[videoheadcleaner]

MY BLOODY VALENTINE (Coach: Cymro2011)

BEA Rank: 39

seeded (R1)
def. Young Marble Giants (R2)
def. Husker Du (SF1)

PPNW?

Link


Vs.

NEW ORDER (Coach: drakonium)

BEA Rank: 159

seeded (R1)
def. Women (R2)
def. Nick Cave And The Bad Seeds (SF1)

PPNW?

Link


YOU DECIDE!

[drakonium]

Get MBV the fuck out of this tournament! Also, New Order is pretty good, too.

[nutso42]

What drakonium said (more or less).

MBV are a better band, but New Order are a better PPNW band.

[Silver]

My Bloody Valentine are a top 10 band for me, but they shouldn't be in this tournament. New Order are alright, I've never been into either them or Joy Division, but they certainly fit the tourney. I'll just abstain, don't really care for voting against MBV but I know they shouldn't be in this tournament.

[Mercury]

New Order, I guess.
_________________
-Ryan

ONLY 4% of people can understand this chart! Come try!

My Fave Metal - you won't believe #5!!!

[Facetious]

MBV's post-punk stuff sucks, that might give New Order an advantage over them.......

[Guest]

When I clicked submit, I was expecting there to be a huge MBV lead. I'm pleasantly surprised at the results so far. Anyway, I voted for New Order because I actually kinda like them more.

[Cymro2011]

Thank fuck.

[ColumnatedRuins]

Very very much prefer My Bloody Valentine and I quite dislike New Order, but I abstained. Mostly because the stuff I like from MBV can't be called Post-Punk even by the loosest definition of the genre, in my opinion (and I'm all for loose, inclusive genre parameters).

But I don't even like New Order enough to vote for them in good conscience I suppose. Especially against MBV, which is one of my favorite guitar bands ever.

[Facetious]