How would you Weezer fans rate thier albums?

Goto page 1, 2, 3 Next

View previous topic :: View next topic

Imbacktosavethuniverse Profile
Hampton, New Hampshire

Here's Mine:

Blue album- B+
Pinkerton album- A-
Green Album- B+
Maladriot Album- B
Make Believe album- C
Red Album- A-
Raditude- D+
Hurley- B-

Death to false metal- B

purple

I'd rate both Blue Album and Pinkerton A-

those are the only albums of theirs I've heard in full so...

cartoken The Seer Profile
Paris

1. Weezer (blue album) 85/100
2. Hurley 55/100
3. Pinkerton 50/100
4. Weezer (Red Album) 50/100
5. Raditude 40/100

Hayden Profile
Japan

1. Blue Album - 90/100
2. Raditude - 75/100
3. Pinkerton - 70/100
4. Red Album - 45/100

That's all I've heard from them...
_________________
Doubles & Conch

Wombi

1. Weezer (Blue) 90/100
2. Pinkerton 85/100
3. Weezer (Red) 65/100
4. Hurley 55/100
5. Weezer (Green) 35/100

Bork Executive Hillbilly Profile
Vinson Mountain, GA

Raditude - 3.70
Pinkerton - 3.45
Weezer (blue) - 3.40
Weezer (red) - 3.35
Weezer (green) - 3.15

5 is max, although the highest rating handed out is 4.57 (so far).
4+ is a masterpiece, 3.75+ is great, 3.50+ is very good, 3.25+ is good.

mooseboy101 Profile
Geneva

Blue Album - 85/100
Pinkerton - 80/100
Green Album - 65/100
Make Believe - 40/100
Red Album - 55/100

Those are the only ones I've listened to.
_________________
sig

bcaie16 Profile
Toronto

Pinkerton 95/100
Blue Album 90/100
.
.
.
.
Rest is garbage.

Applerill Autistic Princess <3 Profile
Chicago

I'll admit it: I'm an absolute Weezer fanboy. There's not really a single of their albums that I hate, not even Raditude anymore.

The Blue Album: 10 (just about tied with Pinkerton)
Pinkerton: 10 (my favorite album of all time BTW)
The Green Album: 8
Maladroit: 6.5
Make Believe:7.5
The Red Album: 8
Raditude:7.5
Hurley: 7

Ironic Karma Profile
Kansas

The Blue Album: 9.0/10
Pinkerton: 9.3/10
The Green Album: 5.9/10
Maladroit - 7.4/10
Make Believe - 4.4/10
The Red Album - 5.0/10
Raditude - 2.4/10
Hurley - 7.3/10

New topic Closed

Topic Posters
All times are GMT>
Goto page 1, 2, 3 Next

Page 1 of 3

You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Topic	Author	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Sticky: How Did You Get Here?	Jackwc	New Members	226	07/16/2025 16:35 Johnnyo
Sticky: What album are you listening to? (cont.)	albummaster	Music	37561	07/02/2026 14:09 pedro1976
Weezer fans, Blue Album and Pinkerton...	CA Dreamin	Music	10	10/05/2014 08:49 CA Dreamin
Which lyricist would you rate over Bo...	DarkSideOfTheComputer	Music	55	12/22/2016 14:01 desh79
Album of the day (#358): Weezer (The ...	BestEverAlbums	Music	11	11/05/2011 08:35 Xavygravy