The Milk-Eyed Mender
by Joanna Newsom

The Milk-Eyed Mender by Joanna Newsom
Year: 2004
Release date: 2004-03-23
Overall rank: 697th   Overall chart history
Average Rating: 
80/100 (from 377 votes)
  Ratings distribution   Average rating history
Accolades:
Award Top 10 albums of 2004 (10th)
Award Top albums of of the 2000s (109th)
Award Top 1,000 albums of all time (697th)

Listen on Spotify SPOTIFY
Sorry, no matches on eBay for "The Milk Eyed Mender Joanna Newsom".

  My favourite store:  

Listen & Collect

Complete your collection or upgrade your listening experience.

Joanna Newsom bestography

The Milk-Eyed Mender is ranked 3rd best out of 7 albums by Joanna Newsom on BestEverAlbums.com.

The best album by Joanna Newsom is Ys which is ranked number 176 in the list of all-time albums with a total rank score of 8,290.

Joanna Newsom album bestography « Higher ranked (362nd)
Have One On Me
This album (697th)
The Milk-Eyed Mender
Lower ranked (817th) »
Divers

(N.B. Bestographies include all albums by an artist (and their variations), but do not include albums ranked outside the top 100,000).

Listen to The Milk-Eyed Mender on YouTube

Loading content from YouTube...

The Milk-Eyed Mender track list

  Track ratings The tracks on this album have an average rating of 84 out of 100 (all tracks have been rated).

Sort Sort by

Track pick (1000 - 100 votes) Top-rated track as rated by BestEverAlbums.com members.

The Milk-Eyed Mender rankings

The Milk-Eyed Mender rankings summary
Overall rank: 697th | 2000s rank: 109th | 2004 rank: 10th  Overall chart history
(Calculated from aggregate positions across 60,000 charts (2 million album rankings). (Last updated: 3 hours ago).
Filter Filter
Sort Sort by
YearSourceChartRankRank Score
2026mianfeiTop 100 Greatest Music Albums2/10093
2026 PurplepashTop 67 Music Albums of 200442/672
2026 DommeDamianTop 23 Music Albums of 20044/234
2026 HaydenTop 100 Music Albums of the 2000s34/10013
2026 Patman360Top 98 Music Albums of 200420/984
2026 eclabTop 100 Music Albums of the 2000s6/10019
2026 giulius06Top 97 Greatest Music Albums32/9767
2026 LedZepTop 99 Music Albums of the 2000s61/998
2026 arthurbittencourtTop 100 Music Albums of the 2000s4/10019
2026JohnnyoAlbums of the year 2004 by Prefixmag2/100 -
2026jtrizzle35Top 65 Music Albums of the 2000s4/6519
2026UnliveableWiltsTop 100 Greatest Music Albums40/10058
2026 baystateoftheartTop 52 Music Albums of 200419/523
2026 DommeDamianScaruffi Best Albums of 200418/63 -
2026 sszwalbenestTop 100 Music Albums of the 2000s9/10018
2026 cestuneblagueTop 100 Music Albums of the 2000s8/10019
2026 imimesisTop 100 Music Albums of the 2000s25/10015
2026 covecoveTop 100 Music Albums of 200411/1005
2026HyggevinylTop 54 Music Albums of 200440/541
2026Exist-en-cielTop 100 Music Albums of 20043/1005
Total Charts: Help The total number of charts that this album has appeared in. 331
Total Rank Score: Help The total rank score. 2,481
You can include this album in your own chart from the My Charts page!

The Milk-Eyed Mender collection

The Milk-Eyed Mender ratings

Average Rating: 
80/100 (from 377 votes)
  Ratings distribution Help Average Rating = (n ÷ (n + m)) × av + (m ÷ (n + m)) × AV
where:
av = trimmed mean average rating an item has currently received.
n = number of ratings an item has currently received.
m = minimum number of ratings required for an item to appear in a 'top-rated' chart (currently 10).
AV = the site mean average rating.

Showing latest 5 ratings for this album.  | Show all 377 ratings for this album.

Sort Sort by
RatingDate updatedMemberAlbum ratingsAvg. album rating
 
85/100
 !
04/19/2026 14:25 Exist-en-ciel  Ratings distribution  15,32770/100
 
100/100
 !
04/02/2026 05:00 colabunga  Ratings distribution  62280/100
 
50/100
 !
01/11/2026 18:17 brent13  Ratings distribution  2,14367/100
 
80/100
 !
01/01/2026 02:42 Scrabbler  Ratings distribution  28876/100
 
50/100
 !
12/29/2025 17:47 mutant  Ratings distribution  1,67156/100

Rating metrics: Help Outliers can be removed when calculating a mean average to dampen the effects of ratings outside the normal distribution. This figure is provided as the trimmed mean. A high standard deviation can be legitimate, but can sometimes indicate 'gaming' is occurring. Consider a simplified example* of an item receiving ratings of 100, 50, & 0. The mean average rating would be 50. However, ratings of 55, 50 & 45 could also result in the same average. The second average might be more trusted because there is more consensus around a particular rating (a lower deviation).
(*In practice, some albums can have several thousand ratings)

This album is rated in the top 1% of all albums on BestEverAlbums.com. This album has a Bayesian average rating of 79.9/100, a mean average of 78.7/100, and a trimmed mean (excluding outliers) of 80.1/100. The standard deviation for this album is 15.9.


