Lulu
by Lou Reed & Metallica

From VictorVale 04/21/2023 17:48 | #296271

Genial, precisa ser reconhecido devidamente.

I think this gets a slightly bad rap. It sounds like it should. The heavy riffs & rhythms of Metallica over the junkie (ex-junkie) poetry lyrics of Lou Reed. The tracks which go on the avant-garde jazz rock tangent are the ones that let the album down. But overall it's not a bad collaboration. The second CD of it (last 4 tracks) being the better by far. (Edited)

From phantom1305 03/06/2019 11:51 | #233129 | TOP COMMENT Vote up your preferred comments and the comments with the most votes will be flagged.

Not my favorite work by either artist, but as time goes on I'm finding I appreciate this album more and more. I often hear this album referred to as "so bad it's good" and sure it's fun to talk about, but if you're looking to enjoy it in an ironic way you're going to find yourself bored really fast.
I think I like what this album represents more than I appreciate the album itself. The combination of thrasher metal and folk really challenges the lister's perspective on music. It's nearly a deconstruction of both genres by Metallica (arguably one of greatest figures in metal) and Lou Reed (who even as far back as the Velvet Underground really set out to push the limits of music and gain a reaction from his audience.
After poking around other albums that are considered so bad they're good, you remember these artists are at least competent and that challenging doesn't necessarily equate to bad... take Captain Beefheart for instance.
Past its initial shock, LuLu is a somewhat boring listen from start to finish. I don't think it's either artists' highest point, but it's a far cry from their lowest. But wow, would I have loved to see footage and outtakes from these recording sessions. I imagine the artists had tons of fun making it.
Also while it doesn't affect my rating at all, it's worth noting that this was Lou Reed's last studio recording before his death. Also, Bowie (an avid Velvet Underground fan even before Bowie's rise to fame) praised this as Lou Reed's greatest achievement. So it's interesting to think of this album as in the context of Lou Reed's final artistic statement. Good or bad, I don't want LuLu to be forgotten. (Edited)

From nitomano 04/14/2018 07:04 | #212844

Una interesante combinación de grandes músicos y el resultado es caótico. En mi opinión solo parece que Metallica improvisa mientras que Reed lee las letras de las canciones que para mi punto de vista son malas. Otro punto en contra es la duración de las canciones, son extremadamente largas y sin cambios de ritmo, solos etc. lo que las hace más tediosas de escuchar.
En conclusión es un mal álbum aunque no tan malo como muchos lo hacen ver.

Old Lou Reed + Laughable Lyrics + Bad Metallica Riffs = No Good (Edited)