New Editions

View previous topic :: View next topic
  • Quote
What is the policy with the new editions of old releases? And I mean essentially new and different edition. For example Wishbone Ash's Argus, originally released 1972. And the 2007 Deluxe Edition which includes 3 bonus tracks and a second disc: BBC radio one "In Concert" (recorded 1972).

Could it be added to BEA as a new separate album titled e.g. Argus (Deluxe Edition) 2007?
  • Quote
Ilolahti wrote:
What is the policy with the new editions of old releases? And I mean essentially new and different edition. For example Wishbone Ash's Argus, originally released 1972. And the 2007 Deluxe Edition which includes 3 bonus tracks and a second disc: BBC radio one "In Concert" (recorded 1972).

Could it be added to BEA as a new separate album titled e.g. Argus (Deluxe Edition) 2007?


I'm pretty sure the short answer is no. There are so many deluxe/expanded reissues of albums that it would be unrealistic, unwieldy, and frankly unworkable to create new listings for them. Now, if a newly compiled and released bonus disc eventually receives its own standalone release (like IN RAINBOWS DISK 2, for example), that would be eligible to be added to the database.
  • Quote
Ilolahti wrote:
What is the policy with the new editions of old releases? And I mean essentially new and different edition. For example Wishbone Ash's Argus, originally released 1972. And the 2007 Deluxe Edition which includes 3 bonus tracks and a second disc: BBC radio one "In Concert" (recorded 1972).

Could it be added to BEA as a new separate album titled e.g. Argus (Deluxe Edition) 2007?

BEA is policy is to only list the original version of each album. From the guidelines: "Different versions of the same album (e.g. re-issues, re-releases etc) are not listed (this stops the site being flooded by multiple versions of the same release). However, in the rare cases that the releases are entirely distinct, and not derived from each other (i.e. not sharing any of the same tracks), each distinct album may be added separately."
_________________
Bluesky ยท Facebook ยท Spotify
  • Quote
Thank you for your sensible answers. As noted, the answer could have been found from BEA guidelines. I'm sorry that I did not find it earlier.
  • Quote
Ilolahti wrote:
Thank you for your sensible answers. As noted, the answer could have been found from BEA guidelines. I'm sorry that I did not find it earlier.

No worries, the info is a bit tucked away tbf
_________________
Bluesky ยท Facebook ยท Spotify

New topic  Post reply
Topic Posters
All times are GMT

Page 1 of 1


 

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Similar Topics
Topic Author Forum
How to add or edit anniversary editio... capkronos Suggestions
Bonds Tracks / Deluxe Editions are th... meruizh Music
World album of the day (#474): New Br... albummaster Music
Thoughts on new Thrice album RoundTheBend Music
Possible problem with new album. Spyglass Suggestions

 
Happy  BEAnniversary
Hoddy2711 7 years
Timo 13 years
lh182 10 years
24kgoldie 11 years
Aitch 13 years
Slothe 4 years
NicoNoir 1 year
Charicature 18 years
SlackerShack 2 years
Rodrigomuniz 2 years
Happy BEAnniversary to everyone celebrating today! ๐ŸŽ‰
Back to Top
Best Ever Albums
Install BEA for an app-like experience.