Top 10 Greatest Music Albums by Extremerockerfan882

From junodog4 11/26/2012 05:41

Take the compilation out, and this is decent.

A few great picks here, and as good as 1 is, you could probabbly replace it with Abbey Road, the White Album, Revolver, or Sgt. Pepper.

To start with a best of is quite strange. But you should try to increase the number of albums in your chart. It can be a great chart if you vary the artists. But Beggars Banquet is a great choice :)

From Mr. Shankly 07/01/2009 04:41

Granted, I'll admit I've broken this rule with soul artists, but I don't think when it comes to the Beatles, you should be allowed a best of compilation in your #1 spot. Keep listening and keep digging, but stop playing it so safe. There are some more obscure gems out there waiting for you.

From maxxy 06/24/2009 02:39

Poor #1 choice, but not too bad. All quality albums.

From 1234567890 06/06/2009 12:28

Its pretty good, last 3 are the best 3.

Here's a tip: putting in too few albums limits your opportunities to include your little twists, your top ten should consist of the core "best ever" albums.
As for your choice of using a compilation, it is generally frowned upon to use a best of collection for artists who were around during the record era, as it eliminates what makes certain albums so great, no filler and a great flow. The Beatles singles that were not put on any album are great but you should aim to look for the best pieces of work as whole, not a sampler platter of the records. I will, though complement you on some of the choices namely Beggar's Banquet and Nevermind the Bullocks.