How would you Weezer fans rate thier albums?

[Imbacktosavethuniverse]

Here's Mine:


Blue album- B+
Pinkerton album- A-
Green Album- B+
Maladriot Album- B
Make Believe album- C
Red Album- A-
Raditude- D+
Hurley- B-

Death to false metal- B

[purple]

I'd rate both Blue Album and Pinkerton A-

those are the only albums of theirs I've heard in full so...

[cartoken]

1. Weezer (blue album) 85/100
2. Hurley 55/100
3. Pinkerton 50/100
4. Weezer (Red Album) 50/100
5. Raditude 40/100

[Hayden]

1. Blue Album - 90/100
2. Raditude - 75/100
3. Pinkerton - 70/100
4. Red Album - 45/100


That's all I've heard from them...
_________________
Submit Your List for BEA's 2023 Film Poll!

[Wombi]

1. Weezer (Blue) 90/100
2. Pinkerton 85/100
3. Weezer (Red) 65/100
4. Hurley 55/100
5. Weezer (Green) 35/100

[Bork]

Raditude - 3.70
Pinkerton - 3.45
Weezer (blue) - 3.40
Weezer (red) - 3.35
Weezer (green) - 3.15

5 is max, although the highest rating handed out is 4.57 (so far).
4+ is a masterpiece, 3.75+ is great, 3.50+ is very good, 3.25+ is good.

[mooseboy101]

Blue Album - 85/100
Pinkerton - 80/100
Green Album - 65/100
Make Believe - 40/100
Red Album - 55/100

Those are the only ones I've listened to.
_________________
sig

[bcaie16]

Pinkerton 95/100
Blue Album 90/100
.
.
.
.
Rest is garbage.

[Applerill]

I'll admit it: I'm an absolute Weezer fanboy. There's not really a single of their albums that I hate, not even Raditude anymore.

The Blue Album: 10 (just about tied with Pinkerton)
Pinkerton: 10 (my favorite album of all time BTW)
The Green Album: 8
Maladroit: 6.5
Make Believe:7.5
The Red Album: 8
Raditude:7.5
Hurley: 7

[Ironic Karma]

The Blue Album: 9.0/10
Pinkerton: 9.3/10
The Green Album: 5.9/10
Maladroit - 7.4/10
Make Believe - 4.4/10
The Red Album - 5.0/10
Raditude - 2.4/10
Hurley - 7.3/10