An Idiot Listens to Western Music: Coll (2021)

Goto page Previous  123 ... 464748 ... 106107108  Next
View previous topic :: View next topic
  • Quote
Fischman wrote:
The Kreutzer has always been my favorite. The one recording I own is a Naxos disc with Takako Nishizaki and Jeno Jando. It is a perfectly fine recording, but I can't imagine anything competing with Perlman and Ashkenazy on this one.


Perlman has a very unique style. I feel like he embellishes a little too much on his Four Seasons take, but he has this tonal quality that is incredibly unique/powerful... sometimes to his favor and sometimes to his demise... what I mean by this is sometimes I feel like he's the artist instead of the composer, and sometimes I like that and sometimes I want a violinist to match what the composer wanted, not what Perlman wants. With this, I feel like his style matches... but I'm a novice in this world.
  • Quote

Beethoven: Piano Concerto No. 5 "E...saac Stern

Era: Classical
Year: 1803 (Triple Concerto)
Form: Concerto
Score: 90

Cello, Violin, and Piano soloist in one fantastic piece, yes please. Beethoven masterfully marries these soloists in a conversation worth hearing over and over. I think I like Brendel's take on the Emporer concerto, and I'm really focusing on the Triple Concerto for this release. I love the dance of the other two instruments as the soloist takes over. Clever - busy, yet quiet, giving beautiful motion/rhythm. I chose this recording for the names really. Open to others who did the Triple Concerto better justice. Looks like there's a Karajan, Rostropovich, Richter recording that looks intriguing/possibly even bigger names. Anyway, I'm rating for the piece and thought it well represented, but possibly not best represented here... perhaps worth a spin... also this cover art might be the sexiest thing ever ( ๐Ÿคก ๐Ÿซข ๐Ÿคฃ ๐Ÿ˜Ž )... All I mean is so much amazing talent on one cover:



Link


Quote:
Beethoven's "Triple" Concerto is often treated as the less brilliant sibling of the more imposing works composed around the same time: Fidelio, the Fourth Piano Concerto, the Violin Concerto, and the Fourth Symphony. It is important to note that this work was written with an amateur pianist in mind: the relatively simple piano part was designed for Beethoven's patron, the Archduke Rudolf; nevertheless, professional musicians are required for the brutal cello part and the less difficult -- but still quite challenging -- violin part. The work was not premiered until 1808, failed to go over well, and has received limited attention ever since. The themes do tend to wander, their development is rather haphazard, and there are no showy cadenzas; in the work's favor, the subtle effects for the soloists and their imaginative interplay with the orchestra must be noted. The concerto follows all the expected patterns. The first movement, Allegro, is in sonata form, with the principal themes laid out by the orchestra before the soloists put in an appearance. The first theme is optimistic, elegant, mildly striving, but completely unpretentious: almost a German walking tune. The two string soloists come in with their version of the first theme, which is soon taken up by the piano with the strings playing a subsidiary role. The soloists develop this material sometimes individually, sometimes the strings alternating with the piano, and sometimes in conjunction with various components of the orchestra. In general, though, only one soloist takes the spotlight at a time, if only for a few bars. This polite turn-taking stretches the movement beyond the point its thematic material merits, the inventive dialogue among the instruments almost compensating for the thin content. The second movement, Largo, is far more compact. Written in A flat major, this movement is highly cantabile and poetic, with the cello first singing out the theme at some length. The piano offers some atmospheric support, while the two string soloists handle most of the lingering, effusive lyricism. Clouds pass over during a minor mode episode imposed by the orchestra near the end, but the soloists modulate back to the major for a seamless transition into the finale, a Rondo alla Polacca. The "Polish" designation has to do with the rhythm rather than any appropriations of folk tunes. The movement begins sweetly enough, though with some tough turns for the string players. Spirits rise through the remainder of the rondo, with a light but distinctly pulsing rhythm (there is nevertheless an obvious polonaise right in the middle of it all) and several instances of rapid passagework for the string soloists. The trio rushes through a penultimate breakneck episode, but slows down for its last, dance-like section while the orchestra keeps trying to cut in with a big, affirmative conclusion. -Description by James Reel
  • Quote
I decided to dig a little into multiple recordings with Beethoven. Earlier a Barenboim vs Brendel, now an Uchida vs Brendel... and to be honest I feel like they are all top notch recordings, even if there's some subtleties, none of them lack emotion/recording quality, etc. imo.


