American Pie (studio album) by Don McLean

Shortlisted for album of the year at the Grammys in 1973. The winner was Concert For Bangladesh by George Harrison & Friends

From NowhereMan 12/19/2024 12:00

Always had a soft spot for this cut. The melodies are always enjoyable.

This is a great album to listen to on Feb. 3rd "The Day the Music Died"

Quizás con el tiempo ha caído en el olvido, pero este es, al menos para mí, uno de los mejores discos de los 70.

one of my earliest purchases its survived the ups and downs of my music catalogue to endure as a personal favorite

A really consistent album that I thoroughly enjoyed. Certainly the album is dominated by its opening title track which should be familiar to most. However, there are some other very good tracks on this album including the magnificent Vincent. Some brilliant narratives told in some beautiful songs.

Unlike so many, I'm not in thrall to the title track. But I think Vincent is just sheer beauty, and there are others here along that line. Maybe doesn't stand up to being the classic it is regarded as, but a gentle listening experience none the less.

brilliant music. Every song is great even if some are definitely better than others.

Clearly underrated album. I agree with @arialblue. American Pie and Vincent are extraordinary, heartbreaking, and the rest is pleasant enough.

Before giving this album a proper whirl, I was of a similar opinion to several reviewers here - other than the title track and Vincent, a little insipid. But when I gave it a proper chance, I came to realise that it's actually a brilliant listen. I found myself thinking it was tailing off a little towards the end, but then checked myself as the tracks were still really good, just not quite as good as those which had come before. Don McLean's guitar playing is superb, and his vocals, whilst at their peak on the two aforementioned tracks, are excellent throughout. Don't be put off by the threat of the title track - the rest of the album is worthy of your time too.
Best tracks: American Pie, Vincent, Crossroads, Winter Wood, Everybody Loves Me, Baby.