Best Songwriters 3: The Beck Ultimatum

View previous topic :: View next topic

Poll: How's your day been?

Dope:

14%

[1]

Meh:

28%

[2]

Rubbish:

28%

[2]

I just missed you so much Bozo:

14%

[1]

Carrots:

14%

[1]

Total Votes : 7

BozoTyrannus Profile

Alright, alright, so I missed the deadline. I know you've all been staying up late at night, wracked with pain and suspense, just wasting away inside as you await with baited breath the results of this tournament. Well, wait no more, as at long last the results have been revealed, and once more your life has meaning! Huzzah!

First up, who got knocked out?
Lou Reed, Victor Jara (may his reputation be spread on BEA thanks to this, but also apologies for imprinting the wrong spelling in everyone's minds), Beck, Matt Berninger, Neko Case, Cole Porter (he didn't have that thing), Nick Drake (wait, what??), and Josh Tillman

Leaving us with what, exactly, as our round three matchup?

3a: Daniel Dumile vs. Tom Waits
3b: Janelle Monáe vs. Phil Elverum
3c: billy woods vs. Van Morrison
3d: André 3000 vs. Bill Callllahan

(and yes, if you check the math of the last round, you'll see Lou Reed and Daniel Dumile were tied. I only vote in tie breakers, so I gave it to Dumile)
_________________
I wanna take Sean Penn
And take Sean Bean
Put 'em in a blender
And make Sean Pean

RoundTheBend I miss the comfort in being sad Profile
Location: Ground Control

🤣

Much tear for the Beck loss but makes sense for those who are playing.

3a: Daniel Dumile vs. Tom Waits
3b: Janelle Monáe vs. Phil Elverum
3c: billy woods vs. Van Morrison
3d: André 3000 vs. Bill Callllahan

I haven't really been too taken by Daniel Dumile's projects. I remember being excited to listen to Madvillainy cuz all the hype and was greatly disappointed. Then the Mm food with MF doom and while I liked that better wasn't like woah, this is the shit! It's probably me being boring, but it just never has done anything for me. On the other hand Tom Waits is incredibly clever and heartfelt and insane. My favorite part about Tom Waits is his role in Mystery Men. well not really, but it's hysterical nonetheless.

Janelle I jam to, I don't really even pay attention to the lyrics most times to honest. The only thing I can really remember her saying is this is what they call classy Brass. So nothing that really is of importance, whereas Phil Elverum made me cry and blew my mind.

Billy Woods was a first listen this year for me. It was pretty good, but again nothing really stood out to me as shit my pants worthy. Van Morrison's work with the single Brown Eyed girl would be enough to make me vote here, but then all the other work he did is 10x even more amazing. Brown Eyed Girl is easily one of the greatest pop songs ever written tho.

Bill Callllahan is also someone new to me this year. Didn't leave that great of an impression on me. André 3000 though is easily top rapper for me for so many reasons, but if you just want to focus on the formalist approach, dude's flow is unbelievably smooth and complex, yet it doesn't feel like it. It just works and you don't even have to think about it, but if you do your mind is blown how he pulls some of that stuff off. Like nobody else could. But then move to his style and not just the words and it's like wow, I didn't think this could get better and it just keeps getting better. Plus his wild side is a bit crazy.

So possibly if I played like some other players with the obstain, I'd only really feel pretty good about my first two votes and the last two I've only listened enough to not be guessing here/maybe I'll give them another spin and revisit pending deadline. But even if I did it was like the argument earlier - I'm going to have a VERY hard time voting against those picks because they've provided a lifetime of great lyrics/songwriting to me and the others I'm like huh?

Fischman RockMonster, JazzMeister, Bluesboy,ClassicalMaster Profile
Location: Land of Enchantment

3a: Daniel Dumile vs. Tom Waits
3b: Janelle Monáe vs. Phil Elverum
3c: billy woods vs. Van Morrison
3d: André 3000 vs. Bill Callllahan

LedZep Profile

3a: Daniel Dumile vs. Tom Waits
3b: Janelle Monáe vs. Phil Elverum
3c: billy woods vs. Van Morrison
3d: André 3000 vs. Bill Callahan (abstain)
_________________
Overall chart
Fake overall chart

2020s

babyBlueSedan Used to be sort of blind, now can sort of see Profile

3a: Daniel Dumile vs. Tom Waits
3b: Janelle Monáe vs. Phil Elverum
3c: billy woods vs. Van Morrison
3d: André 3000 vs. Bill Callllahan
_________________
And it's hard to be a human being. And it's harder as anything else.

Spyglass Resident Metalhead Profile
Location: The red dot on the map

3a: Daniel Dumile vs. Tom Waits
3b: Janelle Monáe vs. Phil Elverum
3c: billy woods vs. Van Morrison
3d: André 3000 vs. Bill Callllahan
_________________
Do it yourself and let me play my music: https://www.besteveralbums.com/thechart.php?c=61802

baystateoftheart Neil Young as a butternut squash Profile
Location: Massachusetts

3a: Daniel Dumile vs. Tom Waits
3b: Janelle Monáe vs. Phil Elverum
3c: billy woods vs. Van Morrison
3d: André 3000 vs. Bill Callahan
_________________
Join us in the canon game :) / Add me on RYM

NewsFromHome

Tom Waits
Phil Elverum
Van Morrison
Bill Callahan (by like a hair - prefer Andre's music but Bill's lyrical ability)

junodog4 Future Grumpy Old Man Profile
Location: Calgary

3a: Daniel Dumile vs. Tom Waits
3b: Janelle Monáe vs. Phil Elverum
3c: billy woods vs. Van Morrison
3d: André 3000 vs. Bill Callllahan
_________________
Finnegan was super bad-ass.

AwaitingAndrew Profile

3a: Daniel Dumile vs. Tom Waits
3b: Janelle Monáe vs. Phil Elverum
3c: billy woods vs. Van Morrison
3d: André 3000 vs. Bill Callahan

New topic Closed

Topic Posters
All times are GMT>

Page 1 of 1

You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Topic	Author	Forum	Replies	Last Post
[ Poll ] Best Songwriters 5L Goes West	BozoTyrannus	Tournaments	9	10/17/2020 01:51 baystateoftheart
Best Songwriters Redux [CLOSED. GET O...	BozoTyrannus	Tournaments	49	07/26/2020 12:13 BozoTyrannus
[ Poll ] Best Songwriters 4: Score and Seven Y...	BozoTyrannus	Tournaments	6	10/01/2020 23:34 baystateoftheart
Best Songwriters [CLOSED]	BozoTyrannus	Tournaments	36	05/19/2020 02:09 RoundTheBend
[ Poll ] Best Songwriters 2: Electric Boogaloo	BozoTyrannus	Tournaments	18	09/15/2020 19:12 BozoTyrannus