Beethoven: Piano Concertos Nos. 3 &...Sanderling

Era: Classical
Year: 1800 for 3 and 1805 for 4
Form: Concerto
Score: 90

I already said all of the piano concertos were fantastic for me. I'll just let the commentary and samples here speak for themselves. I think I like 3 more.


Link


Quote:

Beethoven's famously copious notebooks confirm that he only composed after an indeterminate period of inspiration, followed by a period of experimentation, followed by a period of gestation: in other words, an evolutionary process. While we know in most cases when works were premiered and published, we don't know when exactly he conceived them, or what chain of change preceded their first public performance. We remain in the dark, for example, on what days of which months -- or for that matter in what year -- he concentrated on the Fourth Piano Concerto to the exclusion of all else.

Not that we need to know. It suffices to recognize its revolutionary (as well as evolutionary) nature, beginning with the very first chord. No concerto before, by Beethoven or anyone else, began as the G major does, with the solo instrument playing unaccompanied -- not only that but playing both dolce and softly! The miracle, however, is that Beethoven introduces the main theme and rhythm of the entire first movement within five sweet, soft, solo measures ending on a D major (dominant) chord, which the orchestra answers in B major before modulating to the tonic G. There is none of Beethoven's characteristic vehemence, not even at a crescendo to forte with sforzando punctuation in measures 20-22, although he composed the Fourth Concerto and Appassionata Sonata concurrently, all the while the Fifth Symphony was incubating in his other-consciousness.

Fascinatingly, principal themes in the opening movements of the Fourth Concerto and Fifth Symphony share a rhythmic motto: three short notes of equal value followed by a longer fourth note. (In the concerto, all of these are the same note; in the symphony, the last one is a third lower.) Noteworthy, too, was the premiere of both works on the same Vienna program -- that storied four-hour marathon of December 22, 1808, in the unheated Theater an der Wien, which also introduced the Pastoral Symphony and "Chorale" Fantasie with an orchestra that refused to rehearse with the composer present. Apropos of the G major Concerto: while a traditional double-exposition follows its trailblazing start, Beethoven's instrumental textures, tonal weight, subtleties of harmony, and especially the illusion he creates of improvisation were seven-league strides.

The slow movement is even more revolutionary, despite the brevity of only 72 measures and its indebtedness to the middle, Romanza movement of Mozart's D minor Concerto (K. 466), which Beethoven played publicly with outstanding success. However, in his own concerto, the juxtaposition of implacable strings playing both forte and staccato, and the piano's conciliatory legato response with the "soft" pedal down throughout, was unprecedented. Such palpable confrontation was not the norm in concertos. Neither was the orchestra's eventual capitulation, followed without pause by a rondo-finale marked vivace, whose presto coda is as scintillant as any music Beethoven ever wrote.

Even so, solo pianists and their audiences were slower to take up the Fourth than Beethoven's other concertos. But Mendelssohn -- a general who savored caviar -- loved it best, and played it at his last London concert, in 1846: a program that also featured his own music for A Midsummer Night's Dream and the Scottish Symphony. - Description by Roger Dettmer




Link


Quote:


Beethoven composed this work in 1799-1800, and introduced it at Vienna on April 5, 1803. The first sketches go back to 1797 -- after he'd composed the B flat Piano Concerto (published as No. 2), but before composition of the C major Concerto (in 1798, published as No. 1). Although Beethoven played the first performance of No. 3 in 1803 from a short score -- no one was going to steal it from him! -- he'd actually completed the music prior to April 1800, apart from a few last-minute adjustments. In other words, before he wrote the Second Symphony (Op. 36), the Moonlight Piano Sonata (Op. 27/2), or the Op. 31 triptych for keyboard.

