2025 Rating Tournament Diary

Goto page Previous  1234567
View previous topic :: View next topic
  • Quote
My own picks in three categories for the round based on the results of February 2026.

Albums
Tōth - And The Voice Said (27/II-2026/09) (Album)

And The Voice Said (2026) by Tōth
Tournament ranking – #8
Number of points – «+11»
lead over the nearest pursuer in points – 1
A spot on my list – #1, points – «+10»
Position on the list AOTY - #NR
Position on the list BEA - #1089

It all began, of course, with my fondness for the band Rubblebucket. It was love at second sight.
At first, I enjoyed a few tracks from their 2018 album, but then I truly fell for a live performance video of their song "Party Like Your Heart Hurts"—a track that, incidentally, had initially flown under my radar.
I’m not one to look into the inner workings of musicians; even lyrics in languages I don’t know are something I process on a purely subconscious level. Consequently, it was only while preparing for this review that I learned about the interpersonal dynamics within the group—and the reasons behind the emergence of a new project called Tōth.
All of this served as yet another reminder of the invisible threads that allow us to empathize with people who might seem distant, yet are, in spirit, so very close to us.

As is often the case, there were some coincidences—a recurring theme that has run like a common thread throughout this entire year. As it turned out, one of the goals in designing the cover was to move away from a "glossy mask"—the kind one might hide behind—in order to convey raw, authentic human emotions.

Tōth - Easy (Live with Brooklyn Choir Project) (22/VII-2026/43) (Video)

Link
  • Quote
My own picks in three categories for the round based on the results of February 2026.

Tracks
hemlocke springs - be the girl! (13/II-2026/07) (Single)

Tournament ranking – #5
Number of points – «+17»
lead over the nearest pursuer in points – 1
A spot on my list – #1, points – «+10» (awards from me – Release of the Week 2026/07)
Position on the list AOTY - #346
Position on the list BEA - #---

As it happens, I mentioned this artist’s name quite recently in the context of her style—implying, perhaps, that I was something of an expert on her work. In reality, that’s not the case at all. I truly loved her 2023 debut album—though some might not even consider it a "proper" full-length record—but it felt like a breath of fresh air, filled with vivid, memorable melodies.
I can’t say the same for her 2026 album as a whole, yet the final track stands out significantly from the rest, effectively softening any slight disappointment I might have felt toward the album otherwise.
For me, the track follows an ideal, progressively building structure.
If one chooses to, it’s easy enough to view all the preceding songs as a prelude to the album’s main event.
There’s an interesting parallel here: the themes in this song resonate with the reflections that permeate the album by Tōth.
Both artists are grappling with finding their place in a world that has changed drastically for them.

hemlocke springs - the apple tree under the sea (13/II-2026/07) (Album)

The Apple Tree Under The Sea (2026) by Hemlocke Springs
  • Quote
My own picks in three categories for the round based on the results of February 2026.

Music Videos
Punchbag - I Am Obsessed (4/II-2026/06) (Video)

Link

Tournament ranking – #11
Number of points – «+10»
lead over the nearest pursuer in points – 1
A spot on my list – #1, points – «+10» (awards from me – Release of the Week 2026/06)
Position on the list AOTY - #--- (Single)
Position on the list BEA - #---

Unlike the other two categories in this round, the video I’ve chosen features musicians who are completely unknown to me. As I’ve mentioned before, it’s not my habit to form a personal connection with artists by taking an interest in who they are as individuals. In fact, it’s fair to say that this particular choice was somewhat accidental—
I didn’t find anything else in their EP from this year that really grabbed me.
On the other hand, the video itself truly stands out due to its sheer energy.
This, in turn, resonates with the two other February releases I instinctively selected for the other categories in this round.
The common theme is that of a toxic, obsessive fixation on someone or something.
Across all three releases, the artists reject a "polished," commercial sound in favor of raw, honest emotion.

Punchbag - I Am Obsessed (10/IV-2026/15) (EP)
  • Quote
Below are new applications for the current round, which ends on November 12. November 10 is the last day to make changes to the current round's charts.

Music Videos: Guide (A-Z) (NEW)
1. Horse Lords - First Galactic Utopia (28/IV) Krautrock
2. Mette - Coming Of Age (8/IV) Dance-Pop
3. Raye - Click Clack Symphony. (ft. Hans Zimmer) (20/III) Orchestral Pop

Tracks: Guide (A-Z) (NEW)
1. Black Label Society - Name In Blood (14/I) Heavy Metal
2. Choir Boy - I'll Always Let You Down (16/IV) Synthpop
3. Deep Purple - Arrogant Boy (13/V) Hard Rock
4. Evanescence - Who Will You Follow (10/IV) Alternative Metal
5. Hayeminol - Syntetisk brennesle (16/I) Art Punk

Albums: Guide (A-Z) (NEW)
1. Hayeminol - Ingen Vår I År (16/I) Art Punk
2. Steven Wilson - Requiem For A Village (6/XI) Art Rock
3. Золотые Зубы, Иван Лужков [Zolotyye Zuby, Ivan Luzhkov] - Нет, Это Я Хочу Умереть в Новом Орлеане (10/IV) Art Pop
  • Quote
My thoughts regarding the awards in the three categories of the fourth round—provisionally designated as #10.

