Top 100 Greatest Music Albums
by AvalancheGrips

This chart is always a work in progress. I generally hate this website as I think the opinions of most people here are very antiquated and basic. However, it does allow me to write basically an infinite amount on my chart unlike other sites, so that is what I will use it for.
There are 35 comments for this chart from BestEverAlbums.com members and Top 100 Greatest Music Albums has an average rating of 91 out of 100 (from 72 votes). Please log in or create an account to leave a comment or assign a rating.

View the complete list of 60,000 charts on BestEverAlbums.com from The Charts page.

Share this chart
Collector's summary Help The maximum rank used by the Collector's Summary is configurable from your profile (top 100 is currently selected). Log in or create an account to discover the great albums that are missing from your music collection!
Sort Sort by
Try as I might, I cannot bring myself to unseat this record since I have listened to it back in 2017. Its narrative, performances, and style are simply too iconic and too high quality. It is a bulletproof, unimpeachable record. Every track is feels like a vignette into the life and mind of Kendrick Lamar. But this vignette vibe does not subtract one bit from the cohesiveness of this album as every single track flows seamlessly into the next. Not only does every track flows musically into the next, but they flow thematically, weaving a fabric so vivid and lively. Just as each each distinct piece of a mosaic might be unique, ultimately adding up to a greater piece, To Pimp a Butterfly never lingers on a single sound or voice, resulting in a collage that depicts such a clear picture. A picture of institutional and interpersonal exploitation, abuse, prejudice and ultimately overcoming the pressures of fame and racism through fearless and shameless artistic expression. At its core, this album is about the commodification and exploitation of black art and artists by predominantly white executives. I think this concept applies to actors, athletes, musical artists, authors, and artists in general. This record shows how even fame, even wealth and celebrity cannot extricate you from racism. In America, race is always the first thing people perceive of you. And even as someone who has experienced success, you will never be a part of the big boys club. The entire front half of the album builds this narrative in tracks like "King Kunta", "Institutionalized", "u", and "For Sale?" Slowly, however, the album becomes more celebrational of black heritage and existence. It stands strong on tracks like "Alright", "Complexion (A Zulu Love)", "The Blacker the Berry", and "i".

While each songs constructs this narrative of exploitation, abuse, fame, and ultimate resilience, Kendrick recites a poem, which gets one line further each time it is recited. On "Mortal Man", he finally gets the chance to finish the poem. It is a perfect summarization of the themes of this record. It's about putting aside differences through a mutual respect and uniting on a single front, presumably against the forces that continue to exploit and abuse Black Americans.

This album represents an optimism that unfortunately has not been able to come to fruition. The darker parts of this record have aged really well as capital exploitation has reached an all time high. A year after the release of this record, Donald Trump would be elected president and begin an age of rabid hatred and oligarchical seizure of control. Every day, news is released that hurts the global working class; people of color get the worst of it. ICE raids, mass deportations, hate crimes, and outright bigotry are some of the defining characteristics of the last ten years and will continue until we behead this beast of capital. I don't think Kendrick Lamar is an avid communist, but his message of putting aside differences and finding a mutual respect to fight on a unified front is so powerful and yet so naïve. It's a difficult world we live in, so I am glad that people like Kendrick Lamar are able to create such earnest expressions of self and soul.

