[Kiki]

There is only one right choice here!

[jstreets]

Both seminal songwriters that were achingly affective with their voices and acoustics alone.

1. Pink Moon
2. Either/Or
3. XO
4. Elliot Smith
5. Five Leaves Left
6. Bryter Layter
7. Figure 8
8. Roman Candle

[joyofdivision]

Love them both but Elliott has the overall edge for me..

1. Pink Moon
2. Either/Or
3. Figure 8
4. XO
5. New Moon
6. Bryter Layter
7. Elliott Smith
8. Roman Candle
9. From A Basement On The Hill
10. Five Leaves Left