CLOSED Forum Regulars' Power Rankings 2: Elliott Smith

[rayword45]

Now that I've finally listened to From A Basement On The Hill (and holy crap did this put me in a shitty mood)

Elliott Smith
Either/Or (This is objectively better I think than self-titled but I prefer the broken sound of the self-titled)
Figure 8
From A Basement On The Hill
XO
Roman Candle
New Moon

[scottrosemeyer]

Hell of a difficult request, but I can't let this slip from me.

1. Roman Candle
2. Either/Or
3. Figure 8
4. Elliott Smith
5. XO
6. From a Basement on the Hill
7. New Moon (By far I have heard the least)

I'll probably disagree with this list tomorrow. All of its good.

[CubaZed]

I DIDN'T FORGET ABOUT THIS I SWEAR. I'm going to post my rankings from the albums I have listened to and then post the results after I'm done tallying. If anyone still wants to post their rankings, now is the time to do it.

Either/Or (tied)
Elliott Smith (tied)
Roman Candle
Figure 8
XO

Hell of a hard ranking though

[CubaZed]

CLOSED

Thanks to everyone participated (and again sorry for the delay, it won't happen next time I swear). Without further ado here are the results.

7:New Moon


6:From a Basement on the Hill

Thumbnail. Click to enlarge.

5:Figure 8
First Place Votes: 1

Thumbnail. Click to enlarge.

4:Roman Candle
First Place Votes: 3

Thumbnail. Click to enlarge.

3:XO
First Place Votes: 4

Thumbnail. Click to enlarge.

2:Either/Or
First Place Votes: 4.5

Thumbnail. Click to enlarge.

1:Elliott Smith
First Place Votes: 7.5

Thumbnail. Click to enlarge.

[Mercury]

Wow! I'm actually surprised by that number 1. I thought it would be 2nd or 3rd. Generally Either/Or is his most recognized masterpiece. XO number 3 was kind of expected, was hoping it would be 2 or, as impossible as it may be, 1st.

Good job again, Cubazed.
_________________
-Ryan

ONLY 4% of people can understand this chart! Come try!

My Fave Metal - you won't believe #5!!!