2017 Championship Tournament: Play-In Game #5

Goto page Previous  12
View previous topic :: View next topic

Poll: Please listen to both albums in full before voting, then choose your favorite.
Playboi Carti by Playboi Carti:
35%
 35%  [5]
Glow And Fade by Steve Kilbey & Martin Kennedy:
64%
 64%  [9]
Total Votes : 14

  • Quote
I've been a fan of The Church since the 80's so easy win to Kilbey & Kennedy here. The first two tracks are really good but every one is better than anything from Playboi Carti, which surprisingly I didn't actively dislike, I was just a bit bored througjout it.
  • Quote
Tilly wrote:
craola wrote:
Tilly wrote:
Coldplay moves to Australia and decides to try being a space rock band.

It's okay, but it has a distinctive Coldplay/Travis getting spacey vibe to it. Or Zero 7.

I mean THIS is space rock ...

i mean, steve kilbey has been making music in this vein since before chris martin was born.

What I wrote is what popped up in my head. My opinion at the time. No biggie. Just not my thing.

i mean, yeah, like or dislike whatever. that's fine. and this isn't so much aimed at you as it is this shitty coldplay act you metioned. i've heard people say that u2 sounds too much like coldplay. i've heard people say radiohead sounds too much like coldplay. i've heard people say talk talk sounds too much like coldplay. and now i'm hearing steve kilbey (frikkin the church) sounds too much like coldplay. not only have all of these artists been around since before chris martin was potty-trained, but they've all released great albums. and people blow 'em off over this shitty band of copycats.

i mean, it's fine to not love steve kilbey, but at least dislike it on its own merits and not because a cat-whelping fanboy wrote yellow, nonsensical drivel in its honor.

and yeah, it's even fine to like coldplay, i guess.

um, as for travis and zero 7, just yikes and yowies.
_________________
follow me on the bandcamp.
  • Quote
craola wrote:
Tilly wrote:
craola wrote:
Tilly wrote:
Coldplay moves to Australia and decides to try being a space rock band.

It's okay, but it has a distinctive Coldplay/Travis getting spacey vibe to it. Or Zero 7.

I mean THIS is space rock ...

i mean, steve kilbey has been making music in this vein since before chris martin was born.

What I wrote is what popped up in my head. My opinion at the time. No biggie. Just not my thing.

i mean, yeah, like or dislike whatever. that's fine. and this isn't so much aimed at you as it is this shitty coldplay act you metioned. i've heard people say that u2 sounds too much like coldplay. i've heard people say radiohead sounds too much like coldplay. i've heard people say talk talk sounds too much like coldplay. and now i'm hearing steve kilbey (frikkin the church) sounds too much like coldplay. not only have all of these artists been around since before chris martin was potty-trained, but they've all released great albums. and people blow 'em off over this shitty band of copycats.

i mean, it's fine to not love steve kilbey, but at least dislike it on its own merits and not because a cat-whelping fanboy wrote yellow, nonsensical drivel in its honor.

and yeah, it's even fine to like coldplay, i guess.

um, as for travis and zero 7, just yikes and yowies.


lol. Yeah! I actually hear you on that one. Comparing bands to Coldplay is weak, generic and lame. Time to get new material! I will do better. ๐Ÿ˜„

And I've actually been meaning to check out The Church! I hear their entire discog is pretty amazing. I only really know them from that huge single that was super big in the States back in the 80s -"Under The Milky Way"
  • Quote
Wow, Glow And Fade was simply gorgeous front-to-back and appropriately otherworldly. Beautiful music to match beautiful cover art. It's definitely my favorite discovery from this tournament to date, and is already in my top 20 for the year.

I like this Playboi Carti record about as much as his more acclaimed new album Die Lit. The beats are excellent, and the first seven tracks are great, but then it really falls off in quality for the next eight. By the end it feels like a slog. To Skinny's point, there are rappers who make me feel too old, but Playboi Carti is not one of them. Unfortunately, while he's put out a lot of bangers, he has yet to make a consistently quality project.
_________________
Join us in the canon game :) / Add me on RYM
  • Quote
I really liked the Steve Kilby album: the first names that Come to mind are Pink Floyd, Steven Wilson and indeed the Church, a band I really liked; sorry Tilly not Coldplay; especially The Game Never Changes is an epic and spacey highlight: this will be one for personal chart of 2017 and miles ahead of that other choice we had here.
  • Quote
I feel accomplished enough in making a bunch of oldies listen to carti hehe
_________________
  • Quote
SuedeSwede wrote:
I feel accomplished enough in making a bunch of oldies listen to carti hehe


Nice. Going down better than Drakeo, at any rate.
_________________
2021 in full effect. Come drop me some recs. Y'all know what I like.
  • Quote
dihansse wrote:
I really liked the Steve Kilby album: the first names that Come to mind are Pink Floyd, Steven Wilson and indeed the Church, a band I really liked; sorry Tilly not Coldplay; especially The Game Never Changes is an epic and spacey highlight: this will be one for personal chart of 2017 and miles ahead of that other choice we had here.


lol. No worries. Totally agree with it sounding like Pink Floyd. The good thing is that it's turned me on to The Church - a band I just didn't get back in the late 80s/early 90s when they were a mild hit in the States. Been digging those albums this time around so we'll see. May have to get ready to eat some crow. lol
  • Quote
SuedeSwede wrote:
I feel accomplished enough in making a bunch of oldies listen to carti hehe


lol. I really like it! Especially when it's late night & I've had one too many beers.

Great to see you back around! ๐Ÿ˜

New topic  Closed
Topic Posters
All times are GMT
Goto page Previous  12
Page 2 of 2


 

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Similar Topics
Topic Author Forum
[ Poll ] 2017 Championship Tournament: Play-In... baystateoftheart Tournaments
[ Poll ] 2017 Championship Tournament: Play-In... baystateoftheart Tournaments
[ Poll ] 2017 Championship Tournament: Play-In... baystateoftheart Tournaments
[ Poll ] 2017 Championship Tournament: Play-In... baystateoftheart Tournaments
[ Poll ] 2017 Championship Tournament: Play-In... baystateoftheart Tournaments

 
Member  Levels
Musicbuff123 Level 6
jr_uk_1234 Level 4
John2405 Level 2
robaroni333 Level 2
Well done to all the members who levelled up this week! ๐ŸŽถ๐Ÿ™Œ
Back to Top
Best Ever Albums
Install BEA for an app-like experience.