote
For me, that's a very, very long list. I suppose the one that the most folks might agree with would be Ray Davies.
  • Quote
No one.

There are a few close ones - Springsteen, Roger Waters, Tom Waits, Cohen, Lennon, Eddie Vedder, Win Butler.
  • Quote
Probably no one, though there's an argument to be made for the following (in no particular order)...

Leonard Cohen
Nick Cave
Joanna Newsom
Captain Beefheart
_________________
Best Classical
Best Films
Best Paintings
  • Quote
Dylan writes very 'cool' lyrics, but I can't think of anything he's written that's made me stop dead in my tracks. They're all quite nice for the novelty, but he comes across more like a drunk poet than someone with any actual wisdom.

There's something about Leonard Cohen's lyrics I can't get behind. Feels as though he read a book on how to write poetry and is just following it to a tee. Maybe it's just oldscool, but it always feels very safe, and personal subjects (falling in love, broken heart, death so on) come across as very impersonal somehow. There's a lack of irony somewhere, I think.

I'm obviously a big fan of Mark Kozelek, but I think his best writing was in 2012/2013. Before then and it's mostly just standard, though very nice, indie stuff. I like his later more 'honest' work, but I don't know if I'd class them as lyrics. Felt like he poured most of his stories into Benji, then Universal Themes (which I prefer) got it right with those more quirky but poignoint moments in his life. His stuff on that Jesu album really sounded like he'd run of out stuff to say, probably started singing about his morning coffee at one point.

I think Sufjan Stevens might be one of my favourite lyricists. Gets just about everything right. So many great lines in Illinois and Adz that both hit home but also feel like Sufjan is expressing himself to his fullest. You can tell he's a very explorative, reflective person when it comes to environments and emotions. I felt like Carrie and Lowell lost something, though. It was almost too personal. Not sure. There's a different tone to hearing how he felt seeing a wasp on his arm as a child, to feeling at loss with the death of his mother.

Anyway. Tom Waits is probably my favourite lyricist. He's got that 'cool' factor Dylan has but feels like he actually has something to say, and there's actually a piece of him in everything he writes. Love almost all of his work in that regard. Plus, I've always had an affection for that kind of slurring 'I'm an alcoholic trying to get my life together' vibe.
  • Quote
Possibly Ian Curtis. Some of his lyrics are among the best I've heard, especially considering he was only in his early 20s when he wrote them.

Patti Smith - at the very least she's on a par with Dylan.

Syd Barrett - again, like Curtis, had a genius grasp of the English language despite his relative youth (for now ignoring his excessive LSD use, which arguagly did help his creativity but ate his brain).

There are some rappers I consider fantastic lyricists. Kendrick Lamar, Chuck D are two I would rate very highly, although hard to say whether they're better than Dylan.

I didn't really rate Sufjan Stevens until I heard Carrie & Lowell, the sheer brutal honesty of which just blew me away.

I agree with many in this thread that Leonard Cohen and Tom Waits are two other great lyricists worth mentioning.

(This was just off the top of my head, there'll probably be numerous edits when I have one spontaneous "Eureka! So-and-so wrote amazing lyrics too!"-moment after another.)

1st EDIT: Joanna Newsom! Of course!

New topic  Closed
Topic Posters
All times are GMT
Goto page Previous  123456
Page 6 of 6


 

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Similar Topics
Topic Author Forum
Sticky: What album are you listening to? (cont.) albummaster Music
songs you can listen to on repeat ove... paladisiac Music
How would you Weezer fans rate thier ... Imbacktosavethuniverse Music
If you were stuck on an island which ... Mattmiller25 Music
Who would you invite over for drinks? Guest Music

 
Back to Top
Best Ever Albums
Install BEA for an app-like experience.