ADP #1 Illinois by Sufjan Stevens

Goto page Previous  12
View previous topic :: View next topic
  • Quote
sethmadsen wrote:
Puncture Repair wrote:

3. I think it's a mature nod to your influences and a respectful celebration of them. There shouldn't be anything shame. It tends to really ground the piece, give it a sense of place and history, and also humility.


Do you think the reason Rattle and Hum got slammed was because they did more than nod, they collaborated with the likes of Bob Dylan and BB King?

I think that was half of the reason. I think the other half was the music wasn't that great.

As for Illinois, I hadn't listened to the album or anything by Sufjan Stevens until this thread was posted. So it's very new to me. But I didn't hear any references to other musicians on the album. I may have missed them. Even so, unlike Rattle and Hum, Illinois feels genuinely like one artist's product and doesn't feel pretentious. If Stevens was nodding to his influences on Illinois, it seems he was doing so in a subtle and respectable way, not trying to place himself on the same pedestal. Again, I don't entirely know because the album is so new to me. So far what I've got is that Illinois isn't exactly my cup of tea, but it is a pleasant-sounding homage to the state after which it's named with quite a few good tracks (especially Chicago).
_________________
on such a winter's day
  • Quote
StreetSpirit wrote:
sethmadsen wrote:
Puncture Repair wrote:

3. I think it's a mature nod to your influences and a respectful celebration of them. There shouldn't be anything shame. It tends to really ground the piece, give it a sense of place and history, and also humility.


Do you think the reason Rattle and Hum got slammed was because they did more than nod, they collaborated with the likes of Bob Dylan and BB King?

I think that was half of the reason. I think the other half was the music wasn't that great.


hahahaha.

Well, to be fair, Sufjan only mentions Frank Lloyd Wright (that I caught, he could have mentioned musicians/music from the state as well).

I realize this thread isn't about Rattle and Hum, but I actually like it/think a few tracks are top notch, but I agree it is a soundtrack to a movie, not a good album.

Tracks I dig: (live versions of songs are ok and covers are ok)
Van Dieman's Land - pretty good (better message than music)
Desire - fantastic
Silver and Gold - pretty good (better message than music)
Angel of Harlem - fantastic
Love Rescue Me - fantastic
God Part II - fantastic
All I Want Is You- fantastic
Funny that I don't like the songs they cowrote with BB King and Bob Dylan.

But yeah, 7 out of 17 isn't great, the rest are ok, so it is an ok album in my book, somehow it becomes greater than it really is due to the movie and nostalgia, but when I really evaluate it, I suppose it really is just 7 pretty good to great songs and 10 average to below average songs.
  • Quote
Also @StreetSpirit...

I think this album is a grower and if you give it a spin or two, wait a couple weeks and then come back to it and give it a spin or two, it might click. I at first only gave it like a 75/80 and now I think it is a masterpiece. And really appreciate Puncture Repair's take on the Charlie Brown feel. Helped me maybe settle that opinion on it... or at least it gave it a new light to look at it.

But hell, I like Charlie Brown just fine.

New topic  Closed
Topic Posters
All times are GMT
Goto page Previous  12
Page 2 of 2


 

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Similar Topics
Topic Author Forum
Album of the day (#335): Illinois by ... BestEverAlbums Music
[ Poll ] BSAT Round #2: Sufjan Stevens vs. Feist Guest Tournaments
CLOSED: Let's Rank 14: Sufjan Stevens CubaZed Music
[ Poll ] CLOSED- 2000s BST Rd1: Sweet Trip v S... cestuneblague Tournaments
[ Poll ] (Closed) 2015-2019 Play-in: Sufjan St... babyBlueSedan Tournaments

 
Happy  BEAnniversary
Astro 1 year
Martino7 9 years
Millipede 6 years
Bardiebart 12 years
lepfanlh 1 year
Arnio 1 year
BraddlesHendo 13 years
rogue 13 years
thainguyen 10 years
BiggestDick 5 years
Here's to many more years of great albums! ๐Ÿฅณ
Back to Top
Best Ever Albums
Install BEA for an app-like experience.