Rate the Oais albums - Music - Forums : Best Ever Albums

Imbacktosavethuniverse

Gender: Male
Age: 50
Location: Hampton, New Hampshire

Defiently, Maybe- A+
(What's the story) Morning Glory- A-
Be here now- A+ (not a joke)
Standing on the giants- A
Heathen Chemistry- B
Don't believe the truth- B
Dig Out soul- A-

One of my favorite bands.. Shame they couldn't keep it together..

mooseboy101

Gender: Male
Location: Geneva

Never liked any of them, they make better singles then albums.
_________________
sig

Mr. Shankly

Gender: Male
Age: 52
Location: Auburn, Washington

Why don't you ask people if they like the band first before asking them to rate the albums? It's like you're assuming that there will be a lot of people who have the exact same music taste as you. As for Oasis, I have always been completely befuddled by people who have chosen to follow them throughout their career as they are one of the most mediocre bands of all time. You'll find a few devotees here though, I suppose. I've never understood their ongoing fandom.

As for me, I would give their first two albums a B+, and then I like a handful of songs that followed in the years after, but in the 90's, I found many more bands / artists whose music was way more interesting and enjoyable than Oasis. Plus their music was always overshadowed by all the stupid shit the Gallagher brother did and said in the press. Their shtick got old very quickly. Also, I like interesting lyrics, and although Noel Gallagher can write a catchy tune (which he usually shamelessly rips off from one of his heroes), his lyrics are usually terrible or uninteresting, at best.

Imbacktosavethuniverse

Gender: Male
Age: 50
Location: Hampton, New Hampshire

Quote:

Why don't you ask people if they like the band first before asking them to rate the albums? It's like you're assuming that there will be a lot of people who have the exact same music taste as you. As for Oasis, I have always been completely befuddled by people who have chosen to follow them throughout their career as they are one of the most mediocre bands of all time. You'll find a few devotees here though, I suppose. I've never understood their ongoing fandom.

As for me, I would give their first two albums a B+, and then I like a handful of songs that followed in the years after, but in the 90's, I found many more bands / artists whose music was way more interesting and enjoyable than Oasis. Plus their music was always overshadowed by all the stupid shit the Gallagher brother did and said in the press. Their shtick got old very quickly. Also, I like interesting lyrics, and although Noel Gallagher can write a catchy tune (which he usually shamelessly rips off from one of his heroes), his lyrics are usually terrible or uninteresting, at best.

wow.

cartoken
The Seer

Gender: Male
Age: 39
Location: Paris

never really liked them,

Definitely Maybe 65/100
(What's the Story) Morning Glory? 60/100

that's all i can give them

GARY

Defiently, Maybe- F
(What's the story) Morning Glory- F
Be here now- F
Standing on the giants- F
Heathen Chemistry- F
Don't believe the truth- F
Dig Out soul- F
_________________
.
I owe $100,000 and wasted 4 years of my life.

And all I got was this silly hat

.

Polythene Pam

They are pretty rubbish IMO

And to think they are in the top artists is just criminal >_>

Definitely Maybe C
What's the Story Morning Glory? C

Would recommend Blur or The Stones Roses instead

GARY

Polythene Pam wrote:

They are pretty rubbish IMO

And to think they are in the top artists is just criminal >_>

Definitely Maybe C
What's the Story Morning Glory? C

Would recommend Blur or The Stones Roses instead

Yes it sure is criminal. Here are just some of the artists/bands that Oasis is ranked above on BEA.

Doors
Metallica
Neil Young
Miles Davis
Queen
AC/DC
Fleetwood Mac
Stevie Wonder
John Lennon
RUSH
Iron Maiden
_________________
.
I owe $100,000 and wasted 4 years of my life.

And all I got was this silly hat

.

bcaie16

Gender: Male
Location: Toronto

The only song I can stand is Don't Look Back In Anger

Definately Maybe- D-
What's The Story- F
The Rest- F-

mooseboy101

Gender: Male
Location: Geneva

GARY wrote:

Polythene Pam wrote:

They are pretty rubbish IMO

And to think they are in the top artists is just criminal >_>

Definitely Maybe C
What's the Story Morning Glory? C

Would recommend Blur or The Stones Roses instead

Yes it sure is criminal. Here are just some of the artists/bands that Oasis is ranked above on BEA.

Doors
Metallica
Neil Young
Miles Davis
Queen
AC/DC
Fleetwood Mac
Stevie Wonder
John Lennon
RUSH
Iron Maiden

Let's not forget The Flaming lips, Genesis, Sigur Rós, and of course, Nick Drake.
_________________
sig