From Her To Eternity
by Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds

From Jboy56 05/19/2024 07:16 | #303605

TOo dark, too noisy, too much....

It´s garbage. Really !!!

This rating is for the original lp and not the embarrassing cd re release. Normally bonus tracks are placed after the original lp so the album can be heard as intended. In their wisdom the brain surgeons at Liberation decided to plonk The Moon is in the Gutter and In the Ghetto in between the end of side one and the start of side two thus ruining the listening experience of one of the most idiosyncratic records I've heard. Lyrically one of the most poetic and powerful albums ever released and a fair eye opener when I bought it as a 14 year old. From Her to Eternity will never be everyone's cup of tea but for the fans it's unforgettable.

Nick cave's debut album. I still think it ranks amongst his best. It's the nearest any of his solo records get to the sound of the birthday party. Opener, a cover of Leonard Cohen's avalanche, is a superbly brooding start to a dark and creepy album. Best of the tracks are the Mark Twain inspired, saint huck, cabin fever , the title track, and the excellent closing track, a box for black Paul. I think my favourite is, well of misery, which has some wonderful backing vocals . Stunning. A brilliant first album from a man who's never made a bad record. Great.

From badseed 04/13/2015 03:18 | #139403

One of the most jaw-dropping experiences you'll ever have. Punk meets the blues as Cave wails and shrieks through some of the oddest, most devastating music you'll ever hear. The title track is among Cave's best songs, while "A Box for Black Paul" features haunting, vivid metaphors referring to Cave's previous band The Birthday Party.

Favorite tracks: "From Her to Eternity", "A Box for Black Paul", "Saint Huck", "Avalanche"

From Arthurknight 10/11/2014 23:03 | #124161

nick caves most intense album, and that makes it so amazing

From Decurso 08/10/2014 18:59 | #119175

Kind of eerie....but honestly you would have to be psychic to spot any sign of greatness in Cave based on this album. It is not at all bad, but it's a fledgling first effort from an artist who was still very much in a developmental stage.

From timtooky 04/09/2014 15:11 | #108867

This comment is beneath your viewing threshold.

From paladisiac 12/02/2013 21:29 | #96100

Good, dark, somewhat-abstract alt rock. My rating reflects the cd reissue including "in the ghetto" (65) and "the moon is in the gutter" (55) (but i'm not considering the 1987 version of the title track).

From covecove 08/27/2013 17:55 | #84624

This has to be the Bad Seeds' darkest recording in their entire career which automatically makes it the darkest recording ever (or close enough). That darkness doesn't comes in terms of mood, atmosphere or lyrics but as a whole concept of bizarre and raw sounds scattered around on the floor whic Cave picked up to craft the strangest and most uncomfrtable record ever and yet still sound masterfully focused and ahead of its time. This is the closest that somebody has been to replicate that unique feeling of wonder and enchantment of Beefhart's Trout Mask Replica but it still feels much as its own...