I just got back from mowing my lawn and the such while listening to these (I was going to listen to some mix of mine, but then this inspired me otherwise).
It's the 3rd genre listed in Wikipedia. I think if one can tie it to another source claiming it as such, it's legit.
When I think about the album, I kind of think of side one as the Rock side and side two as the electronic/ ambient side. To me, side one functions as more or less Rock songs, even though it's 90% electronic. It just feels like rock to me more than anything. But side 2 is simply electronic music. And I think it's telling that when he first went to make the album, he first tried to enlist Tangerine Dream to collaborate with, and then Kraftwerk. But those didn't work out I guess. And Eno, who he eventually made it with, was an electronic artist. So he was definitely thinking electronic. But like I said, I think of it as both. Rock and electronic.
RoundTheBendI miss the comfort in being sadProfile Ground Control
When I think about the album, I kind of think of side one as the Rock side and side two as the electronic/ ambient side. To me, side one functions as more or less Rock songs, even though it's 90% electronic. It just feels like rock to me more than anything. But side 2 is simply electronic music. And I think it's telling that when he first went to make the album, he first tried to enlist Tangerine Dream to collaborate with, and then Kraftwerk. But those didn't work out I guess. And Eno, who he eventually made it with, was an electronic artist. So he was definitely thinking electronic. But like I said, I think of it as both. Rock and electronic.
Sometimes the man-machine is my favorite Kraftwerk and sometimes it's not. Heh heh. There's two or three by them that at different times have been my favorite.
I like most of the albums on that list, but off the wall by Michael Jackson and Saturday Night Fever are totally off base. There's little if any electronic music on those albums. Except for the odd synthesizer or two.The person who made the list must consider any dance or Disco music to be electronic music. But only a very small amount of it was. Today practically all dance music is electronic, but definitely not back then. .
It's the 3rd genre listed in Wikipedia. I think if one can tie it to another source claiming it as such, it's legit.
Rate Your Music also lists it 3rd as electronic. And also ambient. But as far as I'm concerned it's all in the eye of the beholder. Especially when they start giving something eight or nine different genre tags.
That'd mean artist like Michael Jackson or Daft Punk couldn't play. It's primarily electronic music... electronic music does not ostracize guitars from the genre as far as I can tell, but the way the guitar plays a role in electronic music is entirely different than in rock music. Same with bass guitar -there's live tracked bass guitars in rap music/electronic music, etc... that doesn't mean it's rock music.
I didn't mean to imply that guitars couldn't be used. When Young Punk asked if guitars counted, I took it to mean he was asking if albums where there were no synthesizers and only guitar could be included. I don't know, maybe something like a White Stripes album?
Last edited by PurpleHazel on 05/20/2018 02:44; edited 2 times in total
And Eno, who he eventually made it with, was an electronic artist.
At the time, Eno was using regular drums, bass and guitar on a majority of his albums, though they would become more electronic shortly after. But, as big an electronic music fan as you are, if you say something's electronic, that's good enough for me.
aight so I still think this is way too vague to be a good idea and I don't like it BUT I'm also a complete hypocrite and at least this isn't vaguely racist like the "regional music" one if you can't beat em join em so w/e here's some jams
That'd mean artist like Michael Jackson or Daft Punk couldn't play. It's primarily electronic music... electronic music does not ostracize guitars from the genre as far as I can tell, but the way the guitar plays a role in electronic music is entirely different than in rock music. Same with bass guitar -there's live tracked bass guitars in rap music/electronic music, etc... that doesn't mean it's rock music.
I didn't mean to imply that guitars couldn't be used. When Young Punk asked if guitars counted, I took it to mean he was asking if albums where there were no synthesizers and only guitar could be included. I don't know, maybe something like a White Stripes album? Turns out he's listened to more conventionally electronic albums than I have!
Oh for sure - I'm agreeing with both and saying it's not quite that straightforward, but usually when guitar is used, it is starting to meander into another genre, pending on stuff. Like that passengers album I posted technically is labeled 1) Experimental, 2) Ambient, 3) Electronica... yet most of the instrumentation is from the members of U2 playing guitar, bass, and drums... even if there's a claim that "we didn't let Larry play the drums". It's in my opinion 80% not electronic... but totally isn't a rock record either.
I didn't think you were agreeing with no guitars at all and understood that when you said the basis of instrumentation wasn't guitar, but that didn't mean it fully excluded it either.
It is hard sometimes, I think, for "rockists" to get into Stockhausen or Eno's ambient work.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum