How to Critique "Experimental" Music (or art)?

Goto page Previous  123
View previous topic :: View next topic
  • Quote
Absolutely agree and more or less what I was saying.

Also I heard that 4:33 was supposed to be performed outside, so actually it wasn't complete silence, but has since taken on the various forms of it's performance interpretation. It's music you actually turn the pages to, etc.
  • Quote
experimental music doesn't mean experiments happened, all it means is that the listener gave up on actually categorizing it. lots of music in the past was experimental but people didn't give up and they actually categorized it.

so experimental music does pose particular challenges because part of what you need to do is make it not experimental music anymore.
  • Quote
What is the best instrumentation for 4:33? Is it solo piano or full orchestra? How 'bout string quartet? Maybe it's that scorching rendition by a red hot trumpeter. I played it on my kazoo and got no applause at all ๐Ÿซข

And what if a conductor slows the tempo and it ends up taking 4:38? Is he a dreadful hack who should never be allowed on the podium or is he a great visionary bringing a radical new interpretation to be praised?
  • Quote
sethmadsen wrote:
Absolutely agree and more or less what I was saying.

๐Ÿ˜„
Quote:

Also I heard that 4:33 was supposed to be performed outside, so actually it wasn't complete silence, but has since taken on the various forms of it's performance interpretation. It's music you actually turn the pages to, etc.


Yeah I read that too: you hear what's outside or in the room at the time. I like it: it seems quite a punk rock thing to do (still, I'm not sure if I would part with my cash for this experience) I think I was just raising those examples as I think there is a danger of over--thinking responses to unconventional forms of expression ('What is the purpose of this? Etc), which could be a barrier to just experiencing it and being moved in some way.
  • Quote
Fischman wrote:
What is the best instrumentation for 4:33? Is it solo piano or full orchestra? How 'bout string quartet? Maybe it's that scorching rendition by a red hot trumpeter. I played it on my kazoo and got no applause at all ๐Ÿซข

And what if a conductor slows the tempo and it ends up taking 4:38? Is he a dreadful hack who should never be allowed on the podium or is he a great visionary bringing a radical new interpretation to be praised?


๐Ÿคฃ ๐Ÿ‘

That's funny- I posted about not over-thinking before I read this!
  • Quote
Tap wrote:
experimental music doesn't mean experiments happened, all it means is that the listener gave up on actually categorizing it. lots of music in the past was experimental but people didn't give up and they actually categorized it.

so experimental music does pose particular challenges because part of what you need to do is make it not experimental music anymore.


Great point.

New topic  Closed
Topic Posters
All times are GMT
Goto page Previous  123
Page 3 of 3


 

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Similar Topics
Topic Author Forum
Sticky: Music Diaries SuedeSwede Music Diaries
Point of Discussion: "Experiment... RockyRaccoon Music
My band made an EP, please give us fe... toxicteaaa Music
Songs titled " Rock and Roll&quo... bobbyb5 Music
Your Favourite Work(s) of Art? (Anyth... nibbles Lounge

 
Back to Top
Best Ever Albums
Install BEA for an app-like experience.