Please log in or create an account if you want to be able to leave a rating

The Milk-Eyed Mender comments

Showing latest 10 comments | Show all 17 comments |
Most Helpful First | Newest First | Positive Sentiment First | Longest Comments First
(Only showing comments with -2 votes or higher. You can alter this threshold from your profile page. Manage Profile)

Rating:  
90/100
From 01/12/2023 14:00 | #292751
A beautifully crafted debut album by Joanna Newsom that demonstrates so much potential and promise which makes me extremely excited to explore future releases. The harp is at the centre of this album with it softly guiding us from song to song with immense delicacy and beauty. The way she plays it is absolutely stunning and it elevates every track to the next level. This also makes it such a unique listen and quite a personal album which allows us to connect to her so easily and feel involved with the music. Lyrically, it is great as well with there being a lot to explore for us as she goes into the themes of love and heartbreak with the use of intelligent wordplay. The vocal might not be for everyone but to me it sounds beautiful and it adds an extra edge and punch to the delivery of her words. Overall, this is such an emotional and powerful record that is packed full of quality and musical brilliance which makes me extremely excited to revisit this album and discover more of her discography.
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) | 0 votes (0 helpful | 0 unhelpful)
Rating:  
85/100
From 07/15/2021 17:58 | #271641
An unusual debut for the Nevada born harpist/multi-instrumentalist. Not often does one hear "pop harp." This is a groundbreaking exploration of music and Newsom gives her audience plenty to appreciate through her music and lyrics.
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) | 0 votes (0 helpful | 0 unhelpful)
Rating:  
60/100
From 02/07/2021 15:23 | #265960
Lately I've been making some baby steps towards Ys. Sadly, no luck with this one yet.
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) | 0 votes (0 helpful | 0 unhelpful)
From 02/06/2017 22:00 | #185024
Yes, the vocals are slightly more grating in comparison to her subsequent work, but what remains is a magical journey through different cycles of love and loss, expertly and profoundly written by Newsom herself. A great debut.
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) | 0 votes (0 helpful | 0 unhelpful)
From 08/03/2016 21:37 | #172214
First album I listened to from her and I'm instantly hooked. This is fantastic. Never has an album had such an emotional impact on me first time listening, the music is beautiful, her voice the same. Wonderful.
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) | +2 votes (2 helpful | 0 unhelpful)
Rating:  
95/100
Joanna Newsom's debut album. The milk eyed mender, is a fascinating and quirky acoustic record, with some stunning songs. Newsom is obviously a huge talent, a Joni Mitchell for the millennium, and like Mitchell, Newsom is totally unique, she's both knowing and playful and innocent sounding all at the same time. Bridges and balloons, gets things of to a great start and the record switches from one superb moment to another. This side of the blue, sprout and the bean, and, the book of right on, are all excellent, but best track is closing cut, clam,crab,cockle,cowrie, it's absolutely beautiful. A brilliant album. I'm in love.
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) | +4 votes (4 helpful | 0 unhelpful)
From 01/01/2016 18:00 | #155499
My favourite album from her .. maybe her most accesible, but this one pleased me more than Ys and Have One On Me.
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) | 0 votes (0 helpful | 0 unhelpful)
Rating:  
100/100
From 09/17/2015 01:32 | #149900
I'm completely blown away! Where has Joanna Newsom been hiding all my life!
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) | +1 votes (1 helpful | 0 unhelpful)
Rating:  
35/100
From 01/15/2014 18:14 | #100709
This comment is beneath your viewing threshold.
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) | -18 votes (2 helpful | 20 unhelpful)
Rating:  
95/100
Joanna Newsom is the best thing to happen to me since Bob Dylan.
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) | +5 votes (5 helpful | 0 unhelpful)

Please log in or create an account if you want to be able to add a comment

Your feedback for The Milk-Eyed Mender

Anonymous
What do you think of this album? Leave a comment or rate it below.
The top-voted comments get featured on our charts, Album of the Day, and the site newsletter.
Log in or create an account to rate this album, leave comments and join the discussion.