Y
by The Pop Group

This album is extremely unique and I highly doubt we will get an album similar to this again. It falls into the Beefheart style of music with more of a punk twist and I think it works really well. The majority of the album sounds completely out of control and insane but the basslines are really well thought out and gives us a spine for the record. If you focus on the basslines it is difficult not to love this album as you feel like you are riding a wave while chaos ensues around you. The quality of performances as well is very high such as the guitars, drums, sax and vocal. All of these combine to create this controlled chaos which creates an interesting and experimental listen for us. Overall, while a couple songs are a little weaker and could be cut, most of the album is brilliant and well worth a listen just to experience an album as out there as this one is. (Edited)

From Jboy56 01/10/2022 15:54 | #279012

Made me mad... And defines the Zeitgeist perfectly (2022)

From Sandinistar 12/08/2018 04:58 | #226492 | TOP COMMENT Vote up your preferred comments and the comments with the most votes will be flagged.

Some punks who listened to Beefheart and CAN and decided what they could use was more anger and funkier basslines. It's never quite clear what you're listening to, but it is a deeply emotional and at times terrifying album. Impossible to be imitated, much less surpassed. Genius or insanity? You tell me. All I know is I love it. (Edited)

From awesomness425 10/31/2015 16:45 | #152333

Everything about this album is messed up
I fucking love it.

From Nobodyisemo 10/28/2015 03:01 | #152153

What the fuck? Holy shit. Whoa hell. Umm, huh. Pretty cool. Structure is not. Sounds and textures are everywhere and they're weird. Listen to it, definitely. It might redefine music for you.

From babyBlueSedan 03/26/2015 21:45 | #137887

An album that is certainly unique, and there are definitely some enjoyable parts. But the worse parts really drag the album down, and altogether it's too meandering and minimalist for me to enjoy. I don't hate it as much as similar albums (Deceit and Suicide come to mind), but it's still not something I can envision myself listening to again. I guess overall this type of post punk is just too artsy and high brow for me.

From SuedeSwede 06/12/2014 13:41 | #114317

I'm not sure I can dig this. Which is weird, because I love Suicide. Hey, it has its moments, but it feels like it's trying to be dark and brooding, and there's moments that come across as incredibly cacophonous, but the high moments made it a decent listen.

From NickVolos 03/29/2014 20:19 | #108045

Scroll down...further down...Find meccalecca's comment & read it. You were warned!

From Graeme2 12/20/2013 14:03 | #98171 | TOP COMMENT Vote up your preferred comments and the comments with the most votes will be flagged.

Still not sure what to make of this. Sounds like loads of people playing different songs at once. Quite mental. Beyond good and evil is a great track mind. File alongside trout mask replica, which is the only other album that springs to mind when I hear this. I don't think they quite created what they wanted. The rhetoric is better than the execution. PiL probably hit the mark better with metal box. (Edited)

From Trickington 09/01/2013 15:54 | #84965

I don't think I understand it yet. There's a few good songs on there and some nice piano playing mixed in with some of the bat shit insane recordings, but other than that, it's hard to get into it.