Albums
Paul McCartney - The Boys of Dungeon Lane (29/V-2026/22) (Album)

The Boys Of Dungeon Lane (2026) by Paul McCartney
Tournament ranking – #4, (rewards: a star (☆) and the right to an additional entry in a category; a team star (★) and the right to a "super entry" in any category)
Number of points – «+21»
lead over the nearest pursuer in points – 0,11
A spot on my list – #2, points – «+9»
Position on the list AOTY - #59
Position on the list BEA - #6

I must confess, I didn’t even bother listening to the album when it was released this May. I had such a strong, preconceived notion that it would be something artificial and forgettable.
Perhaps this was because the singles failed to grab my attention—or, in some cases, were simply unavailable due to being blocked in Russia.
It was only because of the tournament that I ended up listening to the album from start to finish. Now, it firmly holds a top spot in my tournament rankings.
And the fact that the release even won an award in the tournament prompted me to wonder: what, exactly, are the songs actually about?
As is often the case, I’m left with no choice but to chalk it all up to something mystical.
The members of The Beatles are the same age as my parents. It’s as if this cross-generational connection has come full circle—our stories and our experiences repeat themselves. Across time and space, we continue to support one another, like the closest of kindred spirits.

Music Videos
Paul McCartney - Days We Left Behind (Live) (17/V-2026/20) (Video)

Link

Tournament ranking – #4, (rewards: a star (☆) and the right to an additional entry in a category)
Number of points – «+20»
lead over the nearest pursuer in points – 3
A spot on my list – #4, points – «+7»
Position on the list AOTY - #874 (Single)
Position on the list BEA - #--- (Track)

It took me a while to warm up to the melody of this song. Perhaps it was this particular video—featuring archival photographs—that made me pause, encouraging me to linger longer than the usual few seconds and watch the whole thing through to the end.
It’s clear to me that, musically speaking, there are more compelling tracks on the album. But in this instance, the choice wasn’t driven by commercial considerations; it was simply what the artist wanted. And really, who else today has the luxury of doing that? Ultimately, the complex journey toward fully grasping the album—as a release that unfolds gradually—only added to its significance.
  • Quote
My thoughts regarding the awards in the three categories of the fourth round—provisionally designated as #10.

Tracks
Starbenders - Summon My Heart (10/II-2026/07) (Single)

Link

Tournament ranking – #4, (rewards: a star (☆) and the right to an additional entry in a category)
Number of points – «+22»
lead over the nearest pursuer in points – 5
A spot on my list – #2, points – «+9»
Position on the list AOTY - #---
Position on the list BEA - #---

I thought I wouldn’t have anything at all to say about this track. While I’ve known the band Starbenders for a long time, my familiarity with them was mostly limited to their flashy music videos. This time around, however, the album features several genuine hits. Unfortunately, that didn’t change my overall impression of the release—it still feels more like a collection of individual songs than a cohesive work. That said, the information I uncovered—thanks, once again, to this tournament prize—has helped clear up a few mysteries that had been piling up in my life like a snowball lately.
Now, at the very least, I understand why this song turned out so melodic, and why its release as a single was timed to coincide with the launch of the full album. It turns out that Caroline Kingsbury—whose debut album, *Heaven's Just A Flight* (2021), left a very positive impression on me—contributed to this track. Regrettably, Caroline’s subsequent releases haven’t been quite as compelling, which might well be explained by her taking on these kinds of side projects.
As for Starbenders themselves, I’ll almost certainly be revisiting them in future reviews, so perhaps it’s best to keep a bit of mystery intact for now.

Starbenders - The Beast Goes On (27/II-2026/09) (Album)

The Beast Goes On (2026) by Starbenders

New topic  Post reply
Topic Posters
All times are GMT
Goto page Previous  1234567
Page 7 of 7


 

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Similar Topics
Topic Author Forum
Looking for ideas for rating tracks i... JoshN125 Music
2025 BRACKETS- Best Song Tournament cestuneblague Tournaments
[ Poll ] 2025 songs tournament NOMINATIONS is ... cestuneblague Tournaments
[ Poll ] 2025.... anything? tournament cestuneblague Tournaments
Rating Compact Albums videoheadcleaner Music

 
Happy  BEAnniversary
slappthetree 2 years
DannyBarr666 6 years
DaiWyn64 4 years
nixso 1 year
Leedslassie 2 years
F1Aaron 12 years
ofekyem 12 years
DIRKFLOYD 11 years
tbound2 2 years
carlsc 2 years
Celebrating the members who make BEA special! 🎂
Back to Top
Best Ever Albums
Install BEA for an app-like experience.