The model for this startlingly dramatic concerto was Mozart's C minor (K. 491), which Beethoven played in public concerts. But "model" does not mean he merely imitated; indeed, the orchestra's traditional first exposition is so extensively developed that the soloist's repetition risks sounding anticlimactic. Otherwise, as Charles Rosen has written with formidable insight in The Classical Style, "There are many passages in the first movement, Allegro con brio, which allude to Mozart's concerto in the same key...particularly the role of the piano after the cadenza. But the striking development section, with [a] new melody half-recitative [and] half-aria, is entirely original, as is the new sense of weight to the form." Beethoven wrote down that cadenza several years later, to preserve the work's character and momentum, when implacable deafness seriously disadvantaged his public appearances at the keyboard.

To his contemporaries the slow movement came -- and can still come -- as a shock. Not only did he mark it Largo (which is to say very slowly), in 3/8 time, but chose the remote key of E major (four sharps, vs. C minor's three flats). Alone, the piano leads off for 11 measures, introducing both the main theme and ornamentation that accompanies it throughout. Here Beethoven anticipated the solo opening of his G major Fourth Concerto five years down the road, although in that work he dispensed with thematic decorations, beautiful as they were (and are) in the Largo of No. 3.

Characteristically, the finale is a rondo Allegro, again in tonic C minor, with a pair of principal themes introduced by the soloist. This movement is rich in humor yet also dramatic, with a passage midway in E major to remind us where we've been. Following another (but brief) cadenza, Beethoven switches to C major, accelerates the tempo to Presto, and gives the orchestra the last word. -Description by Roger Dettmer
  • Quote

Beethoven: Symphony 3 "Eroica"... Venezuela

Era: Classical
Year: 1805 (premier)
Form: Concerto
Score: 90

Oh my word, it's Beethoven's Third, again... hehe... this was something we'd say as kids as it went along the melody/help you remember which one was which. And yes, I'm a bit out of order... 1 and 2 are going to be later. Anyway, this of course is one of Beethoven's many famous symphonies. It's kind of the first time I've thought of the symphony form - the first movement having that faster, more memorable melody, the second moving to a sombre/slower movement, and then the build back up... and how it reminds me a bit of Vivaldi's Four Seasons... before the symphony was really "invented". Anyway, that's just what came to mind this go around. I was surprised how long the movements were when I noticed the time... they seemed to fly by. It also reminded me/came to mind on how Beethoven really is that pivotal composer who rubbed shoulders with the early classical greats like Mozart and Haydn, and you can hear their styles mimicked from time to time, but then how he also is the beginning of a transition into the Romantic world, and this piece might be (no musicologist) one of the early signs of such. Really pouring his heart and soul into something... caring less about how the courts/magistrates would receive and really just wrote from his heart and this is what came out. Oh also I'm kicking myself... I lived on the Linkewienzeile for 8 months... like less than a mile away on the same street is where this piece... and MANY of Beethoven's works premiered... and didn't even know it. Instead some immature kids showed me where Hitler had lived once... bastards... wish I had gone here instead... ๐Ÿคก .

Oh and Egmont and Prometheus. Egmont of course is my favorite of the two. I actually didn't know this was to a Goethe play until just recently. Just read the synopsis that it's similar to Gรถtz von Berchtlingen which I have read, but not Egmont... now I want to. Prometheus I was less interested in, even if it was pretty good.


