Have we ever done a best ever comedy films list? _________________ Nothing really matters, anyone can see, nothing really matters, nothing really matters to me.
If we do, we might want to make a distinction about what the criteria/qualifications are for "comedy". For instance, Monty Python's Holy Grail is possibly the funniest film ever made. However, there are films that are much superior that arent strictly comedies but where comedy is still a very significant factor and among the genres the film encapsulates (such as Gilliam's Brazil, Kusturica's Underground, Von Trier's The Kingdom...). _________________ Best Classical Best Films Best Paintings
If we do, we might want to make a distinction about what the criteria/qualifications are for "comedy". For instance, Monty Python's Holy Grail is possibly the funniest film ever made. However, there are films that are much superior that arent strictly comedies but where comedy is still a very significant factor and among the genres the film encapsulates (such as Gilliam's Brazil, Kusturica's Underground, Von Trier's The Kingdom...).
Well we could restrict it to what IMDb considers a comedy, like we did on the romance films list, Underground would still make it, but Brazil wouldn't, also would the kingdom be eligible, considering it's a Mini-Series and not a movie? _________________ Nothing really matters, anyone can see, nothing really matters, nothing really matters to me.
Well we could restrict it to what IMDb considers a comedy, like we did on the romance films list, Underground would still make it, but Brazil wouldn't, also would the kingdom be eligible, considering it's a Mini-Series and not a movie?
Kingdom has a theatrical release, so it's kinda all good.
I'd be iffy on a comedy list (not opposed), but it could be tricky. Wouldn't mind a few good laughs though, a good list for BEA to let out their goofy side.
That being said, something more on the violent side of things like In Bruges would probably be in my top 5. _________________ Doubles & Conch
Well we could restrict it to what IMDb considers a comedy, like we did on the romance films list, Underground would still make it, but Brazil wouldn't, also would the kingdom be eligible, considering it's a Mini-Series and not a movie?
I'm fine with that, even though Brazil is actually more of a comedy than Underground. Generally though, IMDb is accurate enough I suppose... _________________ Best Classical Best Films Best Paintings
Defining genres is never cut-and-dry. I would approach a comedy list the same way I approached the horror list last October. Remember the discussion about Alien and 'pure horror' films? Well some movies are 'purer comedies' than others. For example, Tommy Boy and Hayden's pick, In Bruges. Both have the comedy genre tag, and both very good. But Tommy Boy is traditional gag laughter; whereas In Bruges wonderfully blends elements of other genres (drama, gangster, thriller). In Bruges isn't funny at all in certain scenes. I'd certainly say In Bruges is a better overall film than Tommy Boy. But on a comedy list, I would have them pretty close.
Anyway..
@ hereforashortime. You sound like you really want a new poll to start. If you want to host this comedy list idea, I say go for it! Sounds like fun.
That being said, I'm calling dibs on hosting a sci-fi list. Tentatively November.
@ hereforashortime. You sound like you really want a new poll to start. If you want to host this comedy list idea, I say go for it! Sounds like fun.
That being said, I'm calling dibs on hosting a sci-fi list. Tentatively November.
Sci-Fi is all yours, I definitely won't envy being the person that has to decide whether or not Star Wars is considered Sci-Fi. _________________ Nothing really matters, anyone can see, nothing really matters, nothing really matters to me.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
hereforashortime
AfterHours
Hayden
CA Dreamin
