Arcade Fire

I just don't really vibe with late 90s-early 00s alternative. I know a lot of people do, but I have to be honest with myself when I rate these artists.

First four albums were about the best thing going during that time, but they started smelling their own farts at some point.

From BozoTyrannus 06/28/2025 18:43 | #309757

Three great albums, one mediocre album, three terrible ones.

I like them, but how did they get so high on this website?

My personal 'Arcade Fire' ranking albums :

1- Funeral (2004) => 86
2- Neon Bible (2007) => 81.4
3- We (2022) => 81.1
4- The Suburbs (2010) => 79
5- Reflektor (2013) => 76.5
6- Everything Now (2017) => 73.3


If I had to create a 'Best of Arcade Fire', it would be made of 18 tracks :

- Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels) (2004) => 90
- Neighborhood #2 (Laïka) (2004) => 95
- Neighborhood #3 (Power Out) (2004) => 85
- Crown of Love (2004) => 85
- Wake Up (2004) => 95
- Rebellion (Lies) (2004) => 90
- In the Backseat (2004) => 85
- Keep the Car Running (2007) => 85
- Intervention (2007) => 90
- Ocean of Noise (2007) => 85
- No Cars Go (2007) => 90
- The Suburbs (2010) => 85
- Ready to Start (2010) => 90
- Modern Man (2010) => 90
- Afterlife (2013) => 85
- Everything Now (2017) => 85
- Put Your Money on Me (2017) => 85
- The Lightning I & II (working together) (2022) => 90

Firts four albums are good, the first one is amazing, But something went wrong after Reflektor.

They've made some solid albums and songs but they haven't been releasing very good albums as of recently. They also probably shouldn't be in the top ten.

Incredible band with an incredible discography. Few groups have a better first 4 albums

Better than VU?!

How is this the 8th greatest band in the world, I dont use the word overrated too much but this is taking it too far.