Proto
by Holly Herndon

Proto by Holly Herndon
Year: 2019
Release date: 2019-05-10
Overall rank: 4,547th   Overall chart history
Average Rating: 
72/100 (from 70 votes)
  Ratings distribution   Average rating history
Accolades:
Award Top albums of 2019 (63rd)
Award Top albums of of the 2010s (829th)
Award Best albums of all time (4,547th)

Listen on Spotify SPOTIFY

Log in or create an account to rate this album, leave comments or join the discussion.
eBay
Sorry, no matches on eBay for "Proto Holly Herndon".

  My favourite store:  

Listen & Collect

Complete your collection or upgrade your listening experience.

Holly Herndon bestography

Proto is ranked 2nd best out of 5 albums by Holly Herndon on BestEverAlbums.com.

The best album by Holly Herndon is Platform which is ranked number 4241 in the list of all-time albums with a total rank score of 342.

Holly Herndon album bestography « Higher ranked (4,241st)
Platform
This album (4,547th)
Proto
Lower ranked (16,634th) »
Movement

(N.B. Bestographies include all albums by an artist (and their variations), but do not include albums ranked outside the top 100,000).

Listen to Proto on YouTube

Loading content from YouTube...

Proto track list

  Track ratings The tracks on this album have an average rating of 78 out of 100 (all tracks have been rated).

Sort Sort by
#
Track
Rating/Comments

Proto rankings

Proto rankings summary
Overall rank: 4,547th | 2010s rank: 829th | 2019 rank: 63rd  Overall chart history
Calculated from aggregate positions across 60,000 charts (2 million album rankings). Click to see how the rankings are calculated (Last updated: 4 hours ago)

Proto collection

Showing all 10 members who have this album in their collection

Proto ratings

Average Rating: 
72/100 (from 70 votes)
  Ratings distribution Average Rating = (n ÷ (n + m)) × av + (m ÷ (n + m)) × AV
where:
av = trimmed mean average rating an item has currently received.
n = number of ratings an item has currently received.
m = minimum number of ratings required for an item to appear in a 'top-rated' chart (currently 10).
AV = the site mean average rating.

Showing latest 3 ratings for this album.  | Show all 70 ratings for this album.

Sort Sort by
RatingDate updatedMemberAlbum ratingsAvg. album rating
 
15/100
 !
10/12/2026 04:39 Proto  Ratings distribution  4,52833/100
 
75/100
 !
07/11/2026 04:04 Exist-en-ciel  Ratings distribution  16,96170/100
 
80/100
 !
09/01/2025 19:55 mttr-in-plc  Ratings distribution  19688/100

Rating metrics: Outliers can be removed when calculating a mean average to dampen the effects of ratings outside the normal distribution. This figure is provided as the trimmed mean. A high standard deviation can be legitimate, but can sometimes indicate 'gaming' is occurring. Consider a simplified example* of an item receiving ratings of 100, 50, & 0. The mean average rating would be 50. However, ratings of 55, 50 & 45 could also result in the same average. The second average might be more trusted because there is more consensus around a particular rating (a lower deviation).
(*In practice, some albums can have several thousand ratings)

This album has a Bayesian average rating of 72.2/100, a mean average of 70.6/100, and a trimmed mean (excluding outliers) of 72.2/100. The standard deviation for this album is 15.4.


Please log in or create an account if you want to be able to leave a rating

Proto favourites

Showing all 3 members who have added this album as a favourite

Proto forum mentions

This album has been referenced 16 times on the forums, Explore the wider forum discussion to see what members have said about it.
“What album are you listening to? (cont.)”
View post →

“I think utilizing AI in the mixing/recording process isn't the worst thing in the world, particularly with recent sound-isolation technology, but I don't particularly appreciate it (from a behind-the-glass standpoint). Entire songs/albums though? I think it would be a good stand to bar it. This is…”
View post →

“What album are you listening to right now?”
View topic (11 mentions) →

View all forum mentions

Proto comments

Showing all 2 comments |
Top Comments First | Newest First | Positive Sentiment First | Longest Comments First
(Showing comments with any number of votes. Manage Profile)
Rating:  
60/100
From 09/11/2019 14:08 | #242464 | TOP COMMENT Vote up your preferred comments and the comments with the most votes will be flagged.
I loved Holly Herndon's "Platform" and it's true that the San Francisco musician amazed her entourage with her experimental music blending technology and organic. Four years later, she recurs in this approach with her new audacious album called "Proto". Holly Herndon created an artificial intelligence called Spawn designed to react to human singing and to mix the voice of the choir with its own digital singing. It's science fiction! And I think this album really sounds like a science experiment and not a real album. It's science that Holly Herndon tries to infuse. It focuses on theories, the impact of new technologies on current music. Surely one of the craziest records this year but not necessarily one of the easiest to listen to.

6/10
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) · 1
Log in to reply
Rating:  
70/100
Probably very avant-garde, but it is mainly composed of non-descript electronics. Can't figure out the structure or what was hoped in the way of achievement.
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) · 0
Log in to reply
Anonymous
What do you think of this album? Join the conversation!.
The top-voted comments get featured on our charts, Album of the Day, and the site newsletter.

Log in or create an account to rate this album, leave comments or join the discussion.