Personally I find that Hendrix's epic guitar playing makes it better than the Dylan version, which i do like _________________ Nothing really matters, anyone can see, nothing really matters, nothing really matters to me.
of the two, i'll take hendrix. some other notable covers (and no, i haven't heard all of these):
The Grateful Dead
Neil Young
Pearl Jam
U2
The Dave Matthews Band
Steve Hackett
Eric Clapton
The Dream Syndicate
Jeff Healey
Indigo Girls
Van Morrison
Supertramp
Turtle Island String Quartet
Paul Weller
Bobby Womack
XTC
and lots more. i haven't personally heard bobby womack's yet, but that's the most enticing on the list.
for the record, i mean no disrespect about this topic. it's a great song, and i'm curious to hear other performances of it. as it stands, i've heard i think(?) 6 of these. _________________ follow me on the bandcamp.
Every cover of any Dylan song is superior to the original. Dude writes far better than he sings.
One Watchtower cover not yet mentioned is by the Scottish Celtic Rock band Angus Mohr. -- kinda like the Hendrix version plus bagpipes-- trust me, it's better than it sounds on paper.
The other unmentioned version I love is a marvelous live acoustic rendition by new age guitar virtuoso Michael Hedges on his album Live on the Double Planet.
Every cover of any Dylan song is superior to the original. Dude writes far better than he sings.
Dylan's voice works better depending on the subject matter of the song, I wouldn't want hendrix to do a cover of Like a rolling stone _________________ Nothing really matters, anyone can see, nothing really matters, nothing really matters to me.
FischmanRockMonster, JazzMeister, Bluesboy,ClassicalMasterProfile Location: Land of Enchantment
Every cover of any Dylan song is superior to the original. Dude writes far better than he sings.
If you like "good" "singing" you should watch The Voice and X Factor; generic (or hair metal) standards of good singing don't count for shit. _________________ "I feel like for the last two years there’s been sort of a sonic evolution happening and I’ve been experimenting more and more."
FischmanRockMonster, JazzMeister, Bluesboy,ClassicalMasterProfile Location: Land of Enchantment
If you like "good" "singing" you should watch The Voice and X Factor; generic (or hair metal) standards of good singing don't count for shit.
Iit's possible for an artist to have a "good" voice and integrity or authenticity or whatever intangible word you want to apply, so why settle? Plenty of "good" voices are also unique. Unique need not be a synonym for mediocre (or in the case of Dylan, far worst than mediocre)
The topic of this thread is a perfect example. Nobody would accuse Jimi of having an American Idol voice, but he handles the song quite well, actually singing through his mouth rather than his nose, and not employing that horrible affectation that needlessly emphases and draws out the last syllable of every line. And he can actually demonstrate some real proficiency on his guitar at the same time, unlike nasal Bob.
I don't watch any of those shows, and I actually do like quite a few vocalists who would never be accused of having technically great or "pretty" voices.
Dylan's voice is perfect for his songs, I rarely even like covers by other artists.
That being said, All Along The Watchtower is all Jimi's, he made the song so much better (but definitely not because of his voice). Jimi's version of Like A Rolling Stone is not so good.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
hereforashortime
craola
Hayden
Fischman
Muslim-Bigfoot
Daydreamer