Link


I'll let the smart guy do the heavy lifting:
Quote:


Beethoven completed this work in 1804; it was introduced privately in Vienna, chez Prince Lobkowitz, to whom it is dedicated. Beethoven also conducted the public premiere on April 7, 1805, in the Theater-an-der-Wien. Despite everything written to the contrary, the Sinfonia eroica was never a "portrait" of Napoleon Bonaparte, although Beethoven did plan to dedicate it to the charismatic Corsican "First Consul of France." He went into a rage, however, when a pupil, Ferdinand Ries, brought news in May 1804 that Napoleon had crowned himself Emperor. According to Ries, Beethoven shouted that the General was only "an ordinary human being, [and] went to the table, took hold of the title page, tore it in two, and threw it on the floor."

A different story posits that Beethoven erased the Napoleonic dedication from a copy made in August 1804 and entitled Sinfonia grande. In fact, Sinfonia eroica did not appear as the work's title until publication in 1806.

What Beethoven never told Ries was that Prince Lobkowitz, before May 1804, had proffered a handsome fee in exchange for the dedication, which Napoleon's subsequent arrogance made possible. Or that Beethoven realized the advantage in bringing with him a Sinfonia Bonaparte when a Parisian trip was proposed later on (but never materialized). It was conductor Arturo Toscanini who put everything into perspective 50-odd years ago: "Some say Napoleon, some say Hitler, some say Mussolini; for me it is Allegro con brio."

The sheer length of the Eroica's first movement was revolutionary -- an opening movement of 691 measures, plus an exposition repeat of 151 measures. No less revolutionary was Beethoven's jarring C sharp at the end of a main theme in E flat major -- indeed it is an E flat arpeggio. Not until the recapitulation does that C sharp become D flat enharmonically. It is in this movement that the long-range harmonic connections explored over the course of the Romantic era have their real start; the movement is heroic mainly in the vastness of its reach.

A "Funeral March" slow movement was hardly revolutionary, but the span of his C minor slow movement, in rondo form, was unprecedented, and so was its range of emotions from outright grief to C major solace. Although "hunt" music in the third-movement Trio may have startled the Eroica's first audience after funerary tragedy on an unprecedented scale, hunting music in Beethoven's time was even more modish than funeral marches. However, he used it for more than mere surprise in the midst of an onrushing and sometimes raucous scherzo (thereby banishing minuets and Lรคndlers until the symphonies of Bruckner and Mahler). Psychologically he needed sunshine after so much weighty, solemn music.

He was also setting up a racy finale -- a set of variations including a fugue that detractors ever since have called a falling-off of inspiration. This kind of argument ignores, however, not only what preceded the Eroica historically -- Bach's Goldberg Variations for example -- but also Beethoven's own ennoblement of the form. He had already used the legato second theme of his Eroica finale in The Creatures of Prometheus (ballet music of 1800), in an 1802 Contredanse, and as the subject of 15 keyboard variations that same year (Op. 35), subtitled Eroica once the symphony had been published. A never-ending wonder is the viability of this subject after so much use. Beethoven's range of invention in the symphonic finale of 1804 -- from hymnody to humor, from fugue to dance, culminating in a Presto coda -- successfully freed the listener from the gripping, even shocking drama that has stalked his first and second movements. -Description by Roger Dettmer


Last edited by RoundTheBend on 09/15/2019 00:07; edited 2 times in total
  • Quote
Right on - I love the Ashkenazy/Perlman set and they were one of the first Classical albums I ever owned. Id probably rank it 2nd, 3rd or 4th overall, among Oistrakh/Oborin & the more recent (stunning, more incisive than these others) Faust/Melnikov. All 4 have been my very top selection at varying times so I do consider it a very close call.

Perlman is almost always going to top every one on pure technical grounds, save perhaps arguably Oistrakh (and except the sheer virtuosity of Heifetz). While Perlman's broad & singing phrasing tends to be ideal for so much of the Romantic repertoire, sometimes he can lose a pinch of tension/suspense by sounding a little too effortless and wholly melodic (while losing some articulative nuance and "strain"). This happens in his later recordings and not, say, late 80s-backwards (when he was at his peak ... so I am not including the Askenazy VS set we're discussing.) Just mentioning this because he can be an easy/rather automatic choice due to his amazing technical prowess and how ubiquitus he is. But there are other selections that can reward deeper, repeat listening, even if theyre not as "obviously perfect" on the 1st or 1st few listens.

