Pink Elephant
by Arcade Fire

Definitely expected more, this sound is so tired at this point

Album Rating: 71.75
(574/8)

Arcade Fire (PE - CAN - May 25) - Pink Elephant

09.05.2025

A long, long way from their best but it does have some reasonable tracks. It's not as bad as people are making out.

1.Arcade Fire (PE - CAN - May 25) - Open Your Heart Or Die Trying 66
2.Arcade Fire (PE - CAN - May 25) - Pink Elephant 76
3.Arcade Fire (PE - CAN - May 25) - Year Of The Snake 72
4.Arcade Fire (PE - CAN - May 25) - Circle Of Trust 74
5.Arcade Fire (PE - CAN - May 25) - Alien Nation 67
6.Arcade Fire (PE - CAN - May 25) - Beyond Salvation n/a (66) n/a
7.Arcade Fire (PE - CAN - May 25) - Ride Or Die 67
8.Arcade Fire (PE - CAN - May 25) - I Love Her Shadow 75
9.Arcade Fire (PE - CAN - May 25) - She Cries Diamond Rain n/a (67) n/a
10.Arcade Fire (PE - CAN - May 25) - Stuck In My Head 77

Ranked in order:

* Arcade Fire (PE - CAN - May 25) - Stuck In My Head 77
* Arcade Fire (PE - CAN - May 25) - Pink Elephant 76
* Arcade Fire (PE - CAN - May 25) - I Love Her Shadow 75
* Arcade Fire (PE - CAN - May 25) - Circle Of Trust 74
* Arcade Fire (PE - CAN - May 25) - Year Of The Snake 72
* Arcade Fire (PE - CAN - May 25) - Ride Or Die 67
* Arcade Fire (PE - CAN - May 25) - She Cries Diamond Rain n/a (67) n/a
* Arcade Fire (PE - CAN - May 25) - Alien Nation 67
* Arcade Fire (PE - CAN - May 25) - Open Your Heart Or Die Trying 66
* Arcade Fire (PE - CAN - May 25) - Beyond Salvation n/a (66) n/a

I have listened to it twice but can find nothing to remind me of the glories of their earlier releases.

I was a big fan from the beginning. And also Reclector was amazing. But after that? Hum! But this pink one is a pretty surprise to me. A new band would get 4 or 5 stars. But Arcade Fire is not popular by the media. And Win is not a nice man. Oh Regina🥰 Still a very good album.

How far they have fallen pt. II

From LebowskiRams 05/12/2025 18:48 | #308966

Despite some shimmering instrumentals and a decent idea to go psychedelic, this is Arcade Fire at their most vapid and lifeless.

Pink Elephant shows that they can dye themselves whatever color they want, they're simply a colorful shell of their former selves.

From Cargusbralem 05/12/2025 14:24 | #308965 | TOP COMMENT Vote up your preferred comments and the comments with the most votes will be flagged.

Pleasantly surprised with this one! I thought the last couple of albums signified the band's downfall, but it feels like things are picking up again here. I really enjoy the different musical palettes, whether it’s the ambient droning intro being countered by the lo-fi indie title track, or the more Reflektor-style arrangements. It’s an enjoyable and consistent listen overall.

From hoyquarlow 05/12/2025 13:57 | #308964 | TOP COMMENT Vote up your preferred comments and the comments with the most votes will be flagged.

Good album, certainly better than their last two. I like the album is shorter and a bit more minimalist, it's better like this, as long as songs are good - which they mostly are. Only the last song is kind of a filler though.

Pretty sure if this album was made by a new, unknown band it would have had rave reviews. But because it's an album made by the "sexual misconduct guy", every critics says it's poop.

This comment is beneath your viewing threshold.

From ExTeaSea 05/10/2025 01:27 | #308918 | TOP COMMENT Vote up your preferred comments and the comments with the most votes will be flagged.

I dunno, I don't get the hate, it's pretty cool. I like when artists try something kinda risky.