FMT - R1: Janis Joplin def. Donna Summer [CLSD] - Tournaments

FMT - R1: Janis Joplin def. Donna Summer [CLSD]

Goto page 1, 2 Next

View previous topic :: View next topic

Poll: Who?

Janis Joplin:		64%	[11]
Donna Summer:		35%	[6]

Total Votes : 17

videoheadcleaner formerly Harkan Profile

JANIS JOPLIN (coach: itsit)

Thumbnail. Click to enlarge.

BEA Rank:
solo - 353 (2133 points)
with Big Brother And The Holding Company - 769 (773 points)

Highest BEA Album: Pearl (1971) - No. 474 (1845 points)

vs.

DONNA SUMMER (coach: vegetable man)

BEA Rank:
solo - 2951 (101 points)

Highest BEA Album: Live And More (1978) - No. 7901 (67 points)

Last edited by videoheadcleaner on 06/13/2012 08:10; edited 1 time in total

alelsupreme Awful. Profile

Link

Link

junodog4 Future Grumpy Old Man Profile
Location: Calgary

With all due respect to Donna Summer, this one isn't even close. 🫵 C'mon - it's Janis.

vegetable man Profile

Donna Summer was a class act and I feel a better career than Janis. Yes, Janis could screem. I'll give her that much. But palleeease, the girl was fugging ukly! 🧱

You gotta ask yourself one question. Who would you rather wake next to in the morning? 😨

AAAND, Donna Summer had 11 gold and platinum albums and 14 top ten singles. 😁

Janis did not. 🫢

Please think a bit before voting 🙏

Link

Link

Link

Link

_________________
He's the kind of person, you just gonna see him if you can,
Vegetable man.

Facetious Profile
Location: Somewhere you've never been

vegetable man wrote:

So it's all about who was more popular and better-looking?

Hayden Profile
Location: Japan

Janis. No competition. Pop fluff vs. actual music.
_________________
Doubles & Conch

GoJetsGo Profile

vegetable man wrote:

But palleeease, the girl was fugging ukly! 🧱

You gotta ask yourself one question. Who would you rather wake next to in the morning? 😨

Please think a bit before voting 🙏

Pretty sexist... I realize that image is a big part of the music industry, but we should not judge a female artist because we wouldn't want to bang her. Do you judge male artists by the same standard?

I did think. I voted Janis. Nothing against Donna Summer - she was a huge singer, but Janis Joplin is a much more signifigant artist.

Polythene Pam

What's wrong with voting on appearance? You would be lying to yourself if it wasn't a factor.

Voted for Janis 😁

GoJetsGo Profile

Polythene Pam wrote:

What's wrong with voting on appearance? You would be lying to yourself if it wasn't a factor.

Voted for Janis :mrgreen:

Veg wasn't just mentioning appearance. It was whether we'd want to 'bang' her. Dismissing a female artist because she's ugly is sexist.

I agree that appearance is a factor (image, sex appeal, etc..) but I think that Veg was giving it major creedence. More so than he should.

Bork Executive Hillbilly Profile
Location: Vinson Mountain, GA

Donna Summer was talented no doubt but Janis is more my type of music. A lot more.

Bang factor is irrelevant.

New topic Closed

Topic Posters
All times are GMT>
Goto page 1, 2 Next

Page 1 of 2

You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Topic	Author	Forum	Replies	Last Post
[ Poll ] FMT - R2: Tina Weymouth def. Janis Jo...	videoheadcleaner	Tournaments	5	07/04/2012 00:56 videoheadcleaner
RIP Donna Summer	RFNAPLES	Music	12	05/24/2012 17:04 Charicature
Bad Girls by Donna Summer	Johnnyo	Music	9	02/27/2026 09:08 Johnnyo
[ Poll ] SST ROUND 2: Summer Babe vs. (Here Co...	revolver94	Tournaments	2	07/10/2015 16:35 revolver94
[ Poll ] FMT - R1: Christine McVie def. Pat Be...	videoheadcleaner	Tournaments	2	06/28/2012 12:11 videoheadcleaner