Top 100 Greatest Music Albums
by BorderFreeAndrew

From AvalancheGrips 05/13/2024 00:21 | #303488

here, I'll give some substantive criticism: this chart is boring. And I wouldn't go this deep but this user here gave my chart, which I've put a lot of effort into over the years, a 20 rating. No comment, no effort to criticize, just a 20. And I will make it political I don't care; Andrew is a conservative, anti-woke old man and old conservative men don't have good taste. There's nothing interesting, experimental or cutting edge here. It's old, boring singer-songwriters. Nothing here is from the last 20 years, a time period I would argue is rich with new ideas and experimentation especially in the last 5 years. Even in the 1970s and 80s there was a vast amount of bands trying new things, who loved and respected music so much that they wanted to make it better and more interesting, but Andrew here doesn't like that because he's uncurious and bland. Stagnant. And this is why this website fails while AOTY and RYM don't, because it's full of Andrews. I give a 15 instead of a 5 solely because of the inclusion of Bowie, Clube De Esquina, Nina Simone, and Exuma, I like all of them

Addendum: This is my final point and I will not press this any further after this message because I honestly can't believe I'm going this far. Your comment on my chart literally proves my point; you had nothing substantial to say about my chart, and actually you yourself were being pretty petty (also I can't tell if you were being racist with the whole "ain't got no taste in music no mo. I takes it back to the old skool" line, really corny btw, but whatever, seems you love Key and Peele so maybe youre not racist). Look I love being petty too, but I'll try to be more sympathetic because I know you don't have many years left. You sound really mad there and I think I struck a chord, but i'm gonna be constructive.

I don't think it's hipster or pretentious to sincerely love certain albums (I don't know what you specifically think is hipster but I'll put Black Country, New Road- Godspeed You!, and Swans as examples). I have comments written in earnest there not because I think it makes me look cool or hip to like these albums, but because I've put a lot of thought into these works and have grown real love for them. I don't know how you can say I'm shallow when I have basically novels written about my favorite albums. I also don't know how some of these fit into a "starter kit" considering I've loved most of these albums for many years now. You sounded really dumb there. See, I already know I'm young and cool, my music taste has nothing to do with that. I just try to engage critically with the music I listen to, whether I love it or not, maybe that's too far-left, soy, hipster of me.

And look, I actually don't care if you don't like my taste, plus your rating did literally nothing to my overall average, people love my shit. Again, I've put a lot of thought into my chart and have a lot written, it's 6 years old at this point and has gone through many iterations. But here you go randomly giving me a 20 when you have nothing written on yours. I say imperatively, if you have the time, put comments on your chart to show you care about the music on your chart, you could prove me wrong by having any interesting analysis on the albums you claim to love. (Edited)

From DeusExMackia TOP 100 COMMENTER 02/08/2025 18:09 | #307492

Your taste is very hard to love, and yet love it I do. This list is so out of character for this site and therefore all the more better. 85/100 is an arbitrary way of saying "I don't agree with you but I support your every decision". Kate Bush forever. (Edited)

From ForegroundNoise 02/18/2019 21:16 | #232160

Nice chart, especially love the Brigitte Fontaine and Roy Harper picks!! Some notes would make a great addition

Although we both favour the 70's & 60's above every other decade - and rightfully so - we have no albums in common & only 6 artists in common. Despite that, I really liked your chart - it just goes to show what a remarkably diverse world we enter when we journey through modern music and how music & lyrics impact on us in mysterious ways! (Edited)

Keep going to 100 some here i'm not familiar with but ill check out