To Pimp a Butterfly is the first Great American Record.
[First added to this chart: 01/12/2018]
Year of Release:
2015
Appears in:
Rank Score:
29,338
Rank in 2015:
Rank in 2010s:
Overall Rank:
Average Rating:
Top rated album (89/100 - 2328 votes)  89 (2,328 votes)
Comments:
This is the most delicate and intricate record of its time and possibly ever. It feels like you are interrupting when you listen to this record. Its use of silence is not new, but is unmatched. This record is a meeting of forces, a confluence of disparate streams that combine into a soft, yet steady and strong-flowing river. Its distinct elements are this: Floating Points, a progressive electronic producer, who has before created masterpieces like "Silhouettes", a jazzy, almost post-rock, and progressive electronic epic- Pharoah Sanders, a spiritual jazz legend, who has created masterpieces like the albums Karma, Black Unity, and Love In Us all, and who collaborated with Alice Coltrane on her spellbinding Journey in Satchidananda- and finally, The London Symphony Orchestra, who contribute to the most powerful and confounding (in a positive way) movement of the entire record. A climax that soars and climbs and rips through time and sound until giving way back to the silence and delicateness. I feel like an inchworm in a lush flowerbed when I listen to this record. Each repetition of that motif is singular. An individual and unique string of notes repeated possibly a hundred times over the course of the record. It is never the exact same instruments twice nor order of notes played. It mixes harpsichord, glockenspiel, Rhodes keyboard, piano, and vibraphone. The synth soundscapes are perfect, in fact, every sound is perfect. In timbre, note, and placement, there are no mistakes on this record. And yet, it feels imperfect and organic. Sanders's saxophone is perfect in every moment and beautifully accompanies the soft baroque instrumentation and electronic embellishments. It's subtle, but I love that Sanders takes a seat as the London Symphony Orchestra has their moment. And their special section of this album cannot be overshadowed or overstated. Movements 6 through 8 are possibly the greatest ~20 minutes of sound put to recording.

It has taken me some time to be able to call this a perfect record, but I cannot think of a word that describes this album more completely. It is simply without flaw, in a way that does not remove its character and soul. It is a testament to the talent, skill, and passion each contributor possesses. It is a divine project that cannot be replicated, as if the stars aligned for this record to be completed, like a cathedral, or the mountains that carve up the Earth.
[First added to this chart: 07/26/2021]
Year of Release:
2021
Appears in:
Rank Score:
3,016
Rank in 2021:
Rank in 2020s:
Overall Rank:
Average Rating:
Comments:
A set up I tend to appreciate is getting a bunch of the best musicians together and improvising in studio and just seeing what results. This is the strategy seen on the Swans trilogy, Songs: Ohia's "Farewell Transmission", Talk Talk's later albums, and is most successful on Miles Davis's jazz fusion records. Davis's previous record, In a Silent Way, started his electric period, and in just one year, he had already reached its zenith with Bitches Brew.

The performances are so tight while also feeling free-flowing. The sheer feat of being able to lead up to ten musicians in creating some of the densest and most complex grooves is astounding. It's also hard to believe that this album took just three days to record. I love the image of the musicians gathered in a circle with Miles in the center, each player watching Miles intently and waiting for his next cue.

This record feels like a deconstruction of music. Its as if none of the parts were meant to fit together, like every musician is playing to their own song. It's incongruent and collapses in on itself as each track goes and goes and lingers. Songs will start out simple and soft and slowly the drumming gets harder and each strum of the guitar is stronger and the keyboards are louder and the groove grows more intense. It sounds like a record from another planet. It is an insanely ambitious recording at over an hour and a half long. Despite this gargantuan runtime, it feels like a cool breeze, like it's not task at all to listen to the entire thing.

It's hard to overstate just how important this record is. I do not think a band or musician, or even person, is worth the time if they do not consider this album as one of their most influential records.
[First added to this chart: 07/26/2021]
Year of Release:
1970
Appears in:
Rank Score:
8,863
Rank in 1970:
Rank in 1970s:
Overall Rank:
Average Rating:
Comments:
[First added to this chart: 11/03/2021]
Year of Release:
2003
Appears in:
Rank Score:
3,820
Rank in 2003:
Rank in 2000s:
Overall Rank:
Average Rating:
Comments:
Tim Hecker creates a record by sampling live recordings and warping them until they sound alien, otherworldly. There is no album like this, even Hecker's other works. Though there are certainly real, discrete instruments deep under the manipulations performed by Hecker, it's impossible to tell what they are. To call this album an ambient album undersells how active and percussive it is. Ambient has the connotation of passivity, as if the music is allowing the world to happen to it. Virgins is completely in the opposite; it is a motive force. It expends kinetic energy, even in its calmest moments. Each track drives forward into oblivion with such density and textural richness. It's as if you are standing next to a star; it's the soundtrack to a supernova. This album feels like it could go for an eternity, and every burgeoning civilization succeeding the last will understand its cultural context and power and significance.

