BSAT Round #1: Iron & Wine vs. Julia Holter

[nutso42]

BSAT

Round 1


Iron And Wine

Captain: pearljamer


Julia Holter

Captain: revolver94

[revolver94]

Thumbnail. Click to enlarge.

Link



Link


wherever she is "in" she is the best!

[Guest]

Both artists are fine but not much more for me. If I had to be stuck on an island with only one of their discographies though it would be Holter, so my vote goes to her.

[SuedeSwede]

[Precedent]

Iron & Wine



Julia is pretty good, but Sam delivers highs that she's yet to touch.

[GeevyDallas]

i'd allow julia to live on my face and raise her family there, it would be a pleasure to be her home

[Guest]

I think Iron and Wine's music is boringly predictable.

I feel Holter's music is merely unengaging, it's just kinda there.



So Holter it is, for giving me a little less boredom.

[Silver]

Iron and Wine's first album is fine, but most of his other stuff I find pretty dead. I've only heard Loud City Song from Holter, but I think that album is fantastic and I'd take it over the entire Iron and Wine discography.

[meccalecca]

Holter is just getting started. i think she'll continue to improve, and she's already gone beyond Sam Bam.

[MrFrogger]

Holter makes fantastic, sprawling music, Iron and Wine just feels very safe, and similar to dozens of other artists.