However, Perlman's peak is probably unimpeachable and he is possibly the most reliable, consistently excellent recording violinist ever.

Oistrakh has similar qualities but a little more human, nuanced or wisened intonation, usually with a continual sense of tension, that sounds more experiential and emotively profound (Perlman is more "extroverted" which can work better in certain repertoire).

My 2 cents...

Cant go wrong with any of these for Beethoven's VS
_________________
Best Classical
Best Films
Best Paintings
  • Quote
AfterHours wrote:
Right on - I love the Ashkenazy/Perlman set and they were one of the first Classical albums I ever owned. Id probably rank it 2nd, 3rd or 4th overall, among Oistrakh/Oborin & the more recent (stunning, more incisive than these others) Faust/Melnikov. All 4 have been my very top selection at varying times so I do consider it a very close call.

Perlman is almost always going to top every one on pure technical grounds, save perhaps arguably Oistrakh (and except the sheer virtuosity of Heifetz). While Perlman's broad & singing phrasing tends to be ideal for so much of the Romantic repertoire, sometimes he can lose a pinch of tension/suspense by sounding a little too effortless and wholly melodic (while losing some articulative nuance and "strain"). This happens in his later recordings and not, say, late 80s-backwards (when he was at his peak ... so I am not including the Askenazy VS set we're discussing.) Just mentioning this because he can be an easy/rather automatic choice due to his amazing technical prowess and how ubiquitus he is. But there are other selections that can reward deeper, repeat listening, even if theyre not as "obviously perfect" on the 1st or 1st few listens.

However, Perlman's peak is probably unimpeachable and he is possibly the most reliable, consistently excellent recording violinist ever.

Oistrakh has similar qualities but a little more human, nuanced or wisened intonation, usually with a continual sense of tension, that sounds more experiential and emotively profound (Perlman is more "extroverted" which can work better in certain repertoire).

My 2 cents...

Cant go wrong with any of these for Beethoven's VS


Yeah - great points here... bolded the ones for discussion points...

Which begs the question, what criteria do you follow (I mean we've had this conversation about overall, but I mean classical recording criteria), do you value most? (If you so wish)

A rough draft for me is:

1) The actual recording quality - I know I shouldn't be such a brat here, but really early (dare I say amazing performances) make classical music hard to listen to when there's a lot of hiss/"air" on the record... it ruins it for me... I'm listening to buzz and trying not too when the dynamics are preciously low... I can't let something like this ruin a fantastic performance... I don't care who it is. (Flip side of this... if the recordings hiss is minimal and the quality of the performance out shines the hiss if that makes any sense.

1a) Does the recording shine/balance the right parts... sometimes the mix isn't right and it just ruins the "live" quality I really like in a great recording.

2) The performance itself... does it flow right... tempo, attacks, emotion, etc. Emotion/passion is key. I mean your examples earlier are prime... the recording was lived, not merely performed.

3) HIP... a little. Sometimes I feel like HIP recordings miss out on some of number 2 - sure it's using a harpsichord instead of a piano, but the violinist thinks dynamic is only loud or soft... hehe. But I also get frustrated that my favorite violin performance of Four Seasons (Gil Shaham), is not mirrored with the best basso continuum and sounds nearly like elevator music (ok that's gone too far ๐Ÿคฅ )... what I mean is it's been modernized so much it doesn't do the rest of it justice. It frustrates me to find the right balance sometimes.


Also when it is such a close call, do you find it worth your time to dig into them? Tell me more (if you want) about being ok with some minor flaws in performance for emotion... sometimes I can agree with this and other times it's the nailing of the note first, and emotion to back it up to makes it super powerful. If something is full of emotion, but not well executed, it actually kills the emotion for me... maybe you have a helpful point of view here I'm missing out on .


