... Everybody this week is buzzing about the new U2 album, Carnaval de Luz, the title of which is Spanish for "Carnival of Light," which was the title of this Ride album so they had to translate it into Spanish because Heaven forbid they might actually have to come up with a completely different title just to avoid accusations of Ride-plagiarism. That aside, I consider myself a U2 fan, and while I consider this new album (their 16th) to be almost their worst ever (it's not quite as bad as Songs of Experience), it does have some Spanish lyrics in it, like, here and there... so I'll accept that the title can be justified on that basis. (And if you think I'm making fun of them now, wait 'til you read the Paste Magazine review... among others.) ...
I have never been a fan of U2. I’ve always liked a couple of their well-known hits, but nothing more. Back in 2009, however, something unusual happened—there was a moment when I very nearly considered their album *No Line on the Horizon* the best of the year. But this was some kind of anomaly, a glitch in the group’s matrix. There is nothing unusual for me in this 2026 album—nothing that would fundamentally shift my attitude toward the band.
A completely different question, though, is: what’s going on with *Paste Magazine*? This is already the third attack I’m aware of against artists who have been heavily promoted by everyone in recent years. And even though I don’t follow *Paste Magazine* at all, I’d already heard about their similar takes on Taylor Swift and Fontaines D.C.—which suggests that someone put a lot of effort into making that happen.
It will be very interesting to see which album the publication ultimately crowns as the best of 2026, and where Fontaines D.C. and U2 end up on their list.
I don’t have any new albums to suggest here this week.
To keep the thread going, I’d like to mention a few albums from last week that have gradually reached that essential threshold—they’re worth checking out.
Jamie Porteous - It'll Get Better Before It Gets Better (3/XI-2026/45) (Album)
Мать Тереза [Mat Tereza] - Самозванцы (7/XI-2026/45) (Album)
Несладко [Nesladko] - Очень (6/XI-2026/45) (Album)
A completely different question, though, is: what’s going on with *Paste Magazine*? This is already the third attack I’m aware of against artists who have been heavily promoted by everyone in recent years. And even though I don’t follow *Paste Magazine* at all, I’d already heard about their similar takes on Taylor Swift and Fontaines D.C.—which suggests that someone put a lot of effort into making that happen.
Paste has always been an indie-rock site with an institutional fondness for bands and records from the 2002-2012 period (noting that the Editor-in-Chief, Matt Mitchell, really likedWestside Cowboy's new album which sounds like it came straight out of 2006, whereas a different Paste writer had this to say about the greatest album of all time). But I've never had the impression that they were a "puff-piece factory," or a bunch of music-industry cheerleaders or boot-lickers.
If anything, I'd expect them to bash U2 and Taylor Swift, since there's nothing "indie" about U2 or Taylor Swift, and as for Fontaines DC... I wouldn't say this review is an "attack," and it isn't even all that negative (though admittedly it wasn't as positive as what I wrote). It was written by the same guy who wrote the U2 review (Grant Sharples) though, so maybe it's just him.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum