Round 1: Robyn v. Spiritualized

Goto page Previous  12
View previous topic :: View next topic

Poll: Please listen to both albums in full before voting, then choose your favorite.
Honey by Robyn:
55%
 55%  [11]
And Nothing Hurt by Spiritualized:
45%
 45%  [9]
Total Votes : 20

  • Quote
Also naaaaaw this clearly doesnt touch spiritualizeds best
_________________
2021 in full effect. Come drop me some recs. Y'all know what I like.
  • Quote
Robyn has a clearly solid sound with beautifully piercing vocals and fantastic production, but I struggled with it's dynamics and tonality as something that never really took off.

So while Spiritualized is kind of a regurgitation of things (both a pro and a con) I like, it gets the win for me.
  • Quote
As somebody who has liked Jason Pierce since Spacemen 3's debut album, and has Ladies And Gentlemen... in my all time chart, I'm still a huge fan of the latest Spiritualized album. While it might not be as great as some of their earlier albums they did set an extremely high bar, and this is still a wonderful album in it's own right. Top 20 for the year for me and a definite vote over Robyn.
  • Quote
Gowi wrote:
Quote:
is their absolute best


I admit I have this feeling a lot, ie where I think that older artists are releasing their best albums now. I know they mostly do it for the money, I know that in most cases they donโ€™t bring anything new, and I know that in most cases their vocal range hasnโ€™t improved;
But I just find that their new albums tend to be more focused and I just (re-) discover that the production quality of those older albums was not 100%.
But rest assured thereโ€™s also many examples of the opposite: I donโ€™t expect that the upcoming Pixies album will be better than Doolittle or Surfer Rosa.
  • Quote
Quote:
I admit I have this feeling a lot, ie where I think that older artists are releasing their best albums now. I know they mostly do it for the money, I know that in most cases they donโ€™t bring anything new, and I know that in most cases their vocal range hasnโ€™t improved;


Being said, sometimes it works out. I'm extremely fond of Slowdive's 2017 effort, and comfortably consider it their second best.

The Spiritualized album is the only album in the tournament I haven't given a spin yet, but I'll get on it soon. Won't say anything further until I do (but it's going to take quite a bit to beat Robyn).
_________________
Doubles & Conch
  • Quote
This is far from my favorite Spiritualized, but it still easily outdistances Robyn's fluff.
  • Quote
CryingGameDahlin wrote:
Yeah this isn't my absolute favorite from Robyn or even my favorite of '18 but I was listening to it quite a bit around the time of the nomination s and it just really fits a perfect mood, definitely finding a place for lean, moody, unabashedly middle-age synthpop album. .


Totally! It's also quite a grower. One of our favorites from our recent road trip although we still liked her other two albums a lot more.
  • Quote
I worship spiritualized's 90s albums and this new one is great and certainly holds it own. Sure it's nothing new, but Jason owns this sound and this is another GREAT release.
  • Quote
My opinion hasn't changed since last year's first listen for either record. Both are above-average albums, but it's a fairly comfortable win for Robyn. Honey is never less than very good, and catches pop lightning in a bottle a few times, leading to some stunning highlights. My hot take is that Honey would beat any album in either artist's discography (although I have a few albums left to tackle, admittedly).
_________________
Join us in the canon game :) / Add me on RYM
  • Quote
Honey defeats And Nothing Hurt 11-9 and advances to the sweet sixteen.
_________________
Join us in the canon game :) / Add me on RYM

New topic  Closed
Topic Posters
All times are GMT
Goto page Previous  12
Page 2 of 2


 

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Similar Topics
Topic Author Forum
World album of the day (#154): Body T... albummaster Music
Spiritualized - Ladies & Gentleme... Kiki Music
[ Poll ] Sweet 16: Robyn v. Sobrenadar baystateoftheart Tournaments
User Pick of the Day #11: Let It Come... Guest Music
[ Poll ] [Round 2 - Match 15] Hard Drive vs Mu... LedZep Tournaments

 
Top  Commenters
1. garycottier 2,096
2. junodog4 1,048
3. HoldenM 948
4. paladisiac 708
5. Brad1770 662
6. Mercury 659
7. meccalecca 506
8. Untitled 480
9. hairymarx1 441
10. johnner 440
The top commenters on BEA ranked by helpful votes received across their top comments.
Back to Top
Best Ever Albums
Install BEA for an app-like experience.