The album cover is the most striking aspect of this record. It is a statue of the Virgin Mary covered by a blanket during restorations at Duomo di Milano. Its figure seemingly alludes to the infamous Hooded Man photograph taken at Abu Ghraib prison. To me, the music on Virgins is the perfect allegory for the events that unfolded at that prison. Hecker takes beautiful woodwinds, piano, and organ lines and deconstructs them, creating something alien and seemingly not of the Earth. Compare this to the treatment of the prisoners of Abu Ghraib, who were continuously humiliated, tortured, and molested, "deconstructed", by the staff. In performing these acts, the guards created an environment and situation that is utterly alien to most normal people. The images from this time at the prison are too outlandish and barbaric to even seem real. They treated the prisoners as if they were not human, and were thus making themselves less human in the process. The act of othering people to this extent is itself inhuman. By alluding to these events with a photograph of a statue of the Virgin Mary, he attributes her purity and her grace to the prisoners of Abu Ghraib. Taking one step further, he is juxtaposing the events of the Bible, the Passion of Jesus specifically, to the torture of the prisoners. Combining this juxtaposition on the album cover with the music creates such a cohesive narrative without a single word spoken.

Virgins is a work of absolute genius. It is Hecker's perfection of craft, the zenith of his career.
[First added to this chart: 05/12/2024]
Year of Release:
2013
Appears in:
Rank Score:
1,387
Rank in 2013:
Rank in 2010s:
Overall Rank:
Average Rating:
Comments:
To release a work of such subtlety and lushness in an era of bombast and overindulgence in culture is nothing short of the bravest endeavor in music history. At the time, the indie scene was Sonic Youth, Pixies, The Smiths, and Dinosaur Jr., among others. These hardly exerted the same delicateness that Talk Talk was conjuring on Spirit of Eden. In this sense, Spirit of Eden is a singular piece, seemingly coming from nowhere. It is practically an anomaly, like a strange signal from the farthest reaches of outer space. Its use of silence and deliberate pauses is something I do not believe had been employed since Miles Davis and other jazz acts in the 1970s. You can hear the studio in this record, as if you are standing right next to the drum kit or the piano. Each instrument is mixed with such clarity and purpose. Though the tracks were largely improvised and pieced together in post-production, it's hard to shake the feeling that each note, sound, and movement was a premeditated ordeal, perfectly planned far in advance of recording. However, the improvisational approach does allow the record to feel free floating. It is hard to predict where the album will go next, especially upon first listen. This feeling contributes beautifully to the air of mystery that this record has. It feels to me like this album was created by a strange forest god that humans can never know the intentions of, a being neither benevolent nor malevolent.

To me, it is not very important that Talk Talk was a new wave band when they first started. They could have started with The Colour of Spring and this album would still be its own revolution. It is so forward and progressive that it is hard to believe that it exists at all, even today, almost 40 years later.
[First added to this chart: 01/12/2018]
Year of Release:
1988
Appears in:
Rank Score:
10,215
Rank in 1988:
Rank in 1980s:
Overall Rank:
Average Rating:
Comments:
The world will end by An Evil Heat. We have forsaken this Garden of Eden. We sucked its blood like mosquitoes and polluted its air with noxious refuse. One day He will come down and right our wrongs.

This album is a cyst about to burst with pure anger, rage, and fury. It's like being branded with a hot iron. This record is completely unbounded. Eugene Robinson's vocals are like a babbling baby; the voices scheme like a murder of sentient, talking crows. This album, fittingly, sounds like the deepest depths of hell or the surface of the sun or like being part of an insurgent militia in Libya, each scenario exudes "an evil heat". Though this is a noise rock album, not once is it grating or difficult to listen to. That is not to say that it is not a challenging album; the average listener would likely not appreciate this record. However, it is so well mixed and the guitar effects are so refined that it is a joy to listen to for someone used to noisy music. Most tracks reach climaxes that feel like a bed of sound. Additionally, the song writing is so strong. Each track is quite dynamic, as they start soft and low and gradually get more hectic, louder, and more deranged.

"Shine (Glimmer)" closes with a starkly contrasted sound to the rest of the album. While the other eight tracks are like pressure vessels about to explode, the closer is a sprawling landscape of open desert. The guitars layer upon each to create an almost delicate and soothing soundscape. The drums are a consistent beat throughout the entire 30 minute runtime, only pausing at the center of the track and then resuming in the latter third. The vocals on this track are relatively calm and even more gibberish than ever before. Though the guitars lay a soft, soothing bed of sound and the drums maintain a constant groove and the vocals have subsided on this track, this is easily the most evil track on the album. It's all held together with great tension, and there is an underlying sense of dread that it will all snap at once and all the world will end.

This album will strike even the most steadfast atheist with the fear of God.
[First added to this chart: 03/21/2025]
Year of Release:
2002
Appears in:
Rank Score:
142
Rank in 2002:
Rank in 2000s:
Overall Rank:
Average Rating:
Comments:
8. (=)
Germany Can
[First added to this chart: 08/16/2020]
Year of Release:
1973
Appears in:
Rank Score:
4,648
Rank in 1973:
Rank in 1970s:
Overall Rank:
Average Rating:
Comments:
Ghost Tropic is the most mysterious record I have ever experienced. The first riff of the album, the beginning of “Lightning Risked It All” is immediately captivating. It’s deep and raw and rich and brooding and very subtly driving and rhythmic. Quiet and minimal, it slowly builds, with percussion that sounds like empty beer bottles and guitar playing harmonics in your left ear. Jason Molina’s voice is despondent and tragic; his lyrics are cryptic as usual. It grows in intensity until Molina practically yells “Lightning Standing!/ Drained and like us/ deeply risked it all.” It is the most powerful moment on the record and contains so much complexity. Each element working together brilliantly; each element adding its own personality and flare to the moment in such a way that it would spontaneously jerk a tear right out of your eye.

Lyrically, its richness and complexity is astounding; what Molina is able to do with so few words is breathtaking. It’s about the struggle of being on your own. Even after all this listlessness and state of being lost, there are “still no guides,” after all “it’s not a generous world/ It is a separate world”. Life can never be so easy. It foreshadows the opening line of “Ring the Bell,” on Songs: Ohia’s succeeding record, Didn’t It Rain, “Help does not just walk up to you.” You are ultimately alone in this world and that aloneness, not loneliness, can feel just like the album cover, a black infinite void. It’s as though we are all stumbling through a dark forest with our arms out grasping for someone to take our hands. The pivotal line, which I cannot shake from my mind (“Lightning Standing! Drained and like us, deeply risked it all”), is so reflective of the human experience. Though we are alone and in this void, distant in outer space from one another, we crack the darkness with our strikes of lightning, risking it all with a show of blue and purple lights. With this lightning bolt, we light our own way forward. We live our lives earnestly and in doing so reveal parts of ourselves and risk pain and scrutiny. We create art and poetry and music and make career moves and purchases and investments. Each moment we are floating delicately between oblivion and pure bliss. It's all incapsulated in this one gargantuan but subdued and restrained moment. It lasts but one second.

“Body Burns Away” faces death; the void returns with a different mask. There is nothing more alienating than death. We all face it, but in it we are completely alone. Death makes of us what it wants (“I am an empty page to you”). It’s a horrifying journey; to it, you can only give “the fool’s look,” you can only be dumbfounded as you face it. The way we process death is irrational, because there is no way to process rationally unexistence. Molina tackles it relatively intelligently. He sees it as a deal to be made and a transformation. Lightning returns, but this time it is a binding force. Death is the deal we all made when we were born and the “binding lightning” will one day come, and when it does “your body burns away.” Death will leave your body in a forever changed state that is irrevocable, much like a branch is burned down to cinders.

The two interlude tracks are the grounding base of the record. There are both ghastly instrumentals with tropical bird calls fronting them. They are touchingly serene and almost certainly gorgeous in their plumage, but their calls are also haunting and alienating. It reminds me of a video I saw of the last member of a species of bird calling out for a mate only to be met with despairing silence. Even though there are many birds in these samples, it’s hard to shake that feeling of loneliness on these tracks. The simple and pained instrumentals are heightened in their dreariness by the birds’ calls. The meaning behind the name of the record, and these two tracks, is made more apparent by their sound. We live in a Ghost Tropic. It’s bleak and depressing and haunted, alienated and isolated, and the Earth itself is mostly tropical, covered in empty forests. The world is lively and always moving, but do humans really have a grasp on their own faculties, or their emotions? Molina answers with a resounding “No.”

“Not Just a Ghost’s Heart” is the wounded climax of the album. Its rich guitar licks, twinkling piano, and unique sputtering synth are a distinct sound from the rest of the record. There isn’t a notable progression throughout this 12 minute track; it maintains an atmosphere like a haunted, dusty attic. The instrumental is reminiscent of Talk Talk’s “The Rainbow” where the deeply textured guitar and piano exchange places and a steady, unfettered rhythm accompanies them. In both tracks, the space between the instruments takes center stage, and Molina does it just as brilliantly and with just as much subtlety and restraint as the British post-rock band.

The defeated and forlorn finale is “Incantation.” The guitar vibrates deeply and close to the ear, you can hear Molina’s fingers with each change of the chord. The synthscape is simply tragic. It’s like a choir of ghosts. As the music begins to fade, Molina’s voice comes in again “Worked it out with me.” On this track, Molina is the titular ghost, as his voice is notably more distant from the microphone and seems to come in and out like a transient spirit. The synth closes out and fades and repeats the same ghostly notes, like a record left spinning.

The sparseness of this record is unlike any other album, even within the Songs: Ohia discography. Jason Molina focused more on the texture of the instruments on this record, obviously pulling from some post-rock influences. This focus on sound drives the emotion behind each track. You can almost feel the sadness baked into the instruments. Each track is its own brilliant tragedy. Each not just tinged with blackness, but coated in it. This record rewards the patient tremendously, and those willing to unpack this intricate and veiled album will be surely compensated.
[First added to this chart: 03/15/2025]
Year of Release:
2000
Appears in:
Rank Score:
285
Rank in 2000:
Rank in 2000s:
Overall Rank:
Average Rating:
Comments:
Remain In Light is the most forward thinking album of its time. Up until the release of this record, the culture was not capable of creating something like this, and afterwards, the culture was not willing. The 1980s are a culturally dead decade. Neoconservatism was the guiding ideology and experimentation was at an all time low in culture. This is the decade of Top Gun, hair metal, shopping malls, and slop, slop, slop. Even on this website, albums from the 1980s are heavily underrepresented in the top charts. It's because, honestly, music was boring that decade. It started with Joy Division, This Heat, Talking Heads, Dead Kennedys, Glenn Branca, and the middle years are almost completely devoid of anything interesting or innovative. People are afraid to admit that the 80s were culturally dead because of nostalgia but the difference is night and day when viewing the decade through the achievement of this record.

Talking Heads were slowly working their way up, their debut has a lot of solid tracks, but is generally just okay. They lost some footing with their sophomore release, More Songs About Buildings and Food, which is again just fine. All the while, they are sustaining a groovy and eccentric sound that set them apart from other acts. They achieved a bit of greatness with Fear of Music. They started to incorporate Afrobeat influences that gave a lot of the tracks more complex grooves. "I Zimbra" is very simple, but the groove is undeniable. My favorite is "Cities" because they find such a pocket in that track, and it's their best so far. Another highlight is "Life During Wartime" which also has a killer beat. David Byrne's vocals as well improve on this record and become more charismatic. I would say that the three aforementioned tracks foreshadow Talking Heads' direction for their next record the most.

Remain in Light can be seen as split into two records. There's a side with some of the most complex and layered dance rock even 45 years later, and a side with dark and atmospheric bouts of insanity. Regardless of where a track lies, one can be assured that it will have cutting edge Brian Eno production and electrifying and borderline uncomfortable performances from David Byrne. The Afrobeat influence is turned up to 100 on this record as it is apparent in every single track. The first four tracks have polyrhythms that a listener could try and decode for hours. There are guitar solos that will have your jaw dropped realizing that this record came out just a decade after the Beatles.

I used to write-off the latter four tracks because they were not as invigorating as the first half, but that was a complete mistake. There would be no Remain in Light supremacy without the latter half. It serves as the backbone of this record. Can you imagine an entire record of "The Great Curve"? It would be unbearable. One can tell that the band was on something different during the production of this record because there is nothing in their discography even remotely similar to "The Overload."

It really does seem that Talking Heads were striving for not just greatness on this record, but legendary status, because every quirk or quality that makes this album special feels like a deliberate choice made by the band or Brian Eno himself. It is a shame that culture sided with hair metal and U2 as opposed to records like this in the 80s, because a future where a record like this is the zeitgeist is one where poverty is nonexistent and war has stopped.
[First added to this chart: 01/12/2018]
Year of Release:
1980
Appears in:
Rank Score:
26,693
Rank in 1980:
Rank in 1980s:
Overall Rank:
Average Rating:
Top rated album (87/100 - 2319 votes)  87 (2,319 votes)
Comments:
Total albums: 100. Page 1 of 10
Don't agree with this chart? Create your own from the My Charts page!

Top 100 Greatest Music Albums composition

Top 100 Greatest Music Albums chart changes

Biggest climbers
Climber Up 46 from 68th to 22ndChemist
by The Necks
Biggest fallers
Faller Down 1 from 22nd to 23rdPlowing Into The Field Of Love
by Iceage
Faller Down 1 from 23rd to 24thThird
by Portishead
Faller Down 1 from 24th to 25thWhat's Going On
by Marvin Gaye
TitleSourceTypePublishedCountry
Top 100 Greatest Music Albumsjuanr1096Overall chart2025
Top 100 Greatest Music Albums pjohnsongolfOverall chart2024Unknown
Top 100 Greatest Music Albums StanleykurosawaOverall chart2023
Top 100 Greatest Music Albums scwrlwOverall chart2026
essential dank memes for all you plebs HazeyTwilightCustom chart2015
PPV Overall RankingbeaCustom chart2021Unknown
Top 100 Greatest Music Albums PinkZeppelinOverall chart2024
Top 100 Greatest Music Albums flyingcitrusOverall chart2019Unknown
Top 100 Greatest Music Albumsgravityrider999Overall chart2019

Top 100 Greatest Music Albums similarity to your chart(s)


Join 50,000+ music fans


Join now It only takes a moment.

Top 100 Greatest Music Albums ratings

Average Rating: 
91/100 (from 72 votes)
  Ratings distribution Help Average Rating = (n ÷ (n + m)) × av + (m ÷ (n + m)) × AV
where:
av = trimmed mean average rating an item has currently received.
n = number of ratings an item has currently received.
m = minimum number of ratings required for an item to appear in a 'top-rated' chart (currently 10).
AV = the site mean average rating.

Showing latest 5 ratings for this chart.  | Show all 72 ratings for this chart.

Sort Sort by
RatingDate updatedMemberChart ratingsAvg. chart rating
The chart has been updated since this rating was assigned   
100/100
 !
06/20/2026 15:58 jhuik  Ratings distribution  17389/100
The chart has been updated since this rating was assigned   
80/100
 !
03/05/2025 15:51 slatsheit  Ratings distribution  2888/100
The chart has been updated since this rating was assigned   
50/100
 !
02/08/2025 18:13 DeusExMackia  Ratings distribution  13382/100
The chart has been updated since this rating was assigned   
80/100
 !
02/08/2025 11:03 SomethingSpecial  Ratings distribution  1,08986/100
The chart has been updated since this rating was assigned   
20/100
 !
05/13/2024 13:57 BorderFreeAndrew  Ratings distribution  11882/100

Rating metrics: Help Outliers can be removed when calculating a mean average to dampen the effects of ratings outside the normal distribution. This figure is provided as the trimmed mean. A high standard deviation can be legitimate, but can sometimes indicate 'gaming' is occurring. Consider a simplified example* of an item receiving ratings of 100, 50, & 0. The mean average rating would be 50. However, ratings of 55, 50 & 45 could also result in the same average. The second average might be more trusted because there is more consensus around a particular rating (a lower deviation).
(*In practice, some charts can have several thousand ratings)

This chart is rated in the top 2% of all charts on BestEverAlbums.com. This chart has a Bayesian average rating of 90.8/100, a mean average of 89.9/100, and a trimmed mean (excluding outliers) of 91.5/100. The standard deviation for this chart is 12.6.


Please log in or create an account if you want to be able to leave a rating

Top 100 Greatest Music Albums favourites

Showing all 6 members who have added this chart as a favourite

Top 100 Greatest Music Albums comments

Showing latest 10 comments | Show all 35 comments |
Most Helpful First | Newest First | Positive Sentiment First | Longest Comments First
(Only showing comments with -2 votes or higher. You can alter this threshold from your profile page. Manage Profile)

Rating:  
100/100
From 06/20/2026 16:00 | #314985
I love the idiosyncracy off this chart, and I appreciate that you've put a lot of thought into some of the comments. You obviously love music as much as I do. Any list of best ever is always intensely personal, and this is a great example of that.
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) | 0 votes (0 helpful | 0 unhelpful)
Rating:  
80/100
From 03/05/2025 15:51 | #307883
I can't stand some of the stuff in your top 20, but the list is so eclectic and thoughtful that I have to give it some credit.
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) | 0 votes (0 helpful | 0 unhelpful)
Rating:  
20/100
From 05/14/2024 23:15 | #303528
I think you're missing my point. Don't add soul and jazz just because I suggested it. Don't bow to social pressure at all. Add something that you authentically love, but that won't win you points with the snobs. Yes, some of your choices aren't commonly seen on BEA charts. But they fit in with the general snob-core tone of the rest of your list. It's ok to like those albums. But do you like anything that wouldn't be snob-approved? Do you have any guilty pleasures? Something that might get ridiculed by the music elitists? Add THAT! Then I would respect your list a lot more. It could be any genre. And from any era. Doesn't matter if it's boomer or zoomer. (why are you obsessed with generational distinctions?) And the genres I suggested were just picked at random. It could be ska, or blues, or K-pop, or Hindustani classical music (hmm, that one might actually be a logical next step for a Swans fan).

And when I suggested mainstream pop, what I meant was popular/Top 40 music that isn't indie-approved. Yes, Gorillaz and Outkast are popular, but when I say 'mainstream pop' I mean stuff like Bruno Mars, or Harry Styles, or Elton John, etc. For example, a recent Chart-of-the-Day had multiple John Mayer albums on it. Personally, I never much liked John Mayer, and I still don't. But I respect that user's bravery and guilelessness. Because they had a mix of critic-approved and critic-panned stuff, I found their list much more interesting and individualistic than yours. Of course, that's just my opinion. And it shouldn't hurt your feelings that not everyone loves your kind of Top 100.

As for my own Top 100, you're free to hate it. But when you call it "run-of-the-mill Rolling Stones magazine boomer bullshit", it shows you have no idea what you're talking about. My chart has 2 albums each from Julian Cope, Lisa Germano, and SFA. And NONE of them have ever shown up on any RS chart. RS barely knows they exist. In fact, well over 50% of my chart is stuff that RS ignored or shat on. Is there some overlap with RS charts? Sure. It would be odd if there wasn't. But it's minimal. Your chart has plenty that's also on Pitchfork's charts. So if I called it "run-of-the-mill Pitchfork zoomer bullshit", I'd have a much stronger case. As for adding a hip-hop album from the last decade to my Top 100, if BEA allowed us a Top 300, you would see a few: Kendrick, Little Simz, Danny Brown, Tyler maybe. I like those albums a lot. Just not enough to supplant the ones I already have in my Top 100. So I guess you'll have to keep thinking I'm a racist. Oh well. I'll try not to lose any sleep over it.
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) | 0 votes (0 helpful | 0 unhelpful)
From 05/14/2024 13:53 | #303518
@BorderFreeAndrew most of these criticisms fall completely flat to me because there are albums on my chart that I've literally never seen on others (e.g. Lift to Experience, Nicolas Jaar, Elza Soares, even Low is rare on this site). Meanwhile, your chart is the same boring run-of-the-mill Rolling Stones magazine boomer bullshit. 64 albums from the 60s and 70s is sickening to me, where's the diversity? Another funny thing is I've never used RYM, you're yelling at clouds dude. I really think that you're projecting your resentment of the young RYM hipsters onto me and that's really sad man. Sure, I'll put more soul and jazz on my chart, I've been meaning to, but I want you to put one (1) hip-hop album from the last decade on yours or I'll still think you're racist. Also, you're saying I'm anti-pop? My favorite album is from one of the most popular artists of the last decade; Gorillaz, Jessie Ware, Stevie Wonder, and OutKast are all pop artists. I know you've listened to tons of music from the last decade so where is it?
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) | 0 votes (0 helpful | 0 unhelpful)
Rating:  
20/100
From 05/13/2024 02:32 | #303492
What, no Glenn Miller? No Dinah Shore? Where's the Bing Crosby and Doris Day records? I takes it back to the oooooooold skool:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3d1phCytJyg&ab_channel=Key%26Peele

But seriously, stop being so shallow and petty just because someone isn't impressed with your Beginning-Hipster's-Starter-Kit of a Top 100. BTW, I actually saw your #9, Lift To Experience live in Austin, TX back in 2001 when nobody cared who they were. I'm such an "old conservative man" who's "uncurious and bland".

Edit: You want me to say something substantial about your chart? Sure, no prob. First off, the fact that you'd think my light-hearted comment above could be "racist" illustrates your problem: You're demonstrating a worldview that is narrow and short-sighted. And this shows in your chart. As someone who you're certain is "uncurious and bland", I've heard almost all your chart entries. And I like most of them. The reason I don't like your chart is because it's too stylistically samey and predictable. I don't care whether it's newer or older stuff. I'm just tired of seeing the same RYM-core over and over again (since you brought them up). I like charts that surprise me. I like charts that introduce me to something I hadn't already heard about, or remind me of something I'd forgotten. Your chart does that only once: I'd never heard of Ciśnienie, so I may check them out now. Most importantly, I like charts that show diversity (you know, cuz I'm such a "racist"). Where is the funk? The jazz? The folk? Even the inclusion of some mainstream pop would be a nice indication that you're not self-consciously trying to impress the anti-pop snob brigade. As for classic soul, you've got one token Stevie Wonder album. "Racists" like me like a lot more classic soul and R&B than that. And the Swans are fine. But 3 of your top 6? I don't doubt that you sincerely love these albums. But this suggests to me that you need to expand your horizons and explore a wider variety of music (both past and present). Your chart makes you seem a lot more "uncurious" than me. I'm not "mad" at your retaliatory comment/rating, or it's blatant ageism. I'm just disappointed at the insecurity it displays ("your rating did literally nothing to my overall average, people love my shit"). Gain the maturity to accept that not everybody is gonna "love your shit" and that's ok.
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) | 0 votes (0 helpful | 0 unhelpful)
Rating:  
95/100
From 05/10/2024 14:23 | #303465
Lots of stuff I don't care for (Swans, Tool), but also lots in common. Love the thought and dedication put into the comments, great chart!
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) | 0 votes (0 helpful | 0 unhelpful)
Rating:  
85/100
From 08/28/2023 10:15 | #298888
A young persons chart only 22 albums from the 60's, 70's & 80's but your descriptions are brilliant so that lifts the chart to 85/100
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) | 0 votes (0 helpful | 0 unhelpful)
Rating:  
90/100
From 02/07/2023 20:04 | #293768
Great descriptions accompanying the entries. Good chart
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) | 0 votes (0 helpful | 0 unhelpful)
Rating:  
90/100
From 02/07/2023 17:33 | #293757
That's a lot of depressing albums. Also, Komm Susser Tod is definitely one of the greatest songs ever!
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) | 0 votes (0 helpful | 0 unhelpful)
Rating:  
100/100
From 10/31/2022 22:52 | #290950
I was right, this thing DOES increase in quality based on fascinating descriptions.
Helpful?  (Log in to vote) | 0 votes (0 helpful | 0 unhelpful)

Please log in or create an account if you want to be able to add a comment

Your feedback for Top 100 Greatest Music Albums

Anonymous
What do you think of this chart? Leave a comment or rate it below!
Log in or create an account to rate this chart, leave comments and join the discussion.