Last edited by RoundTheBend on 09/15/2019 00:12; edited 1 time in total
  • Quote


Era: Classical
Year: 1801
Form: Symphony
Score: 87

Part of the reason why I chose these Dudamel recordings are because it's just the symphony mostly. In this case absolutely. Also the bass/cello section is incredibly powerful in the recording, which I like, but still allows the rest of the orchestra the right mix still. Forgot to add to database, but I'm done with that. Anyway, I find this key to Beethoven, even if it's less known/popular... I feel his tympani/arrangement style here is an essence of Beethoven. While it's not his greatest emotional/mental work, it's still fantastic/still quality work.

Quote:


Measured against the hot-wired First Symphony, the heroic Third, and the heaven-storming Fifth -- all of them written between 1799 and 1808 -- Beethoven's Second is a relaxed work in greater part, akin to the Fourth and Sixth symphonies. This has prompted music listeners ever since to wonder how he could have created a work as buoyant as No. 2 at a time when his worsening deafness had been diagnosed as incurable and irreversible.

The work came to term in 1802 from sketches organized the previous year. Likelier than not, it reflects several happy months in the rural retreat of Heiligenstadt, on the recommendation of an otologist. From one window in his isolated cottage he could see eastward to the Danube, and beyond. Outside, he roamed the fields and surrounding woods freely, yet his mood was "morose" according to Ferdinand Ries, the devoted pupil who visited him there.

Beethoven introduced the new symphony at Vienna on April 5, 1803, at a mammoth Akademie in the Theater an der Wien, along with the Third Piano Concerto (completed in 1800), a new oratorio, Christ on the Mount of Olives, and a repeat performance of the First Symphony from 1800. In the third movement of No. 2, the word scherzo appeared symphonically for the first time, although it retained a song and trio form, and was built on the sudden juxtapositions of loud and soft, with changes in their patterns just when he'd seemed to settle on one. The scoring, however, continued to employ traditional pairs of winds and brass, timpani, and strings.

An Adagio molto introduction anticipates the soft-loud contrasts that explode like Chinese firecrackers two movements later, although the sound and shape of it recall Haydn. The exposition begins in measure 35, with a main subject of Mozartian levitation, but thereafter Beethoven asserts his own less courtly and more confrontational personality.

As in the First Symphony, he wrote the first, second, and fourth movements in sonata form. The longest of them is this A major Larghetto in triple meter, if all the repeats are observed. Finding an accommodating tempo can pose problems: largo, after all, means "broad," the slowest tempo in music. Larghetto is a diminutive form -- i.e., not as slow -- but how slow (or not slow) remains the conductor's call.

After Beethoven's surprises in (as well as of) the scherzo, he chortles throughout a finale marked Allegro molto, mostly at his own syncopated jokes. They begin in the first measure and don't let up till the double-bar. Many of his contemporaries were shocked, and several reviled him in print. One Viennese critic, after a repeat performance in 1804, called Symphony No. 2 "a crass monster, a hideously writhing, wounded dragon that refuses to die and, though bleeding in the finale, furiously thrashes about with its stiffened tail." One should always keep posterity in mind whenever a spiky new piece tempts us to dismiss it without a trial (whereas easy-listening pieces tend to spoil as quickly as unrefrigerated seafood, and most should). -Description by Roger Dettmer



Link
  • Quote


Era: Classical
Year: 1807
Form: Symphony
Score: 87

They say the trick to good composition is to do something that says, gotcha - the "a ha" moments. Well the end of this symphony does just that - it's a trick on ending... it's simultaniously "spannend" and nearly annoying - wait I thought, wait... oh ok, oh maybe now... nope ok he's definitely, oh wait dude just started a silent violin part, he couldn't possibly be ending this... yup, Gotcha! Anyway, just like the 2nd, this is still quality, even if not the most popular, filled with the qualities we love from Beethoven's symphonies: solid rhythms and melodies in an almost punk rock style (half kidding), while simultaneously having dense complex sound palettes.


