I have generally struggled to appreciate Mahhler; a little morose for my tastes. But I wanted another go, so I took a suggestion to make my new attempted entry point his 4th Symphony.and it turned out to be a good one. I heard Mozartian melody and Haydenesque wit. This is still a big, romantic epic, but deftly executed classical balance. Mahler cleverly uses orchestration to develop musical personalities and have them interact and we get what sounds to like a broad swath of life itself, and considering its coming from Mahler, a surprisingly sunny outlook at that. Sure, there's a little gloom in the third movement, but it never threatens to overwhelm. Still, this is no lightweight piece. I once read tha Mahler once said "A symphony must be like the world; it must contain everything", Mahler puts his music where his mouth is and even this easygoing (by Mahler standards) symphony clocks in at over 52 minutes.
I really enjoyed it. In The Insider's Guide to Classical Recordings, Jim Svejda says "The fourth is as happy as Mahler can become and still remain Mahler." I think that sums up why this worked so well for me today. But will it be a gateway into general Mahler appreciation, or just an anomaly in the Mahler catalog that becomes a one off dead end? We'll see the next time I get a Mahler craving and decide to go after something darker and more... Mahlerian.
FischmanRockMonster, JazzMeister, Bluesboy,ClassicalMasterProfile Land of Enchantment
Johannes Brahms - Horn Trio, Op. 40 Year: 1865
Alexander Melnikov/Fortepiano
Isabelle Faust/Violin
Teunis van der Zwart/Horn
Rating: 4.25 Stars
I should be over being amazed by Brahms. Yet here again he has managed to not just amaze me, but amaze me in a totally unpredictable way. The structure of this piece is unlike any of Brahms's other works... or anything else I've heard for that matter. There's more slow across the first three movements than any such long form piece should have, and yet the combination of expertly formed beauty, built in expressiveness, and capivating flow and overall arc. Oh, and when the fireworks kick in in the final movement, its like tying up a beautiful wtlrapped gift with shiny, top quality ribbons and a beautiful bow.
And for this listen, its not just the composition, but also the performance. Maybe the use of period gave the performers extra insight, but they really seem to inhabit this peice from within, and the performance is breathtaking. I often associate period instruments with scratch or rough sounds, but there's no such issues here. In particular, Teunis van der Zwart brings forth such a gorgeous tone from his horn that alone makes this a worthwhile listen. But the rest is excellent as well; no weaknesses. No complaints.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum