I'll be honest. it's hard to pick a "winner" here but I think that The Beatles just have it. they are both quality albums with The Replacements just falling short of a being classic album. I think that the Beatles is.
The Beatles has some great tracks on it. Across The Universe, Let It Me, the arrangement of Maggie Mae is great. I Me Mine and For You Blue are very good tracks and then you have The Long And Winding Road (One of my favourite Beatles songs) and Get Back.
Not particularly familiar with the film but the album stands on it's own.
With regards to The Replacements, I loved this album when it came out and still do although, as mentioned previously, I feel that it is one or two track shy of being a classic album for me but I still love it.
The previous two albums had been good but not great, this was Paul Westerberg's peak of his career although I do love a couple of his solo albums.
They were never quite punk and never quite rock but fell in that gap between the two occupied by others like R.E.M, The Wipers and the many Bob Mould fronted projects. A seriously good album
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
albummaster
imacgill