Link


Quote:
Robert Schumann described this symphony as "a slender Greek maiden between two Norse giants," and started the long-standing tradition which holds that somehow Beethoven's even-numbered symphonies are less profound than the odd-numbered ones. This may seem true at first glance, but there is much that Schumann's analysis leaves unsaid. While the lambent beauty of the Adagio might suggest the kind of Classicism that the Eroica transcended, one should remember that, in many senses, the Fourth, emerging from an intensely foreboding, and even tragic, introduction, is no less heroic than either the Eroica or the Fifth. Dark-hued and intensely chromatic strivings pull the music from B flat minor toward the unison F which heralds the beginning of the sunny Allegro vivace exposition. While Weber criticized the deliberately sparse-sounding introduction, Tovey sensed its immense stature, writing of the "sky-dome vastness" of its harmonic progression. The Adagio, a sonata structure minus development, begins with an insistent rhythm which recurs several times. At the start, the violins sing out the sublimely reflective principal motif, a tenderly lyrical utterance which stands in direct contrast to the opening figure. These two contrasting elements are always at the hub of the movement, the expressive violin theme later becoming the subject of variations. The reprise of the second group then leads to the highly atmospheric coda. What follows is the Scherzo; a bucolic main theme suggests the rustic folk-dance idioms that Beethoven knew well; nevertheless, the movement surpasses the Eroica's Scherzo in power and dynamism. It should be noted that this is the first of Beethoven's symphonic scherzos to feature a repeat of the trio section, which is significant, given the massive nature of the surrounding material. The scherzo is heard one last time, now abridged, before the shattering final coda with its three-bar horn solo. Expanded scherzos also figure in several of Beethoven's later symphonies (the exception is the Eighth), and sketches suggest the technique was originally envisaged for the Fifth. Opening with a series of mercurial sixteenth note fragments from which the first subject group is derived, the final movement is "perpetuum mobile." As the movement unfolds, the oboe's second theme provides contrast with the initial statement, the relentless development section posing serious technical challenges to the lower instruments: bassoon, cellos, and basses. In the coda, surely one of Beethoven's most humorous inventions, the theme is passed around at half speed after a "false" ending has been reached, and finally brushed aside dramatically as cellos and basses plummet down the scale before the striking final bars for full orchestra.
  • Quote
RoundTheBend wrote:

Beethoven: Piano Concerto No. 5 "E...saac Stern



I have this exact same recording. Both the Triple and the Emperor are marvelous. But they are heavy and require some focus to fully appreciate, so I don't break this one out all that often. Still, incredible music, exceptionally well presented.
  • Quote
RoundTheBend wrote:

I already said all of the piano concertos were fantastic for me. I'll just let the commentary and samples here speak for themselves. I think I like 3 more.


Link




Three has always been my favorite, but as you say, there's not a weak one in the bunch.

This is another wonderful performance.

New topic  Post reply
Topic Posters
All times are GMT
Goto page Previous  123 ... 464748 ... 106107108  Next
Page 47 of 108


 

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Similar Topics
Topic Author Forum
Sticky: Music Diaries SuedeSwede Music Diaries
An Idiot Listens to 2017 RoundTheBend Music Diaries
[ Poll ] Best Ever Western Films [LIST] badseed Tournaments
[ Poll ] Best Ever Western Films [POLL] badseed Tournaments
Grogg listens to music grogg Music Diaries

 
Member  Levels
Musicbuff123 Level 6
jr_uk_1234 Level 5
Karl_A Level 2
robaroni333 Level 2
Well done to all the members who levelled up this week! ๐ŸŽถ๐Ÿ™Œ
Back to Top
Best Ever Albums
Install BEA for an app-like experience.